On Sat, Dec 10, 2011 at 5:12 PM, Louis R Suárez-Potts <[email protected]> wrote: > Regular readers of this list might recall discussions by Khirano, Rob and > others about the fate of the Native Language projects in OOo. I'm not sure > what the outcome was, and a quick browse of archives didn't really enlighten > me, as it seems things were left hanging. > > I'd like to see if we can resolve this issue. A recap: OOo had many > "native-language projects" in which non-coding discussions were in the native > tongue, e.g., Russian, Viet, Brazilian Portuguese, Gaelic(s), and so on. At > any given moment there were about a hundred, and one can see these listed > still at http://projects.openoffice.org/native-lang.html. > > These were non-coding projects but also were designed to provide a path for > contributors to gain both the skills and community respect to gain more power > within the project. They also served as "homes" for a lot of l10n work, > though there was no necessary connection between one and the other. That is, > there could be an l10n effort but no corresponding Native Language project, > and vice versa. > > The projects had their shortcomings. First, I had set them up as *linguistic* > projects so as to maximise the global distribution of any given language's > speakers, and to minimise nationalist claims to any language, which I saw as > potentially limiting. Second, the NL projects did not easily lend themselves > to in-person communication, which, as we all know, is where the real > community action takes place. it was therefore difficult to arrange for > meetings, conferences, outreach programmes, and so on, at least coming from > the NL projects, though there were, of course, signal exceptions, such as > German, or French, where there was already an engaged body and commercial > infrastructure. > > Consequently, over several OOoCons, I proposed and to a degree, put into > action, a skeleton method by which there could be regional modules whose > remit was to do on-the-ground community development. They would be aided by > the central OOo but otherwise they were left up to their own devices. > Raphael's Swiss NGO and community is the best example, but there are others. > The problem here, was that there was in this instance, as in others, scant > attention paid by the corporate overlord, as it did not obviously contribute > to *coding* (and if it had, no doubt other problems and issues would have > been discovered invalidating the effort). > > Now to the present issue. I've written that I would rather focus here, in > Apache land, on coding. But that only opens the door, as it were, to > establishing the very successful Native Language modules either in another > wing of Apache (??) or outside the Apache frame but corresponding to it, so > that QA, a key element of the NL projects, for instance, could be tied in. > Licenses, etc., would have to be harmonised. And I'd also suggest using a > simpler work medium, such as wikis. > > I think some of this is already going on but it is not clear to me *what* is > going on or where. I'm not alone. I have received several pings on this very > question, and I'd like to move on it. >
I can see several models that could work: 1. Volunteers who were previously part of native-language project become members of this Apache project and work on our lists and other infrastructure. We already have the translations under the SGA, I believe. 2. NL volunteers maintain their own external organization and infrastructure and do their primary work externally but occasionally contribute patches to this project. By adopting the Apache license in their own work they make it consumable by AOO and LO. 3. NL projects work outside of Apache, and create localized derivatives of AOO for local distribution. This could be done as a pure volunteer effort or backed by one or more business models. So long as they respect our trademark, this could be a fine choice. Patches might be contributed back to Apache. This is not required by our license, but it makes things easier for them, since they would then have less code to merge in for subsequent release of AOO. You hint at another option. I'm not sure it would work, but let's list it for sake of argument: 4. NL projects are individually proposed as their own podlings. Their charter would be for them to produce localizations of AOO. But they would be autonomous PMC's within Apache, with their own website, mailing lists, etc. The above options could occur simultaneously by different NL groups, according to their interests. There is no right answer. I'm not a big fan of central planning. It is really for these communities to decide for themselves. But if any of them want to know more about Apache and how they might contribute to the AOO project, then send them along. -Rob > cheers > Louis > > PS The majority of the NL projects reformed to constitute LibreOffice. > Because of disparities of license, I suppose harmonisation of effort will be > more difficult, but by no means ought it to be abandoned, if actual > contributors deem it worthwhile. I dislike duplication of effort both as a > project manager and as someone who then has to persuade the bewildered user > that A and B are just alike but one is more equal than the other. > >
