(313) contemporary academic music literature?

2008-04-06 Thread Frank Glazer
i recently read this book
http://www.amazon.com/This-Your-Brain-Music-Obsession/dp/0525949690
and enjoyed it quite a bit, but ideally i'm looking for something
that's a bit less rock and a bit more techno.

can anybody recommend any contemporary (21st century) academic-level
critical writing and/or research on electronic music (or music in
general) that is worth reading?

as an example, i've been meaning to read this piece that martin posted
a few months ago: http://folk.uio.no/hanst/Manchester/ChicagoHouse.htm

not as interested in the cultural or historical aspects either (ala
love saves the day and last night a dj saved my life, both of which
i've read), but feel free to share if something is extraordinary.

please no commentary from those who think music can't/shouldn't be
discussed scientifically.  :)

-- 
peace,

frank

dj mix archive: http://www.deejaycountzero.com


(313) Anyone Still Listen To Sonic Sunset?

2008-04-06 Thread Arturo Lopez
To balance out some of my recent negativity, I'll link to some of my
favorite all-time music, ever.

http://www.sonicsunset.com/

For those of you who aren't familiar, Sonic Sunset was a long-running
radio show here in Chicago that featured some amazing music for many
years.

"Expect deep new sounds alongside timeless classics - from techno,
electro, detroit/chicago house, underground disco machine funk and
weird nu-wave / italo / funk / soul dusties that slipped through the
cracks of time (and fell onto our turntables)."

I have yet to find two people with better music taste, as far as I'm
concerned.  Just scroll down the main page for a few minutes and
review the tracklists for most of the shows. You've got everything
from Funk/Soul music to "Japan" to Kraftwerk to Atkins. It really is
good stuff. The shows usually run along a theme, so you might have a
Larry Heard special or B12 records special, but it's always good
stuff.

Anyway it's brought me many hours of good listening, hope it does for
some of you who aren't familiar with it as well.

-Arturo


Re: (313) minimal suxs like dub

2008-04-06 Thread Arturo Lopez
>From DufDuf:
"ie.  minimal is a technique like dub is a technique"

Disagree. Dub is a genre, Minimal is a genre.  Rhythm & Sound does not
sound like Magda. Yes these things exist along a continuum of sound,
but are certainly at fairly distinct ends, with rather pronounced
sound differences, regardless of how they are mixed together by a dj.
Sure after a certain point we are sometimes splitting hairs, and of
course everything bleeds into different areas, but that's part of the
fun. People can get a little crazy with categorization, but it's a
very useful tool for talking about certain types of music. I can say
"minimal" and people know what I'm talking about for the most part.
It might be hard to classify a single track,  but I'm quite
comfortable using a label to make it easy to discuss a type of sound
as a whole.

"I mean seriously the repetitive complaints I keep hearing
about laptop dj's or copy cat stylists .. and references to
the same single dubstep producer is wearing me thin."

My delete key works just fine on messages I don't want to read.  I
just don't read posts I'm not interested in. I appreciate your
opinions and did find them interesting, but writing in to everyone to
say you are tired of hearing a discussion about something while
participating in that same discussion is weak sauce.

"I've been beat up around here before . for saying this, but
the music is moving.  It's doing new things, in a million
different ways."

I'd say there's plenty new in the performance side of things, but
things aren't moving all that fast on the music-writing side. The
technical ability to spit out a track on ableton in a few hours
doesn't mean it's going to be any good.

"I honestly can't tell any more the difference between house,
techno, techhouse, detriot, minimal or any other genre you
might want to mention."

Splitting hairs again. I don't think it matters at all how you
classify one piece of music, but people like to generalize in order to
make things easier for large groups of music.  There's just too much
music out there. You have to know what area of the dartboard to shoot
for in order to narrow it down to find stuff you like. That, or find
people whose taste you trust in order to suggest things.  I've found
that people on this list for example, generally like the same kinds of
things I like, so I don't care if they call it "X" genre, it gets the
benefit of the doubt.  And for the most part when people suggest music
on here, I don't really hear any discussion at all about genres. It's
'check out this track' or 'check out this mix.'  and I think that's
fine enough for most.

"The current era of music can mean everyone is a producer
in their bedroom.  So what I think we are hearing is people
using the same sort of production techniques across similar
tempo's and styles of music."

