Re: [CinCVS] libcinelerra3

2007-08-25 Thread Valentina Messeri
hi, :D i really don't want start a flame, hehehhe, only make some observations about the way you start you large mail. I've been lurking here for a while, but this thread has been too much to resist. I would very much like to find an open source solution for video editing that could be

Re: [CinCVS] Some of my thoughts on scripting

2007-08-25 Thread Dennis Schulmeister
On Sat, 2007-08-25 at 17:38 +1200, David McNab wrote: On Sat, 2007-08-25 at 10:41 +0800, Martin Ellison wrote: But anyway, what is wrong with switches? You find out soon enough if you've got a big switch in a tight time-critical loop. You wouldn't create new objects in such a loop,

Re: [CinCVS] Some Ficl documentation for you

2007-08-25 Thread Mark Carter
From: Martin Ellison [EMAIL PROTECTED] Hopefully, you just need FICL running in its own thread. You guys really like your threads, n'est pas? I have a feeling that they'll be too hard for me to understand, though. I like to approach things from the angle of simplicity and debuggability. I

Re: [CinCVS] libcinelerra3

2007-08-25 Thread Mark Carter
I would worry about the architecture of the thing first. Right now the code extremely tangled with many opportunities for non-deterministic behavior. I assume that's why everyone is arguing about a re-write. My own opinion is that a re-design is needed first. HV is undoubtedly a

Re: [CinCVS] Some of my thoughts on scripting

2007-08-25 Thread Mark Carter
I think youz guys are getting a bit bogged down in the argument. My point about the switching wasn't about them being time-critical (the check_sig() functions are going to be taking up most of the time anyway), but that the code was a bit of a mess and a more elegant solution was available, and

Re: [CinCVS] libcinelerra3

2007-08-25 Thread Herman Robak
On Sat, 25 Aug 2007 13:24:01 +0200, Valentina Messeri [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: In it's present state I'm afraid that it would be an exercise in frustration that would totally defeat the purpose. For now Final Cut Pro or Final Cut Express seats make a lot more sense. They work flawlessly,

[CinCVS] libmpeg3

2007-08-25 Thread Mark Carter
I notice that Cinelerra has a directory for libmpeg3. It is giving me compilation problems - and Googling around, I don't seem to be the only one. So my question is: what's it doing there, can't we just get rid of it and use the latest version from our repos?

Re: [CinCVS] libcinelerra3

2007-08-25 Thread Herman Robak
On Sat, 25 Aug 2007 00:10:42 +0200, Christian Thaeter [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Herman Robak wrote: (about interlacing) Here is how I think it should go: 1) Split out the fields, putting them after one another on the timeline. 2 a) Line-double or interpolate them up to full vertical

Re: [CinCVS] libmpeg3

2007-08-25 Thread Kevin Brosius
On 2007-08-25 13:02, Mark Carter wrote: I notice that Cinelerra has a directory for libmpeg3. It is giving me compilation problems - and Googling around, I don't seem to be the only one. So my question is: what's it doing there, can't we just get rid of it and use the latest version from

Re: [CinCVS] libcinelerra3

2007-08-25 Thread Bradley A. Hare
Mark Carter wrote: HV is undoubtedly a better programmer than me. I think he wrote it in a way that made sense for him. He wrote most of the code, so he pretty much knows the score of what's going on in it. But what works for him may not work for everybody else. Certainly there is a lot of

Re: [CinCVS] libcinelerra3

2007-08-25 Thread Bradley A. Hare
Valentina Messeri wrote: YOU..you're simply talking about your experience, do'you really think, talking about educational purposes that propietary tools worth the while? I could understand profesional purpose, cause people got so used to their propietary tools and they, obviously, think

Re: [CinCVS] libcinelerra3

2007-08-25 Thread Mark Carter
From: Bradley A. Hare [EMAIL PROTECTED] Working minimal functionality that can be maintained. I might be wrong, others seem to have been more successful at this than I have, I just want to use Cinelerra for more casual amateur use, rather than professional. I've found Cinelerra rather

Re: [CinCVS] libcinelerra3

2007-08-25 Thread Bradley A. Hare
Mark Carter wrote: I've taken to hacking away a bit at the code - and alas I broke my version. One thing that leaps out is all those case statements, esp. wrt colour models. I may be being too niaive, but I'd really like to see some kind of method of getting a grip on that. I looked at the

Re: [CinCVS] libcinelerra3

2007-08-25 Thread Jason van Gumster
Since other silent users are busting out of the woodwork to voice their opinions, I'm compelled to spit my two cents on all of the recent discussion. ;) Mark Carter [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: From: Bradley A. Hare [EMAIL PROTECTED] Working minimal functionality that can be maintained. I might

Re: [CinCVS] libcinelerra3

2007-08-25 Thread Bradley A. Hare
Jason van Gumster wrote: I can't be the only one who's done successful complex editing in Cinelerra. I do fair amount of of work, professionally and independently, and while I'll admit Cinelerra isn't perfect, it certainly does the job for me on the projects I choose to use it on. Could you

Re: [CinCVS] libcinelerra3

2007-08-25 Thread Graham Evans
Bradley A. Hare wrote: Jason van Gumster wrote: I can't be the only one who's done successful complex editing in Cinelerra. I do fair amount of of work, professionally and independently, and while I'll admit Cinelerra isn't perfect, it certainly does the job for me on the projects I choose to

Re: [CinCVS] About cinelerra problem on slackware12

2007-08-25 Thread rafael2k
Could you try the cinelerra packages I made for slack 12? http://slack.sarava.org/packages/slackware/slackware-12.0/media/video/cinelerra/ Patches and compile script: http://slack.sarava.org/slackbuilds/media/video/cinelerra/ bye, rafael diniz Em Qui 23 Ago 2007, Jean Sébastien TAROT escreveu: