Re: [documentation-dev] Question about the right for using Screenshots of OOo on Microsoft Windows

2006-11-26 Thread Alex Thurgood
Andre Schnabel wrote: We cannot get to a consensus as long as we do not know, what we talk about. Just to say we address legal issues is much to genereal to get any consensus. Maybe we should mention to users the potential impact of using copyrighted material belonging to others. We don't

Re: [documentation-dev] Question about the right for using Screenshots of OOo on Microsoft Windows

2006-11-26 Thread Sophie Gautier
Hi Alex, Andre, Alex Thurgood wrote: Andre Schnabel wrote: We cannot get to a consensus as long as we do not know, what we talk about. Just to say we address legal issues is much to genereal to get any consensus. Maybe we should mention to users the potential impact of using copyrighted

Re: [documentation-dev] Question about the right for using Screenshots of OOo on Microsoft Windows

2006-11-26 Thread Alex Thurgood
Sophie Gautier wrote: Thanks for your input Sophie, I appreciate it. Haven't got time to respond in depth to your comments now, I'll come back to you later. ;-) Alex - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For

Re: [documentation-dev] Question about the right for using Screenshots of OOo on Microsoft Windows

2006-11-25 Thread Alex Thurgood
G. Roderick Singleton wrote: So where's the problem if we do that and do all the proper recognition of trademarks et cetera. e.g. Windows(R), Solaris(R) in the text body. The problem is that the law is not the same throughout the world, nor is it applied in the same way. However, and

Re: [documentation-dev] Question about the right for using Screenshots of OOo on Microsoft Windows

2006-11-24 Thread Alex Thurgood
G. Roderick Singleton wrote: Hi Ger, However, I would like to ask if what you have suggested is Sun policy? Sort of like the reply-to path provided by you news2mail gateway. It might be good to remind ourselves that Sun signed a least one agreement with Microsoft relating to the use of IP

Re: [documentation-dev] Question about the right for using Screenshots of OOo on Microsoft Windows

2006-11-24 Thread G. Roderick Singleton
On Fri, 2006-11-24 at 14:35 +0100, Alex Thurgood wrote: G. Roderick Singleton wrote: Hi Ger, However, I would like to ask if what you have suggested is Sun policy? Sort of like the reply-to path provided by you news2mail gateway. It might be good to remind ourselves that Sun signed

Re: [documentation-dev] Question about the right for using Screenshots of OOo on Microsoft Windows

2006-11-19 Thread Jean-Francois Nifenecker
Alex Thurgood a écrit : The question to be raised IMHO is one of managing risk, even if that risk is perceived to be insignificant or any claim unfounded : can the organizers (obviously not Sun and Novell, since they seem to have struck deals that have taken the edge out such threats of

Re: [documentation-dev] Question about the right for using Screenshots of OOo on Microsoft Windows

2006-11-16 Thread Alex Thurgood
marbux wrote: Sigrid, I can not speak to German law, but I suspect it is not different in relative substance from that in the U.S. Under U.S. law, the Microsoft conditions are downright silly and are unenforceable. (I stress, however, that I have retired from the practice of law and am no longer

Re: [documentation-dev] Question about the right for using Screenshots of OOo on Microsoft Windows

2006-11-14 Thread Juergen Schmidt
Walter A. March wrote: What if we don't have a UNIX OS? Just Windows. I do hope I can still contribute! you can at least provide the data, info, description ... how to create an appropriate document window to take the screenshot ;-) The description should enable other users to do it for you.

Re: [documentation-dev] Question about the right for using Screenshots of OOo on Microsoft Windows

2006-11-14 Thread Scott Carr
I can't believe the Microsoft would have that much of an issue with this. The only thing I can see someone doing with a screenshot would be to circle a button or something. Is this really something we need to worry about? If it is, then I would suggest looking into Knoppix for doing

Re: [documentation-dev] Question about the right for using Screenshots of OOo on Microsoft Windows

2006-11-11 Thread Walter A. March
What if we don't have a UNIX OS? Just Windows. I do hope I can still contribute! Frank Peters wrote: I agree. We should not start getting involved into a long, tiring, and potentially dangerous legal argument and just don't use Windows screenshots any more. Stick to a UNIX OS for screenshots

Re: [documentation-dev] Question about the right for using Screenshots of OOo on Microsoft Windows

2006-11-11 Thread G. Roderick Singleton
On Sat, 2006-11-11 at 07:22 -0500, Walter A. March wrote: What if we don't have a UNIX OS? Just Windows. I do hope I can still contribute! I have been using the (R) after most uses of Windows in new documents. I say most because I have not automated the process as yet. I have been using All

RE: [documentation-dev] Question about the right for using Screenshots of OOo on Microsoft Windows

2006-11-08 Thread Peter M. Damiana
Dear Sigrid, I suggest that if Microsoft is being difficult about this issue, then we should simply make screenshots by using other OS, since OOo works practically the same way on all OS'. Regards Peter -Original Message- From: Sigrid Kronenberger [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent:

Re: [documentation-dev] Question about the right for using Screenshots of OOo on Microsoft Windows

2006-11-08 Thread marbux
Sigrid, I can not speak to German law, but I suspect it is not different in relative substance from that in the U.S. Under U.S. law, the Microsoft conditions are downright silly and are unenforceable. (I stress, however, that I have retired from the practice of law and am no longer allowed to