It's always been that way, with whatever the current medium/techniques
are. Tape edits to laptops, most people putting out tracks were/are
always using the same sorts of tools at the same time.

"I just think we might get more life out of electronic music
if we start to look at some of the processes going on as the
use of techniques as opposed to genreification followed by
quick dismissal."

I've got no problem genre-fying something that I think is mostly
terrible (or excellent). It's my opinion. Classifying a group of music
that sounds similar is perfectly valid if you are trying to express
your opinion. No, I haven't listened to every 2-step record out there,
but I can comfortably say that I'm not that interested in that music
as a whole. No, I haven't listened to every minimal record out there,
but I've heard enough (and certainly bought a few), to know it's not
something I'm interested in either.

"Currently I am enjoying the sounds classified as minimal
because they provide a group of tracks that enable me to play
sets that contain a lot of spatial texture."

Rock on.

"The use of reverbs, delays, stripped out melody modes and
monotonic rhythms enable out board sample layering and
the use of off beats on the other deck to construct the type
of sets I have wanted too for years."

Well I guess that is the good thing about most minimal records, you
can put 4 of them on at the same time and not really notice it, it
does give you a lot of room. I'll give you that it can certainly make
for a lot of fun mixer work.

"Lets face it every Dj wants to be producer with out having to
do the hard work in the studio."

No.


And from FBK:
"What would make me happy is a bit of funk coming back into the
sound...or at least the acknowledgement of the groove.  The electronic
holy grail is really whatever you want-for me it's to have the music I
love not all sound like it's coming out of the same three boxes from
four people."

Very well put.

-Arturo


RE: (313) Ellen Allien's New Mix: Opinions?

2008-04-06 Thread Odeluga, Ken
I'm sure I've heard a BC track in a Carl Craig set before, possibly his
own! ;-) ... But no actually I think it was 'Infinition'. Seeing as he's
mates with von Oswald & co, seems likely, ditto with the CR stuff. As
for Hood, there's a well known parting of ways in the tastes between the
pair, so neither have probably played each other's records out this side
of 2000, I'd guess.

-Original Message-
From: Paul Kendrick [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
Sent: Friday, April 04, 2008 4:27 PM
To: Toby Frith; kent williams; list 313
Subject: RE: (313) Ellen Allien's New Mix: Opinions?


Im shocked to find Carl Craig #1, but he don't play hood or CR records
in his set, well not for years if he ever did. 

-Original Message-
From: Toby Frith [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
Sent: 04 April 2008 15:45
To: kent williams; list 313
Subject: RE: (313) Ellen Allien's New Mix: Opinions?


The fact that minimal techno is currently seen as "hip" can only be a
good thing. 

More and more people are into labels like Chain Reaction, M-Plant and
Basic Channel than ever before. That ultimately will lead them back to
the Detroit originators. It takes time, but I know for one that it has
transformed the London techno scene.





-Original Message-
From: kent williams [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Sent: 04 April 2008 15:41
To: list 313
Subject: Re: (313) Ellen Allien's New Mix: Opinions?


The one mix I have by Ellen Allien is Fabric 34 and I listen to it a lot
-- both straight through and when individual tracks come up on shuffle.

I think it's high time that we stop using minimal as a dirty word.
Minimalism in its broadest sense has been a revolution in music, not so
much because it has been revolutionary in content, but because it has
demanded a new relationship between the music and the listener. The best
minimal techno is every bit as dramatic and emotional as any
other sort of dance music.   The worst is just boring.   Worse than
that, it's a sort of music that appeals and encourages an audience of
people completely off their faces on drugs.  Give me something with a
little soul and variety anyday!

It's also to separate the music from the scene, and to realize that
slagging on a music/scene when it blows up is as much a hipster
transgression as following that trend.  I was amused last summer walking
around Brooklyn 'hipster' neighborhood last summer; it seemed like
people who, in my shallow evaluation were, in fact, the dreaded
hipsters, were modulating their fashion sense and coiffure to avoid the
dreaded hipster signifiers.

Being hip is too exhausting for me.  You'll always be trying to stay
ahead of curve, and nothing but eternal vigilance will keep you from
staying with something formerly cutting edge, now declasse'.   It's
like surfing -- you want to be in the curl without the wave crashing
over you.  I'm content to like what I like and let someone else sort it
out.

