[discussion] Install statistics for SME Server

2014-03-05 Thread Tony Keane
Hi All We are wanting to start showing the world how many servers are actually installed around the world and to facilitate this we have started creating a map showing the locations of the installs. (These are only down to the Town or Country of install) To view the current map and graph go

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server

2014-03-06 Thread Jesper Knudsen
: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server Hi All We are wanting to start showing the world how many servers are actually installed around the world and to facilitate this we have started creating a map showing the locations of the installs. (These are only down to the Town or Country of

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server

2014-03-06 Thread AllesKunst.net ID GmbH - Rudolf Vielnascher
sday, March 06, 2014 2:33 PM Subject: Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server Hi Tony, I did something similar some years back but gathered the data automatically through the contribs I have published (Sme-unjunkmgr and Dansguardian-stats). If you want to show something that anyone

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server

2014-03-06 Thread John Crisp
On 06/03/14 14:50, AllesKunst.net ID GmbH - Rudolf Vielnascher wrote: > Showing only the installs that tell you, will show a very lonesome > comunity. > I think you may have missed the point of what Tony is doing. Currently we have no way of knowing what servers we have and where. The stuff he

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server

2014-03-07 Thread Dave Liquorice
On Thu, 06 Mar 2014 17:02:03 +0100, John Crisp wrote: > As we no longer have SMOLT ... Is that correct? My server still has smolt enabled and there is a boot time message about enabling the monthly smolt checkin. Looking at the config of smolt it points to smolt.contribs.org. I note the commen

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2014-03-07 Thread chris burnat
On 03/08/2014 05:08 AM, Dave Liquorice wrote: On Thu, 06 Mar 2014 17:02:03 +0100, John Crisp wrote: As we no longer have SMOLT ... Is that correct? My server still has smolt enabled and there is a boot time message about enabling the monthly smolt checkin. Looking at the config of smolt it po

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2014-03-07 Thread chris burnat
On 03/08/2014 10:26 AM, chris burnat wrote: https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Smolt_retirement It may be worth going back to this bug, there is a lot of information, in particular from Greg and JPP. SMOLT could possibly be resurrected? Also: https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Smolt_retirement and:

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2014-03-08 Thread Jesper Knudsen
...@lists.contribs.org [mailto:discussion-boun...@lists.contribs.org] On Behalf Of chris burnat Sent: 8. marts 2014 01:04 To: Dave Liquorice; discussion@lists.contribs.org Cc: Charlie Brady Subject: Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT] On 03/08/2014 10:26 AM, chris burnat wrote

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2014-03-08 Thread Hsing-Foo Wang
: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT] On 03/08/2014 10:26 AM, chris burnat wrote: https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Smolt_retirement It may be worth going back to this bug, there is a lot of information, in particular from Greg and JPP. SMOLT could possibly be resurrected

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2014-03-08 Thread stephane de Labrusse
riginal Message- From: > discussion-boun...@lists.contribs.org > [mailto:discussion-boun...@lists.contribs.org] On Behalf Of chris > burnat Sent: 8. marts 2014 01:04 To: Dave Liquorice; > discussion@lists.contribs.org Cc: Charlie Brady Subject: Re: > [discussion] Install statistics fo

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2014-03-08 Thread John Crisp
ailto:discussion-boun...@lists.contribs.org] On Behalf Of chris >burnat >Sent: 8. marts 2014 01:04 >To: Dave Liquorice; discussion@lists.contribs.org >Cc: Charlie Brady >Subject: Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT] > > >On 03/08/2014 10:26 AM, chris

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2014-03-09 Thread Jonathan Martens
On 8-3-2014 21:52, stephane de Labrusse wrote: -BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Hi i worry that these statistics are a bit against the private life of our sysadmin and users. Have we already take statistics like that ? Even if the data can not be traced back to the server and only

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2014-03-09 Thread Hsing-Foo Wang
Hi Jonathan, nice to see you back around. The 'Test Internet Connection' in the console app 'phones home' with data. Let's take a look at that. I personally think that the data submitted should only contain: a. Install date b. Version c. GeoIP location d. Unique installer code regarding d.

