Re: [arr] Re: "Rahman has a Divine Face" - Subhash Ghai
Kudos to Jiban for saying that !! That email says it all !! On Thu, Oct 30, 2008 at 1:48 PM, rakesh kumar <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Totally agree with you jiban. > > We have to look forward. Dil se .. Bombay .. Roja ..are all gems from ARR.. > which we all will cherish.. but we should look forward and appreciate gems > like Yuvvraaj which is different and excellent in his own standard. > > ARR Rules.. Always > > Rakesh > > --- On *Wed, 10/29/08, jibandevta <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>* wrote: > > From: jibandevta <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > Subject: [arr] Re: "Rahman has a Divine Face" - Subhash Ghai > To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com > Date: Wednesday, October 29, 2008, 10:50 PM > > > I stongly disagree with the way Jahanzeb categorising 'class' > for ARR's music..though Dil se, Roja and Bombay are masterpieces > ..ARR has grown mature with Lagaan, Swades,JA and Yuvvraaj.. > Those who are disqualifying Yuvvraaj music, shows their lack > of knowledge of Western classical music.. > Its timne for us to walk with Rahman sir forward rather > getting nostalgic about past glories.. > We have to come out of our shell now.. > > -Jiban > > --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com , > dian hayati <[EMAIL PROTECTED] > wrote: > > > > It's true that Dil Se, Bombay, Roja and our boss masterpieces are > the greatest...but to me, I will never compare his work as all of > them are wonderful... . > > > > > > Best Regards, > > > > Dian Hayati Syamsuir | Assistant of Marketing Communication > Manager | PT Kusuma Megahperdana | Kompleks Ketapang Indah Blok B2 > No. 21 Jl. KH. Zainul Arifin | Jakarta Indonesia 11140 | p: +6221 > 6338103 ext 102 | f: +6221 6336651 | www.kusumamegah. com > > > > --- On Wed, 10/29/08, Jahanzeb Farooq wrote: > > > > From: Jahanzeb Farooq > > Subject: [arr] Re: "Rahman has a Divine Face" - Subhash Ghai > > To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com > > Date: Wednesday, October 29, 2008, 6:49 PM > > > > > > > > > > > > > > well i sincerely pray that the film becomes a hit. otherwise the > music > > will quickly disappear. barring 2-3 songs the rest do not have a > mass > > appeal. > > now about comparing with Bombay, Taal, Dil Se, ... "for me" it is > > complete nonsense. yuvraaj can never be close to these > masterpieces. > > for me if the above four fall in class 1 of ARR then Yuvraaj falls > in > > class 4. Lagaan, Saathiya, Earth 47, Sapnay, Rangeela etc are > class 2. JA, JTYJN, RDB, Guru etc are class 3. Yuva, kabhi na kabhi > etc fall in > > class 5. > > > > --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, V S Rawat wrote: > > > > > > On 10/29/2008 1:08 AM India Time, _Aaditya(Addy) *COOL*_ wrote: > > > > > > > I had watched that inteview, Mr Ghai said Bombay, Taal and > > Yuvvraaj as > > > > ARR's 3 favourite works. Anyway nice work by Vithur, you are > an > > asset to > > > > this group. > > > > > > > > > > Well, I am ready to accept any brickbats from you guys, but I > have > > to > > > say that Yuvraj music is not at par with Bombay. Even taal > wasn't. > > > > > > Giving it further thought, I feel that Taal/ yuvraaj music are > sort > > of > > > "commercialized" , that is how ghai wanted it to be, whereas all > > Mani's > > > albums have a purity, an innocence, a > > > composed-for- the-listener, -not-composed- for-market feel in > them. > > > > > > Mani is in a class of his own. > > > > > > -- > > > V > > > > > > > > > -- Farzad Khaleel Webmaster http://rahmaniac.co.nr
Re: [arr] Re: "Rahman has a Divine Face" - Subhash Ghai
