Re: [Sugar-devel] Review Request of GSoC Proposal: Making a Beginner Guide

2018-03-26 Thread James Cameron
Good question, Tony. It is for developers. Self-serving. I don't agree with the project at all. I think it is make-work. It doesn't help the children that Sugar is focused on. None of the mentors have made ongoing or material contributions to our existing developer documentation. Very few

Re: [Sugar-devel] Review Request of GSoC Proposal: Making a Beginner Guide

2018-03-26 Thread Tony Anderson
Is this a 'beginner' in the community of developers or a beginning user of Sugar? Tony On Monday, 26 March, 2018 09:09 AM, Pratul Kumar wrote: Hello, Thanks for the guidance, reviews and feedbacks. Kindly help me with the answer to one of the questions of "You and Community". Question:

Re: [Sugar-devel] Review Request of GSoC Proposal: Making a Beginner Guide

2018-03-26 Thread Pratul Kumar
Hello, Thanks for the guidance, reviews and feedbacks. Kindly help me with the answer to one of the questions of "You and Community". Question: If your project is successfully completed, what will its impact be on the Sugar Labs community? Give 3 answers, each 1-3 paragraphs in length. The

Re: [Sugar-devel] Review Request of GSoC Proposal: Making a Beginner Guide

2018-03-20 Thread James Cameron
Thanks, I've no further suggestions. On Tue, Mar 20, 2018 at 08:45:32PM +0530, Pratul Kumar wrote: > * > Hello, > > Thanks for providing feedback and guiding me in the right direction. > I have worked on it and tried to add them and make things bit more refined. > >

Re: [Sugar-devel] Review Request of GSoC Proposal: Making a Beginner Guide

2018-03-20 Thread Pratul Kumar
Hello, Thanks for providing feedback and guiding me in the right direction. I have worked on it and tried to add them and make things bit more refined. https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Xzn-ub8pBCQuz9-RfltzHqDZqY7uZ2xF77MFP_9fKzw/edit?usp=sharing Kindly have a look at it and if there is

Re: [Sugar-devel] Review Request of GSoC Proposal: Making a Beginner Guide

2018-03-19 Thread James Cameron
G'day Pratul, Thanks for the opportunity to comment on your draft proposal. Your proposal suffers from lack of measurable controls for risks. In general, you've added responses to the risks which are mostly either aspirational, hopeful, or procedural. Some of the responses don't address the

[Sugar-devel] Review Request of GSoC Proposal: Making a Beginner Guide

2018-03-18 Thread Pratul Kumar
Hello Everyone, I am Pratul Kumar, a sophomore at LNMIIT Jaipur. After discussion with community members previously, I have drafted a proposal with well-thought implementation workflow. As I always believe that nothing in this world is perfect, there is always a scope for improvement in