Re: [CinCVS] WHERE CINELERRA IS GOING? ...anyone? proposal for CinelerraCV 2 maintenace

2007-08-16 Thread Martin Ellison
Could you explain this more? svn allows branching, so why not just create as many development branches as required and work there? I do not know git, so could you please explain what git has over svn? (Not intended as an attack). On 16/08/07, Christian Thaeter [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: ... 2)

Re: [CinCVS] WHERE CINELERRA IS GOING? ...anyone? proposal for CinelerraCV 2 maintenace

2007-08-16 Thread Christian Thaeter
Martin Ellison wrote: Could you explain this more? svn allows branching, so why not just create as many development branches as required and work there? I do not know git, so could you please explain what git has over svn? (Not intended as an attack). I am out of office today. In short:

Re: [CinCVS] WHERE CINELERRA IS GOING? ...anyone? proposal for CinelerraCV 2 maintenace

2007-08-16 Thread mark carter
On Thu, 2007-08-16 at 16:37 +0800, Martin Ellison wrote: Could you explain this more? svn allows branching, so why not just create as many development branches as required and work there? I do not know git, so could you please explain what git has over svn? (Not intended as an attack).

Re: [CinCVS] WHERE CINELERRA IS GOING? ...anyone? proposal for CinelerraCV 2 maintenace

2007-08-16 Thread Kevin Brosius
On 2007-08-16 00:49, Christian Thaeter wrote: Kevin Brosius wrote: On 2007-08-15 17:36, Christian Thaeter wrote: ... I think you won't get much feedback from the older core developers since these goals are so large and you haven't tackled a smaller piece of Cin first. I have done

Re: [CinCVS] WHERE CINELERRA IS GOING? ...anyone? proposal for CinelerraCV 2 maintenace

2007-08-16 Thread Martin Ellison
On 16/08/07, Herman Robak [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: ... Adam would not be able to fix this in a reasonable timeframe, even if he was given an exhaustive TODO list. Neither will we, unless a lot of the underlying code is redone to support all the stuff that an NLE and compositor of the

Re: [CinCVS] WHERE CINELERRA IS GOING? ...anyone? proposal for CinelerraCV 2 maintenace

2007-08-15 Thread Christian Thaeter
This my maybe arguable view how to hive Cinelerra CV out of its develoment stall: 1) Change the focus of CinelerraCV Currently CVs goal is repackaging the HV version and fixing bugs. But a real community version should acknowledge progress and new features which are contributed by the community.

Re: [CinCVS] WHERE CINELERRA IS GOING? ...anyone? proposal for CinelerraCV 2 maintenace

2007-08-15 Thread Mikko Huhtala
Christian Thaeter writes: This my maybe arguable view how to hive Cinelerra CV out of its develoment stall: 1) Change the focus of CinelerraCV [ ... ] 2) Stop using SVN [ ... ] 3) Make releases [ ... ] 4) Make tracking HV less important Hear hear. I've been reading this thread and

Re: [CinCVS] WHERE CINELERRA IS GOING? ...anyone? proposal for CinelerraCV 2 maintenace

2007-08-15 Thread Fred Williams
On Wed, 2007-15-08 at 21:20 +0300, Mikko Huhtala wrote: Christian Thaeter writes: This my maybe arguable view how to hive Cinelerra CV out of its develoment stall: 1) Change the focus of CinelerraCV [ ... ] 2) Stop using SVN [ ... ] 3) Make releases [ ... ] 4) Make

Re: [CinCVS] WHERE CINELERRA IS GOING? ...anyone? proposal for CinelerraCV 2 maintenace

2007-08-15 Thread Christian Thaeter
mark carter wrote: On Wed, 2007-08-15 at 19:36 +0200, Christian Thaeter wrote: 2) Stop using SVN I just saw a YouTube vid by Linus who is talking about git: http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=4XpnKHJAok8 Even if commit access is generously handled to people who ask, it's still a big blocker

Re: [CinCVS] WHERE CINELERRA IS GOING? ...anyone? proposal for CinelerraCV 2 maintenace

2007-08-15 Thread Kevin Brosius
On 2007-08-15 17:36, Christian Thaeter wrote: This my maybe arguable view how to hive Cinelerra CV out of its develoment stall: 1) Change the focus of CinelerraCV 2) Stop using SVN 3) Make releases 4) Make tracking HV less important I've been pretty silent on these issues so far, not

Re: [CinCVS] WHERE CINELERRA IS GOING? ...anyone? proposal for CinelerraCV 2 maintenace

2007-08-15 Thread Christian Thaeter
Kevin Brosius wrote: On 2007-08-15 17:36, Christian Thaeter wrote: This my maybe arguable view how to hive Cinelerra CV out of its develoment stall: 1) Change the focus of CinelerraCV 2) Stop using SVN 3) Make releases 4) Make tracking HV less important I've been pretty silent on these