On 13 January 2012 16:35, Joe Schaefer <[email protected]> wrote: > Please do not step down from the PPMC Pedro, > you have done good work here and it is very important > that the PPMC consist of such people going forward.
+1000 > Creating a class of active committers who are not > on the PPMC will not help move this project closer > to graduation. Let's please avoid that circumstance > over what appears to be a simple disagreement. +1000 - there are many difficult things to resolve, we need all perspectives to find the optimal solution. Ross > > > ----- Original Message ----- >> From: Pedro Giffuni <[email protected]> >> To: [email protected] >> Cc: >> Sent: Friday, January 13, 2012 11:31 AM >> Subject: Re: Category-B tarballs in SVN (was Re: External libraries) >> >> --- Ven 13/1/12, Jürgen Schmidt ha scritto: >> ... >>> >>> well that is a valid point that comes into my mind as well >>> when I have read the mails and thought a little bit longer. >>> >>> If that is the only reason than we can move it besides >>> trunk. But that is a technical solution only and it doesn't >>> solve the underlying problem. >>> >>> And what is more important we can't exchange everything now >>> and we can't remove all the features that depends on this >>> category-b stuff. Otherwise the office is no longer useable >>> and we can stop here or can kill the project directly. >>> >> >> I am only asking for the technical solution. I think we >> have discussed sufficiently that replacing this stuff >> is possible but will take time. >> >> I am also not setting any time frame for moving those files. >> beyond that we should do it somewhen before release. >> >>> >>> The whole discussion is not really motivating for project >>> members and of course does not really promote the Apache way >>> or the ASF in general. >>> >> >> I agree it's not very motivating but in my defense it was >> something that had to be discussed sooner better than later. >> >>> >>> So we always have to take Windows into account and on >>> Windows you don't have system libraries for this stuff. >>> >> >> We can do packages of this stuff. It will even save time >> from building over and over again the same stuff. >> >>> So please come back to reality. >>> >> >>> Juergen >>> >>> PS who will go demotivated into the weekend >>> >> >> >> OK, this is something I really didn't intend. This was >> meant to be discussed on a strictly technical level >> without demotivating developers or calling "bloody >> murder" on the project. >> >> I hereby drop *any* claim that we may not be complying >> with any relevant policy. Also to give full assurance >> that I will not be problem to the project I will be >> stepping down from the PPMC so my vote will not be >> binding: I am really only interested in technical >> discussions anyway. >> >> Pedro. >> -- Ross Gardler (@rgardler) Programme Leader (Open Development) OpenDirective http://opendirective.com