Someone wants that ARR should go in same pattern.. They can't understand the variety of his recent flicks. Regards MANAF --- On Thu, 10/30/08, rakesh kumar <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: From: rakesh kumar <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Subject: Re: [arr] Re: "Rahman has a Divine Face" - Subhash Ghai To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com Date: Thursday, October 30, 2008, 1:18 AM Totally agree with you jiban. We have to look forward. Dil se .. Bombay .. Roja ..are all gems from ARR.. which we all will cherish.. but we should look forward and appreciate gems like Yuvvraaj which is different and excellent in his own standard. ARR Rules.. Always Rakesh --- On Wed, 10/29/08, jibandevta <[EMAIL PROTECTED] co.in> wrote: From: jibandevta <[EMAIL PROTECTED] co.in> Subject: [arr] Re: "Rahman has a Divine Face" - Subhash Ghai To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com Date: Wednesday, October 29, 2008, 10:50 PM I stongly disagree with the way Jahanzeb categorising 'class' for ARR's music..though Dil se, Roja and Bombay are masterpieces ..ARR has grown mature with Lagaan, Swades,JA and Yuvvraaj.. Those who are disqualifying Yuvvraaj music, shows their lack of knowledge of Western classical music.. Its timne for us to walk with Rahman sir forward rather getting nostalgic about past glories.. We have to come out of our shell now.. -Jiban --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, dian hayati <[EMAIL PROTECTED] > wrote: > > It's true that Dil Se, Bombay, Roja and our boss masterpieces are the greatest...but to me, I will never compare his work as all of them are wonderful... . > > > Best Regards, > > Dian Hayati Syamsuir | Assistant of Marketing Communication Manager | PT Kusuma Megahperdana | Kompleks Ketapang Indah Blok B2 No. 21 Jl. KH. Zainul Arifin | Jakarta Indonesia 11140 | p: +6221 6338103 ext 102 | f: +6221 6336651 | www.kusumamegah. com > > --- On Wed, 10/29/08, Jahanzeb Farooq wrote: > > From: Jahanzeb Farooq > Subject: [arr] Re: "Rahman has a Divine Face" - Subhash Ghai > To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com > Date: Wednesday, October 29, 2008, 6:49 PM > > > > > > > well i sincerely pray that the film becomes a hit. otherwise the music > will quickly disappear. barring 2-3 songs the rest do not have a mass > appeal. > now about comparing with Bombay, Taal, Dil Se, ... "for me" it is > complete nonsense. yuvraaj can never be close to these masterpieces. > for me if the above four fall in class 1 of ARR then Yuvraaj falls in > class 4. Lagaan, Saathiya, Earth 47, Sapnay, Rangeela etc are class 2. JA, JTYJN, RDB, Guru etc are class 3. Yuva, kabhi na kabhi etc fall in > class 5. > > --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, V S Rawat wrote: > > > > On 10/29/2008 1:08 AM India Time, _Aaditya(Addy) *COOL*_ wrote: > > > > > I had watched that inteview, Mr Ghai said Bombay, Taal and > Yuvvraaj as > > > ARR's 3 favourite works. Anyway nice work by Vithur, you are an > asset to > > > this group. > > > > > > > Well, I am ready to accept any brickbats from you guys, but I have > to > > say that Yuvraj music is not at par with Bombay. Even taal wasn't. > > > > Giving it further thought, I feel that Taal/ yuvraaj music are sort > of > > "commercialized" , that is how ghai wanted it to be, whereas all > Mani's > > albums have a purity, an innocence, a > > composed-for- the-listener, -not-composed- for-market feel in them. > > > > Mani is in a class of his own. > > > > -- > > V > > >
Re: [arr] Re: "Rahman has a Divine Face" - Subhash Ghai
Totally agree with you jiban. We have to look forward. Dil se .. Bombay .. Roja ..are all gems from ARR.. which we all will cherish.. but we should look forward and appreciate gems like Yuvvraaj which is different and excellent in his own standard. ARR Rules.. Always Rakesh --- On Wed, 10/29/08, jibandevta <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: From: jibandevta <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Subject: [arr] Re: "Rahman has a Divine Face" - Subhash Ghai To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com Date: Wednesday, October 29, 2008, 10:50 PM I stongly disagree with the way Jahanzeb categorising 'class' for ARR's music..though Dil se, Roja and Bombay are masterpieces ..ARR has grown mature with Lagaan, Swades,JA and Yuvvraaj.. Those who are disqualifying Yuvvraaj music, shows their lack of knowledge of Western classical music.. Its timne for us to walk with Rahman sir forward rather getting nostalgic about past glories.. We have to come out of our shell now.. -Jiban --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, dian hayati <[EMAIL PROTECTED] > wrote: > > It's true that Dil Se, Bombay, Roja and our boss masterpieces are the greatest...but to me, I will never compare his work as all of them are wonderful... . > > > Best Regards, > > Dian Hayati Syamsuir | Assistant of Marketing Communication Manager | PT Kusuma Megahperdana | Kompleks Ketapang Indah Blok B2 No. 21 Jl. KH. Zainul Arifin | Jakarta Indonesia 11140 | p: +6221 6338103 ext 102 | f: +6221 6336651 | www.kusumamegah. com > > --- On Wed, 10/29/08, Jahanzeb Farooq wrote: > > From: Jahanzeb Farooq > Subject: [arr] Re: "Rahman has a Divine Face" - Subhash Ghai > To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com > Date: Wednesday, October 29, 2008, 6:49 PM > > > > > > > well i sincerely pray that the film becomes a hit. otherwise the music > will quickly disappear. barring 2-3 songs the rest do not have a mass > appeal. > now about comparing with Bombay, Taal, Dil Se, ... "for me" it is > complete nonsense. yuvraaj can never be close to these masterpieces. > for me if the above four fall in class 1 of ARR then Yuvraaj falls in > class 4. Lagaan, Saathiya, Earth 47, Sapnay, Rangeela etc are class 2. JA, JTYJN, RDB, Guru etc are class 3. Yuva, kabhi na kabhi etc fall in > class 5. > > --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, V S Rawat wrote: > > > > On 10/29/2008 1:08 AM India Time, _Aaditya(Addy) *COOL*_ wrote: > > > > > I had watched that inteview, Mr Ghai said Bombay, Taal and > Yuvvraaj as > > > ARR's 3 favourite works. Anyway nice work by Vithur, you are an > asset to > > > this group. > > > > > > > Well, I am ready to accept any brickbats from you guys, but I have > to > > say that Yuvraj music is not at par with Bombay. Even taal wasn't. > > > > Giving it further thought, I feel that Taal/ yuvraaj music are sort > of > > "commercialized" , that is how ghai wanted it to be, whereas all > Mani's > > albums have a purity, an innocence, a > > composed-for- the-listener, -not-composed- for-market feel in them. > > > > Mani is in a class of his own. > > > > -- > > V > > >
Re: [arr] Re: "Rahman has a Divine Face" - Subhash Ghai
It's true that Dil Se, Bombay, Roja and our boss masterpieces are the greatest...but to me, I will never compare his work as all of them are wonderful Best Regards, Dian Hayati Syamsuir | Assistant of Marketing Communication Manager | PT Kusuma Megahperdana | Kompleks Ketapang Indah Blok B2 No. 21 Jl. KH. Zainul Arifin | Jakarta Indonesia 11140 | p: +6221 6338103 ext 102 | f: +6221 6336651 | www.kusumamegah.com --- On Wed, 10/29/08, Jahanzeb Farooq <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: From: Jahanzeb Farooq <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Subject: [arr] Re: "Rahman has a Divine Face" - Subhash Ghai To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com Date: Wednesday, October 29, 2008, 6:49 PM well i sincerely pray that the film becomes a hit. otherwise the music will quickly disappear. barring 2-3 songs the rest do not have a mass appeal. now about comparing with Bombay, Taal, Dil Se, ... "for me" it is complete nonsense. yuvraaj can never be close to these masterpieces. for me if the above four fall in class 1 of ARR then Yuvraaj falls in class 4. Lagaan, Saathiya, Earth 47, Sapnay, Rangeela etc are class 2. JA, JTYJN, RDB, Guru etc are class 3. Yuva, kabhi na kabhi etc fall in class 5. --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, V S Rawat <[EMAIL PROTECTED] > wrote: > > On 10/29/2008 1:08 AM India Time, _Aaditya(Addy) *COOL*_ wrote: > > > I had watched that inteview, Mr Ghai said Bombay, Taal and Yuvvraaj as > > ARR's 3 favourite works. Anyway nice work by Vithur, you are an asset to > > this group. > > > > Well, I am ready to accept any brickbats from you guys, but I have to > say that Yuvraj music is not at par with Bombay. Even taal wasn't. > > Giving it further thought, I feel that Taal/ yuvraaj music are sort of > "commercialized" , that is how ghai wanted it to be, whereas all Mani's > albums have a purity, an innocence, a > composed-for- the-listener, -not-composed- for-market feel in them. > > Mani is in a class of his own. > > -- > V >
Re: [arr] Re: "Rahman has a Divine Face" - Subhash Ghai
On 10/29/2008 1:08 AM India Time, _Aaditya(Addy) *COOL*_ wrote: > I had watched that inteview, Mr Ghai said Bombay, Taal and Yuvvraaj as > ARR's 3 favourite works. Anyway nice work by Vithur, you are an asset to > this group. > Well, I am ready to accept any brickbats from you guys, but I have to say that Yuvraj music is not at par with Bombay. Even taal wasn't. Giving it further thought, I feel that Taal/ yuvraaj music are sort of "commercialized", that is how ghai wanted it to be, whereas all Mani's albums have a purity, an innocence, a composed-for-the-listener,-not-composed-for-market feel in them. Mani is in a class of his own. -- V