But I digress.  Ellen Allien is usually pretty ace in my estimation. If
one of her mixes sounded a little flat at first, I'd give it a few
listens to sink in before dismissing it.


For all the latest news and comment visit www.telegraph.co.uk.  This
message, its contents and any attachments to it are private,
confidential and may be the subject of legal privilege.  Any
unauthorised disclosure, use or dissemination of the whole or part of
this message (without our prior written consent) is prohibited.  If you
are not the intended recipient, please notify us immediately. Incoming
and outgoing telephone calls to our offices may be monitored or recorded
for training and quality control purposes and for confirming orders and
information. Telegraph Media Group Limited is a limited liability
company registered in England and Wales (company number 451593).  Our
registered office address is: 111 Buckingham Palace Road, London, SW1W
0DT.


Re: (313) Jared Wilson

2008-04-06 Thread /0

http://www.j4r3d.com/willdjpst.mp3
Tracklisting
-
Ruth - Roman Photo
Sensitive - Don't Stop
Jared Wilson - Bangkok Four Seasons Hotel - Blank Artists
Osborne - Wait a Minute
Liaisons Dangereuses - Put Etre - Music Box
Jared Wilson - Office Analogue - Blank Artists
New Order - Everything's Gone Green
Jared Wilson - New Cable Freaks 19303 - Blank Artists
Jared Wilson - This Love - 
TNT - Beat Track 1
Boxcutter - Bloscid - Planet-Mu
Jared Wilson - Dumdahdum
Telex - Disko Moskow - Music Box
Grauzone - Eisbar
Girls at Our Best - Go for Gold



- Original Message - 
From: "Jeffrey Richards" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>

To: "Kowalsky" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; "313" <313@hyperreal.org>
Sent: Sunday, April 06, 2008 11:39 AM
Subject: Re: (313) Jared Wilson



a release he came out with last year:
http://www.discogs.com/release/983148

his website:
http://www.j4r3d.com

he also has a myspace music site under the name Acid
Beard with a bunch of tracks on it.  Good stuff.

I wish he would release a couple of the MySpace tracks
on vinyl.

Jeff

--- Kowalsky <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:


I heard, years ago, an excellent mix recorded by
Jarde Wilson. It
started with an AFX's remix for a Bug tune (run the
place red) and
some great dancehall riddims from that time, then
moves to some great
technoish sounds. I also bought a 12", that i found
lost in a store,
with some great tunes by him, when i was in Paris.
Anyone knows what else he's been doing?







You rock. That's why Blockbuster's offering you one month of Blockbuster 
Total Access, No Cost.

http://tc.deals.yahoo.com/tc/blockbuster/text5.com





Re: (313) Chill Out Rooms

2008-04-06 Thread Southern Outpost
Can't forget the KLF Chill Out, one of my favourites back in the day.


On 4/6/08, Martin Dust <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> Klaas-Jan Jongsma wrote:
> > I loved Global Chillage, played it a lot back then! All those old
> > ambient records one FAX where also personal favorites.
> I think they over egged it with almost an album a week at one point but
> there's some good stuff in there. I was always liked Emit as a label.
>
> m
>
>
> >
> >
>
>


-- 
--
Southern Outpost
Sydney - San Francisco - Berlin
http://www.southernoutpost.com
--


Re: (313) Chill Out Rooms

2008-04-06 Thread Martin Dust

Klaas-Jan Jongsma wrote:
I loved Global Chillage, played it a lot back then! All those old 
ambient records one FAX where also personal favorites.
I think they over egged it with almost an album a week at one point but 
there's some good stuff in there. I was always liked Emit as a label.


m









Re: (313) Chill Out Rooms

2008-04-06 Thread Martin Dust

Frank Glazer wrote:

The time I heard MMM play he absolutely killed it, and there was nary
a pink floyd record to be found.  Why all the hate? 
There's no hate as you suggest, just my opinion based on suffering 
several weeks worth of it.


m

  


Re: (313) Chill Out Rooms

2008-04-06 Thread Klaas-Jan Jongsma
I loved Global Chillage, played it a lot back then! All those old  
ambient records one FAX where also personal favorites.


On 6 apr 2008, at 21:26, Frank Glazer wrote:


The time I heard MMM play he absolutely killed it, and there was nary
a pink floyd record to be found.  Why all the hate?  Global Chillage
was a classic!  What am I missing?

On Sun, Apr 6, 2008 at 7:59 AM, Martin Dust <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>  
wrote:

Klaas-Jan Jongsma wrote:


Yeah we need more rooms with those old Irresistible Force  
records... Chill

Out or Die ;-)


We never got that kind of hippy crap up here, the chill rooms  
always had
good stuff going on in them - which was good because it was always  
"squat"
tekno next door. MMM seems to have made a living out of playing  
Pink Floyd

b-sides at the wrong speed.

I guess now smoking is illegal they'll never really come back to  
clubs.


m





--
peace,

frank

dj mix archive: http://www.deejaycountzero.com




Re: (313) Chill Out Rooms

2008-04-06 Thread Frank Glazer
The time I heard MMM play he absolutely killed it, and there was nary
a pink floyd record to be found.  Why all the hate?  Global Chillage
was a classic!  What am I missing?

On Sun, Apr 6, 2008 at 7:59 AM, Martin Dust <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> >>Klaas-Jan Jongsma wrote:
>
> > Yeah we need more rooms with those old Irresistible Force records... Chill
> Out or Die ;-)
> >
>  We never got that kind of hippy crap up here, the chill rooms always had
> good stuff going on in them - which was good because it was always "squat"
> tekno next door. MMM seems to have made a living out of playing Pink Floyd
> b-sides at the wrong speed.
>
>  I guess now smoking is illegal they'll never really come back to clubs.
>
>  m
>



-- 
peace,

frank

dj mix archive: http://www.deejaycountzero.com


Re: (313) Chill Out Rooms

2008-04-06 Thread /0

instinct ruled.  one of the best labels ever, imo


- Original Message - 
From: "KiDD*e" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>

To: "Three-One-Three" <313@hyperreal.org>
Sent: Sunday, April 06, 2008 11:23 AM
Subject: Re: (313) Chill Out Rooms



http://www.manvsbigmachine.com/users/instinct-ambient/home.htm
Pretty indeed !
- K*

- Original Message - 
From: "/0" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>

To: "Martin Dust" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Cc: "313 Mailing List" <313@hyperreal.org>
Sent: Sunday, April 06, 2008 4:00 PM
Subject: Re: (313) Chill Out Rooms



the Chill Out series on instinct in the mid 90s was terrific

- Original Message - 
From: "Martin Dust" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>

Cc: "313 Mailing List" <313@hyperreal.org>
Sent: Sunday, April 06, 2008 7:59 AM
Subject: Re: (313) Chill Out Rooms


> >>Klaas-Jan Jongsma wrote:
>> Yeah we need more rooms with those old Irresistible Force records...
>> Chill Out or Die ;-)
> We never got that kind of hippy crap up here, the chill rooms always 
> had

> good stuff going on in them - which was good because it was always
> "squat" tekno next door. MMM seems to have made a living out of playing
> Pink Floyd b-sides at the wrong speed.
>
> I guess now smoking is illegal they'll never really come back to clubs.
>
> m








Re: (313) Jared Wilson

2008-04-06 Thread Jeffrey Richards
a release he came out with last year:
http://www.discogs.com/release/983148

his website:
http://www.j4r3d.com

he also has a myspace music site under the name Acid
Beard with a bunch of tracks on it.  Good stuff.

I wish he would release a couple of the MySpace tracks
on vinyl.

Jeff

--- Kowalsky <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

> I heard, years ago, an excellent mix recorded by
> Jarde Wilson. It  
> started with an AFX's remix for a Bug tune (run the
> place red) and  
> some great dancehall riddims from that time, then
> moves to some great  
> technoish sounds. I also bought a 12", that i found
> lost in a store,  
> with some great tunes by him, when i was in Paris.
> Anyone knows what else he's been doing?
> 



  

You rock. That's why Blockbuster's offering you one month of Blockbuster Total 
Access, No Cost.  
http://tc.deals.yahoo.com/tc/blockbuster/text5.com


