Hello all, 72 hours have passed, and the vote totals are:
6 Binding +1 votes 5 Non-binding +1 votes 0 +0 votes 1 Binding -1 votes 1 Non-binding -1 votes Binding +1 votes from: Andrew Jaquith Juan Pablo Santos Rodríguez Florian Holeczek Harry Metske Dirk Frederecick Janne Jalkannen Non-binding +1 votes from: Michael Gerzabek Christophe Dupriez Jürgen Weber Siegfried Goeschl Luca Gilardoni Binding -1 votes from: Sam Ruby Non-binding -1 from: Ross Gardler Related jspwiki-dev threads: [1], [2] Based on this I understand that the vote has passed, BUT: Some issues have been raised in general@incubator, and 4 people, although they haven't voted -1, felt it would be wise to withdraw the voting until these issues have been fixed, namely: a) making (at least) one apache official release, b) placing an unvoted artifact into distribution c) tidying up the project's incubator site, The first and the second one being showstoppers (JSPWIKI-540) towards graduation. So we need to decide (as soon as possible, in order to translate to general@incubation) if we withdraw the voting or accept it as passed. The only dire consequence would be the need of casting the vote again, once we have made an ASF release, which we have to do anyway: When beginning the [VOTE] thread I stated that 2 releases were made following Apache guidelines, but it turns out that I was mistaken - 2.8.3 and 2.8.4 were released following apache *voting* guidelines, but they were neither distributed the apache way, nor gpg-signed, for instance. So they were more to be considered "Release candidates" rather than "ASF releases". I'm inclined to withdraw + recast community vote, so we go through graduation "the ASF way", from beginning to end, but I don't know which is the general feeling. My suggested steps would be: - turn JSPWiki 2.9.0-svn-9 into 2.9.0-incubating-0 and release it the ASF way - at the same time tide up the project's incubator site (I already have some mock-ups on this) - approve the charter, that is, if there aren't any comments or changes during this week, mark as resolved JSPWIKI-538 - once all the above is complete, recast community vote, and, on approval, proceed with IPMC vote So, what do you think? regards, juan pablo [1] http://mail-archives.apache.org/mod_mbox/incubator-jspwiki-dev/201204.mbox/%3CCAMufup6Yq5oqMw9nQ4JyVR9FOsEvJCO3WFj-1GBY0rgkbvyhSA%40mail.gmail.com%3E [2] http://mail-archives.apache.org/mod_mbox/incubator-jspwiki-dev/201204.mbox/%3CCAMufup6fG8TVS10S5hwsp3VYPKLzGi41519n06pZRfmt-QSChg%40mail.gmail.com%3E
