RE: RRs and Confeds as they relate to IE studies [7:29968]

2001-12-24 Thread Kane, Christopher A.
PM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: RRs and Confeds as they relate to IE studies [7:29968] Good question. I don't claim to be an expert on BGP and will not comment on the advantages and disadvantages of RR/Confeds in large/small environments. I've only config'ed BGP once in a prod

Re: RRs and Confeds as they relate to IE studies [7:29968]

2001-12-23 Thread Howard C. Berkowitz
>The size of the network does have a role when choose between RR and Confeds. >The BGP desgin for a POP is quite different than for the backbone, this is >true no matter the size of the ISP. Well, yes. If the POPs have different policies, confeds may be useful. Otherwise, I think you'll find mo

Re: RRs and Confeds as they relate to IE studies [7:29968]

2001-12-23 Thread Kent Yu
The size of the network does have a role when choose between RR and Confeds. The BGP desgin for a POP is quite different than for the backbone, this is true no matter the size of the ISP. POPs are better place for RR where the backbone is better off with something else. If it is a purely dialup PO

RE: RRs and Confeds as they relate to IE studies [7:29968]

2001-12-23 Thread Howard C. Berkowitz
l my eyes. > >Guess I will just never be good at sales. > >Chuck > > > >-Original Message- > >From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]]On Behalf Of >Howard C. Berkowitz >Sent: Sunday, December 23, 2001 7:49 AM >To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] >Su

Re: RRs and Confeds as they relate to IE studies [7:29968]

2001-12-23 Thread Gregg Malcolm
Good question. I don't claim to be an expert on BGP and will not comment on the advantages and disadvantages of RR/Confeds in large/small environments. I've only config'ed BGP once in a prod net. Seems to me tho that there is an important distinction between the two as they might pertain to the

Re: RRs and Confeds as they relate to IE studies [7:29968]

2001-12-23 Thread Howard C. Berkowitz
>I'm currently tearing apart BGP as part of my IE studies. It's not too bad >since I come from a Network Service Provider background. But, I have run >into a conflict in regards to RRs vs. Confeds. I probably don't need to >straighten this out for the Written but when it comes to the lab I'd like

Re: RRs and Confeds as they relate to IE studies [7:29968]

2001-12-23 Thread Howard C. Berkowitz
>RR's are normally used in small to medium sized implementations. >Confederations are normally used in large implementations. I imagine on the >lab they'll give some clue as to which one is required. > >The k1d It's not a matter of size; it's a matter of how much policy control you need. Most

Re: RRs and Confeds as they relate to IE studies [7:29968]

2001-12-23 Thread c1sc0k1d
RR's are normally used in small to medium sized implementations. Confederations are normally used in large implementations. I imagine on the lab they'll give some clue as to which one is required. The k1d ""Kane, Christopher A."" wrote in message [EMAIL PROTECTED]">news:[EMAIL PROTECTED]...