Re: (313) Chill Out Rooms

2008-04-06 Thread KiDD*e
http://www.manvsbigmachine.com/users/instinct-ambient/home.htm
Pretty indeed !
- K*

- Original Message - 
From: "/0" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
To: "Martin Dust" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Cc: "313 Mailing List" <313@hyperreal.org>
Sent: Sunday, April 06, 2008 4:00 PM
Subject: Re: (313) Chill Out Rooms


> the Chill Out series on instinct in the mid 90s was terrific
>
> - Original Message - 
> From: "Martin Dust" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
> Cc: "313 Mailing List" <313@hyperreal.org>
> Sent: Sunday, April 06, 2008 7:59 AM
> Subject: Re: (313) Chill Out Rooms
>
>
> > >>Klaas-Jan Jongsma wrote:
> >> Yeah we need more rooms with those old Irresistible Force records...
> >> Chill Out or Die ;-)
> > We never got that kind of hippy crap up here, the chill rooms always had
> > good stuff going on in them - which was good because it was always
> > "squat" tekno next door. MMM seems to have made a living out of playing
> > Pink Floyd b-sides at the wrong speed.
> >
> > I guess now smoking is illegal they'll never really come back to clubs.
> >
> > m




Re: (313) Chill Out Rooms

2008-04-06 Thread /0

the Chill Out series on instinct in the mid 90s was terrific

- Original Message - 
From: "Martin Dust" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>

Cc: "313 Mailing List" <313@hyperreal.org>
Sent: Sunday, April 06, 2008 7:59 AM
Subject: Re: (313) Chill Out Rooms



>>Klaas-Jan Jongsma wrote:
Yeah we need more rooms with those old Irresistible Force records... 
Chill Out or Die ;-)
We never got that kind of hippy crap up here, the chill rooms always had 
good stuff going on in them - which was good because it was always 
"squat" tekno next door. MMM seems to have made a living out of playing 
Pink Floyd b-sides at the wrong speed.


I guess now smoking is illegal they'll never really come back to clubs.

m


Re: Re: (313) Ellen Allien's New Mix: Opinions?

2008-04-06 Thread Kevin Kennedy
Sadly, the hipsters and the sycophants are the leaders rather than the
innovators and the creative.

 And yes...Richie wants your wallet full of cashso do all that copy him.

The fact that even Hollywood has begun to copy itself more and more
bothers and makes me ask where is the creativity?

Oh, I take the laptop comment personally.  But I'm old and I like to
show some energy whenever I am playing a set.  Just ask anyone who saw
me @ the Reverse Edit afterparty last year.

fbk

sleepengineering/absoloop US


Re: (313) minimal suxs like dub

2008-04-06 Thread Kevin Kennedy
On Sun, Apr 6, 2008 at 7:09 AM, duf duf <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
>
>
>  Kevin Kennedy wrote:
>
>
> > ...and sadly today most of it is just electronic crap.
> >
>
>
>  This has been the a mantra for over 15 years though .. dance
>  music is can always completely mundane in the micro.
>
The period between 1993-96 saw an explosion in this music...especially
this style...there were actual classics being created during this
period-see DBX's 'losing control,' Shake's 'floorfiller,' and most of
Rob Hoods output during that period.  Heck, even my music from that
time still finds the floor in some DJ's hands...
>


>  What are we really looking for?  What is going to make techno
>  happy?  What is the electronic holy grail?

  What would make me happy is a bit of funk coming back into the
sound...or at least the acknowledgement of the groove.  The electronic
holy grail is really whatever you want-for me it's to have the music I
love not all sound like it's coming out of the same three boxes from
four people.

>  Dub/reggea has resolved some of this with its 'version' system
>  where all producers, MC's and Dj's have a crack at stylising or
>  interpreting a tune at the same time.

Sadly, dub/reggae had it's classic period from 1976-82, and I will not
say it's dead.

   However, the 'version' system you speak of (which of course works
for dub since it's basic source material is usually vocal reggae) is
the 'remix' system in electronic music...

>  There is this acceptance that the music is a vehicle for personal
>  expression, communication, interaction. So the focus is around a
>  particular persons 'version' as opposed to constantly seeking the
>  creation of something new or unique.

