[CGUYS] hard drive poll questions

2009-03-02 Thread mike
Hitachi 0A38016 1 TB SATA II 16 MB92 bux Western Digital 10EACS 1 TB SATA II 98 bux Both carry 3 year warranty. I've got bad feelings about hitachi due to past experience with just one drive. I'm buying two of these which means I could save a whopping 12 bux, what does the list think?

Re: [CGUYS] hard drive poll questions

2009-03-02 Thread Tony B
We've always found the Hitachi's to be the superior drive, since the days they were IBM. Usually costing a bit more though, which makes sense. Most of ours are upgraded before they fail. On Mon, Mar 2, 2009 at 12:00 PM, mike xha...@gmail.com wrote:  Hitachi 0A38016 1 TB SATA II 16 MB    92 bux

Re: [CGUYS] hard drive poll questions

2009-03-02 Thread b_s-wilk
Hitachi 0A38016 1 TB SATA II 16 MB92 bux Western Digital 10EACS 1 TB SATA II 98 bux Both carry 3 year warranty. I've got bad feelings about hitachi due to past experience with just one drive. I'm buying two of these which means I could save a whopping 12 bux, what does the list think?

Re: [CGUYS] hard drive poll questions

2009-03-02 Thread Tom Piwowar
Both carry 3 year warranty. I've got bad feelings about hitachi due to past experience with just one drive. I'm buying two of these which means I could save a whopping 12 bux, what does the list think? Any opinions on either drive? BTW, I won't be RAIDing the drives so the WD will still be ok

Re: [CGUYS] hard drive poll questions

2009-03-02 Thread mike
Good info Betty, thanks. It's hard to keep track of who is actually making hardware these days and I'll be the first to admit my bad feelings about hitachi are not founded in any real facts. To be honest I'm not worried about recovery as 1 of these drives is the main and the other a mirror,

Re: [CGUYS] hard drive poll questions

2009-03-02 Thread db
After buying many drives for servers, I find WD's to generally be the most cost effective and reliable and a good company to work with always. I most always buy thu newegg and alway try to buy WD 7200 rpm, large cache models with a 5 yr. warranty and if not that, the 3 yr. warranty models.

Re: [CGUYS] hard drive poll questions

2009-03-02 Thread b_s-wilk
I buy Seagate drives--their top ones; haven't been disappointed. Our PM 6100 ca. 1994 has one in it that sounds like an airplane warming up, but still works after 14 years--lasted longer than most dogs. However, I'm considering a Hitachi 500GB for my MacBook. I've only had one other Hitachi

Re: [CGUYS] hard drive poll questions

2009-03-02 Thread Eric S. Sande
It's hard to keep track of who is actually making hardware these days. As far as hard drives this is true. Fujitsu and Maxtor were well considered back in the day and Seagate was vilified, but Seagate has gotten a lot better and has an excellent warranty. I know Western Digital gets good

Re: [CGUYS] hard drive poll questions

2009-03-02 Thread Rev. Stewart Marshall
Not exactly. 1.5 TB drives are starting to really make a push and I have seen prices dropping on 1 TB drives. I have seen 500GB laptop drives really coming on presently. My wife's new laptop came with a 250 GB while mine came with a 120 GB (Year difference) Looked at upgrading mine and

Re: [CGUYS] hard drive poll questions

2009-03-02 Thread Eric S. Sande
1.5 TB drives are starting to really make a push and I have seen prices dropping on 1 TB drives. Yeah, but you have to figure that the more moving parts you've got would tend to compromise reliability unless the technology were really improved. My feeling is that we're not going to see a real

Re: [CGUYS] hard drive poll questions

2009-03-02 Thread Rev. Stewart Marshall
I have not read enough lately but I think they achieved the increase in capacity not by changing the physical structure but in how it is written and read. But yes the SSD is the new wave and I think will become the new standard. The increase in size will just take time. I think when we start

Re: [CGUYS] hard drive poll questions

2009-03-02 Thread Eric S. Sande
I have not read enough lately but I think they achieved the increase in capacity not by changing the physical structure but in how it is written and read. Yes, it would appear so if they can do it on two platters within a standard form factor. Amazing technology.