>but you argued SBS wasn't guessing, how can you say it is now? > Compilation tags are calculated based on logical rules - given the presence of differing artist values without an album artist tag, the album is a compilation. That's not guessing, but you consider it to be guessing.
>> I am saying that other applications work the same as SbS - they don't >> assume that missing disk tags are a mistake and guess a disk number on >> your behalf. Instead they get listed in a different grouping. > >not true. some apps ignore the Disc tag for grouping purposes. > And so does SbS if you treat disks as a single album. Always one way or another, but not a bit of both. >if you have a12 track album, and all the tracks have Disc=<blank> >EXCEPT track 10, which has Disc=1/1 then SBS does not do what you [and >i] seem to think it would do. > >we'd think it would put all the tracks except 10 in one album, and 10 >in the other album. but it doesn't do that. it puts 11 and 12 in with >ten. > >that is a bug. > >it is incorrectly assuming 11 and 12 go with 10, and not with the other >9 with which they share the same <blank> value. > Oh sorry, I hadn't understood that from the previous posts - yes, I agree that does seem to be a bug. Phil _______________________________________________ ripping mailing list [email protected] http://lists.slimdevices.com/mailman/listinfo/ripping