Some rabid followers  of Richie Hawtin that produce music already have
this in their heads...it's called their career?
>
>  In this context .. the tyranny of minimal is not so dangerous. Its
>  just the life of the music, growing, shifting and evolving.

I guess you are right, however I don't see how going backwards
15-20 years and starting over without some kind of direction is
progress...what I mean by this is that many entering the
business/artform today are doing something they think is new, when
there is a precedent that they don't see or hear.  After 15 years of
being into this music, I know it's happened before.

I keep saying there is no news under the sun.  Maybe all of this
will evolve into something...
-- 
fbk

sleepengineering/absoloop US


Re: (313) Chill Out Rooms

2008-04-06 Thread Martin Dust

>>Klaas-Jan Jongsma wrote:
Yeah we need more rooms with those old Irresistible Force records... 
Chill Out or Die ;-)
We never got that kind of hippy crap up here, the chill rooms always had 
good stuff going on in them - which was good because it was always 
"squat" tekno next door. MMM seems to have made a living out of playing 
Pink Floyd b-sides at the wrong speed.


I guess now smoking is illegal they'll never really come back to clubs.

m


Re: (313) Chill Out Rooms

2008-04-06 Thread Klaas-Jan Jongsma
Yeah we need more rooms with those old Irresistible Force records...  
Chill Out or Die ;-)




On 5 apr 2008, at 17:24, Dan Bean wrote:


Yes, very much.

-Original Message-
From: Martin Dust <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Sent: 04 April 2008 22:32
To: 313 Mailing List <313@hyperreal.org>
Subject: (313) Chill Out Rooms

Does anyone miss them at events? I do, I'd really love to play a slow
long 3hr set to bend some heads.

m





(313) Intermediate - Detroit (fwd)

2008-04-06 Thread chad m. sponholz


nice... :)

-- Forwarded message --
Date: Sun, 6 Apr 2008 18:31:57 +0800
From: ChinesePod <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Subject: Intermediate - Detroit

Hi vqns,

Today's ChinesePod lesson is: Intermediate - Detroit.

Take a ride with ChinesePod on the Freeway of Love to Detroit, Michigan.
We get to Motown, the Motor City, the 3-1-3. Though we're slightly
apprehensive due drive-by shooting cliches, we hang in there practicing
our tones to stay calm as we drive though Greek Town and past Joe Lewis'
arm. Now, you may be on Nanjing Road or 8-Mile Road, either way, this is
the lesson for you. Learn in Mandarin about a place far, far away from
your dumplings and rice... Detroit.

Special Offer : Free ChinesePod Shirts! Click here to find out how you
can get yours... Also, Praxis Language is hiring!

- The ChinesePod Team

You have received this email because you are subscribed to ChinesePod
academic email. If you wish to unsubscribe, please click here.




Re: (313) minimal suxs like dub

2008-04-06 Thread duf duf



Kevin Kennedy wrote:


...and sadly today most of it is just electronic crap.



This has been the a mantra for over 15 years though .. dance
music is can always completely mundane in the micro.

I guess what I'm trying to suggest is that this plethora of crap
is what makes the music what it is.

Don't the sounds evolve in the clubs on the dance floors, minute
changes that seem mundane week to week but consequential
when reviewed across seasons.

What are we really looking for?  What is going to make techno
happy?  What is the electronic holy grail?

Dub/reggea has resolved some of this with its 'version' system
where all producers, MC's and Dj's have a crack at stylising or
interpreting a tune at the same time.

There is this acceptance that the music is a vehicle for personal
expression, communication, interaction. So the focus is around a
particular persons 'version' as opposed to constantly seeking the
creation of something new or unique.

In this context .. the tyranny of minimal is not so dangerous. Its
just the life of the music, growing, shifting and evolving.













Re: (313) minimal suxs like dub

2008-04-06 Thread duf duf





 Lets face it every Dj wants to be producer with out having to
 do the hard work in the studio.


That is not a fact.  There are tons of DJs who subscribe to the David
Mancuso school of DJing, or at least lean primarily that way.


True . it's a pretty broad statement I made there.

But certainly the process of Dj'ing can often be like accepting the
Grammy on behalf of someone else .. without the speech.

Still I'd argue that Cool Herc got more people into Dj'ing than Mancuso ..

Who would win that fight? Love or the wheels of steel?