Re: [arr] Re: "Rahman has a Divine Face" - Subhash Ghai
Really? So sad our boss didn't mention the great Dil Se Best Regards, Dian Hayati Syamsuir | Assistant of Marketing Communication Manager | PT Kusuma Megahperdana | Kompleks Ketapang Indah Blok B2 No. 21 Jl. KH. Zainul Arifin | Jakarta Indonesia 11140 | p: +6221 6338103 ext 102 | f: +6221 6336651 | www.kusumamegah.com --- On Wed, 10/29/08, Aaditya(Addy) *COOL* <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: From: Aaditya(Addy) *COOL* <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Subject: Re: [arr] Re: "Rahman has a Divine Face" - Subhash Ghai To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com Date: Wednesday, October 29, 2008, 2:38 AM I had watched that inteview, Mr Ghai said Bombay, Taal and Yuvvraaj as ARR's 3 favourite works. Anyway nice work by Vithur, you are an asset to this group. --- On Tue, 28/10/08, Sylenthira <[EMAIL PROTECTED] com> wrote: From: Sylenthira <[EMAIL PROTECTED] com> Subject: [arr] Re: "Rahman has a Divine Face" - Subhash Ghai To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com Date: Tuesday, 28 October, 2008, 9:15 PM Thanks a lot, Vithur. It was a nice one.. --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, Vithur <[EMAIL PROTECTED] > wrote: > > EXCLUSIVE:Excerpts frm arr,ghai,gulzar chat hi all, > today had the pleasure of watching a special program called "legends of > melody" which had arr,subhash ghai and gulzar as the guests for the movie > YUVVRAAJ on NDTV 24*7 at 1.30. It was a great show lasted for half an hour. > Although i cant remember the whole set of questions bt m putting below > watever i remember. > > Q(to ghai): How did u deal with the mode of working of arr.(arr starts > smiling).How much did u tolerated. > ANS. Well actually i wanted him to prepare the music as fast as > possible(starts laughing). The reason was that i had already imagined how > the shot must takes place, the dress etc. Only part remaining used to be the > music. So out of excitement i wanted him to deliver now. Sometimes u get > frustrated bt when u look at rahman, he has such a divine face. He always > remains calm and smiles when u look at him. So i used to forget everything > and start smiling with him.(both arr and ghai laugh). Bt u know a person > like rahman needs his time. He deserves it. > > Q(to gulzar): How much do u think poetry scenario has changed today? > ANS. It has changed a lot. Now a days we hav commercialized poetry. Bt look > at rahman he brought tremendous change. Earlier we used to have 2 lines of > mukhada and then 2 lines of antara. Bt with rahman anything is possible. > > Q(to arr): When u prepare tune, if ghai doesnt like wat happens then? > ANS. Nothing he just says it doesnt work. I go to something else. Its that > simple. > (ghai interrupts) The best thing about rahman is that he immediately shifts > to the next tune if i dont like it. He has no such ego. He can change it > himself if he doesnt find it right. Infact sometimes when i like the tune > hearing first time he cant believe it "ki inhe pasand kaise aa gaya itni > jaldi"(laughs) > Q(to all): Now each of u hav to tell the 3 works that u liked of the other > two gentlemen in which u hav not collaborated. > ANS. GHAI: my favs are roja,taal and yuvvraaj.( on being reminded not to > mention his own) All are great. in case of arr the least u can expect is > EXCELLENT. > > ARR: I m getting nostalgic so i wud say ghai's HERO is the one i used to > play during childhood. > > Gulzar: In case of rahman, i loved the song "e ajnabi" from dil se. I loved > ghai's "taal". the way he pictuarized the song was so great. I decided to > work with ghai sahab. When he called me for yuvvraaj he said " kya aap > likhenge" i said " yes sir,bilkul"( everyone laughs). ARR says " i couldnt > belive he agreed for writing so many songs"(laughing) > > ( Posted from Orkut ) > -- > regards, > Vithur > > ARR in my Heart; > His Music in my Blood; > Add more friends to your messenger and enjoy! Invite them now.
