Re: 1.0 release, and graduation

2011-09-30 Thread Jukka Zitting
Hi, On Tue, Sep 27, 2011 at 3:05 PM, Karl Wright wrote: > The nature of this project is unique in that only a few committers are > interested in any given connector. This is very similar to the concern we used to have with Tika, that most people are only really interested in a narrow subset (i.e

Re: 1.0 release, and graduation

2011-09-27 Thread Karl Wright
Hi Jukka, >> Graduating into a Lucene subproject is probably out of the question given the structural changes in Lucene, so for now my recommendation would be to remain in the Incubator until the community balance gets better. ... To put things in perspective, since the beginning of this year

Re: 1.0 release, and graduation

2011-09-21 Thread Alex Ott
Hello We can put following script (in attachment) to simplify setup of missing maven dependencies that are fetched using 'ant download-dependencies' command. After using this script I was able to build everything using maven. One more comment is on tests - maybe it's better to put long-running te

Re: 1.0 release, and graduation

2011-09-21 Thread Jukka Zitting
Hi, On Mon, Sep 19, 2011 at 9:06 PM, Karl Wright wrote: > (a) what we are still missing as far as incubator graduation is concerned There's still quite a bit to be done for community diversity. The drive to get new committers in is definitely a step in the right direction, but we'll need to foll

Re: 1.0 release, and graduation

2011-09-21 Thread Alex Ott
Hello On Wed, Sep 21, 2011 at 9:43 AM, Tommaso Teofili wrote: >> (2) I'm not sure it is reasonable to go with one build system over >> another.  Lucene/Solr has been having this battle for years.  I >> thought we might just learn from that experience and try to be more >> flexible.  There are exc

Re: 1.0 release, and graduation

2011-09-21 Thread Tommaso Teofili
Hello Karl 2011/9/21 Karl Wright > Hi Tommaso, > > Thanks for your feedback! > > Are you in a position to update the status page? I don't think I can. > I should be able to do it, will try and see if I can get that updated finally :) > If you disagree please point me in the right direction.

AW: 1.0 release, and graduation

2011-09-21 Thread Wunderlich, Tobias
(1) If MySQL support is something important then I will triage the appropriate ticket accordingly. I'm curious where this requirement comes from, though. For my part, I'd realy like MySQL support. At the moment I just modified the jdbc-connector for my purposes, but an out of the box connector

Re: 1.0 release, and graduation

2011-09-20 Thread Karl Wright
Hi Tommaso, Thanks for your feedback! Are you in a position to update the status page? I don't think I can. If you disagree please point me in the right direction.. As far as the technical aspects: (1) If MySQL support is something important then I will triage the appropriate ticket according

Re: 1.0 release, and graduation

2011-09-20 Thread Tommaso Teofili
Hello Karl, all 2011/9/19 Karl Wright > Folks, > I'd like to begin discussion about the next release, currently labeled > 0.4, and also our potential for graduation from the incubator. What > I'd like is a sense of: > > (a) what we are still missing as far as incubator graduation is concerned,

1.0 release, and graduation

2011-09-19 Thread Karl Wright
Folks, I'd like to begin discussion about the next release, currently labeled 0.4, and also our potential for graduation from the incubator. What I'd like is a sense of: (a) what we are still missing as far as incubator graduation is concerned, and (b) what a 1.0 release might look like to everyo