Re: [arr] Re: "Rahman has a Divine Face" - Subhash Ghai
I had watched that inteview, Mr Ghai said Bombay, Taal and Yuvvraaj as ARR's 3 favourite works. Anyway nice work by Vithur, you are an asset to this group. --- On Tue, 28/10/08, Sylenthira <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: From: Sylenthira <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Subject: [arr] Re: "Rahman has a Divine Face" - Subhash Ghai To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com Date: Tuesday, 28 October, 2008, 9:15 PM Thanks a lot, Vithur. It was a nice one.. --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, Vithur <[EMAIL PROTECTED] > wrote: > > EXCLUSIVE:Excerpts frm arr,ghai,gulzar chat hi all, > today had the pleasure of watching a special program called "legends of > melody" which had arr,subhash ghai and gulzar as the guests for the movie > YUVVRAAJ on NDTV 24*7 at 1.30. It was a great show lasted for half an hour. > Although i cant remember the whole set of questions bt m putting below > watever i remember. > > Q(to ghai): How did u deal with the mode of working of arr.(arr starts > smiling).How much did u tolerated. > ANS. Well actually i wanted him to prepare the music as fast as > possible(starts laughing). The reason was that i had already imagined how > the shot must takes place, the dress etc. Only part remaining used to be the > music. So out of excitement i wanted him to deliver now. Sometimes u get > frustrated bt when u look at rahman, he has such a divine face. He always > remains calm and smiles when u look at him. So i used to forget everything > and start smiling with him.(both arr and ghai laugh). Bt u know a person > like rahman needs his time. He deserves it. > > Q(to gulzar): How much do u think poetry scenario has changed today? > ANS. It has changed a lot. Now a days we hav commercialized poetry. Bt look > at rahman he brought tremendous change. Earlier we used to have 2 lines of > mukhada and then 2 lines of antara. Bt with rahman anything is possible. > > Q(to arr): When u prepare tune, if ghai doesnt like wat happens then? > ANS. Nothing he just says it doesnt work. I go to something else. Its that > simple. > (ghai interrupts) The best thing about rahman is that he immediately shifts > to the next tune if i dont like it. He has no such ego. He can change it > himself if he doesnt find it right. Infact sometimes when i like the tune > hearing first time he cant believe it "ki inhe pasand kaise aa gaya itni > jaldi"(laughs) > Q(to all): Now each of u hav to tell the 3 works that u liked of the other > two gentlemen in which u hav not collaborated. > ANS. GHAI: my favs are roja,taal and yuvvraaj.( on being reminded not to > mention his own) All are great. in case of arr the least u can expect is > EXCELLENT. > > ARR: I m getting nostalgic so i wud say ghai's HERO is the one i used to > play during childhood. > > Gulzar: In case of rahman, i loved the song "e ajnabi" from dil se. I loved > ghai's "taal". the way he pictuarized the song was so great. I decided to > work with ghai sahab. When he called me for yuvvraaj he said " kya aap > likhenge" i said " yes sir,bilkul"( everyone laughs). ARR says " i couldnt > belive he agreed for writing so many songs"(laughing) > > ( Posted from Orkut ) > -- > regards, > Vithur > > ARR in my Heart; > His Music in my Blood; > Connect with friends all over the world. Get Yahoo! India Messenger at http://in.messenger.yahoo.com/?wm=n/