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2014-03-09 Thread Jonathan Martens
On 9-3-2014 20:47, Hsing-Foo Wang wrote: Hi Jonathan, nice to see you back around. I have been around, although laying low and will be around and every now and then chime in with my meaning, ideas etc. although I can not dedicate the time I did before at the moment. The 'Test Internet Connecti

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2014-03-09 Thread Hsing-Foo Wang
On 9-3-2014 21:05, Jonathan Martens wrote: On 9-3-2014 20:47, Hsing-Foo Wang wrote: Hi Jonathan, nice to see you back around. I have been around, although laying low and will be around and every now and then chime in with my meaning, ideas etc. although I can not dedicate the time I did befo

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2014-03-09 Thread Jesper Knudsen
r From: discussion-boun...@lists.contribs.org [mailto:discussion-boun...@lists.contribs.org] On Behalf Of Hsing-Foo Wang Sent: 9. marts 2014 21:24 To: discussion@lists.contribs.org Subject: Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT] On 9-3-2014 21:05, Jonathan Martens wrot

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2014-03-10 Thread Jonathan Martens
On 9-3-2014 23:33, Jesper Knudsen wrote: The only think that this would "reveal" beyond what a YUM update does is a unique ID and install date (why do we need that?). I do not think we need an opt-in for that. Basically, as long as the data gathering is so simple I do not even think a unique

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2014-03-10 Thread Jesper Knudsen
bs.org] On Behalf Of Jonathan Martens Sent: 10. marts 2014 09:58 To: discussion@lists.contribs.org Subject: Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT] On 9-3-2014 23:33, Jesper Knudsen wrote: The only think that this would "reveal" beyond what a YUM update does is a unique

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2014-03-10 Thread Hsing-Foo Wang
ts 2014 09:58 *To:* discussion@lists.contribs.org *Subject:* Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT] On 9-3-2014 23:33, Jesper Knudsen wrote: The only think that this would "reveal" beyond what a YUM update does is a unique ID and install date (why do we need that?).

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2014-03-10 Thread Jesper Knudsen
Hsing-Foo Wang Sent: 10. marts 2014 15:40 To: discussion@lists.contribs.org Subject: Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT] I hope Shad would be willing to speak up, for he is fully aware and maintained all 'phone home' and install UUID, EPOCH stuff. Hopefully it wi

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2014-03-10 Thread Hsing-Foo Wang
ussion-boun...@lists.contribs.org> [mailto:discussion-boun...@lists.contribs.org] *On Behalf Of *Jonathan Martens *Sent:* 10. marts 2014 09:58 *To:* discussion@lists.contribs.org <mailto:discussion@lists.contribs.org> *Subject:* Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMO

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2014-03-10 Thread Jesper Knudsen
@lists.contribs.org Subject: Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT] Right, I was looking for the install epoch and there it is ;-) Now for the GeoIP data? otherwise it would be difficult to map geographically right? On 10-3-2014 16:39, Jesper Knudsen wrote: The config DB

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2014-03-10 Thread Hsing-Foo Wang
bs.org *Subject:* Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT] Right, I was looking for the install epoch and there it is ;-) Now for the GeoIP data? otherwise it would be difficult to map geographically right? On 10-3-2014 16:39, Jesper Knudsen wrote: The config DB seems to h

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2014-03-10 Thread Jesper Knudsen
oo Wang Sent: 10. marts 2014 16:45 To: discussion@lists.contribs.org Subject: Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT] Right, I was looking for the install epoch and there it is ;-) Now for the GeoIP data? otherwise it would be difficult to map geographically right? On 10-3-20

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2014-03-10 Thread Shad L. Lords
On Mon, Mar 10, 2014 at 3:22 PM, Jesper Knudsen wrote: > All, > > > > I have now created both the script (Perl) that gathers data on all the SME > servers and also the Backend (PHP, MySQL) that collects and store the data. > Supports SME 7x and 8x (tested) and most likely also 9x. > > > > Currentl

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2014-03-11 Thread Jonathan Martens
On 10-3-2014 23:13, Shad L. Lords wrote: This information is already being collected. Why do we need a separate script to collect this information? Is there a way to access that to dynamically or periodically to generate the map? Kind regards, Jonathan ___

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2014-03-11 Thread Shad L. Lords
On Tue, Mar 11, 2014 at 1:44 AM, Jonathan Martens wrote: > On 10-3-2014 23:13, Shad L. Lords wrote: > >> This information is already being collected. Why do we need a separate >> script to collect this information? >> > Is there a way to access that to dynamically or periodically to generate > th

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2014-03-11 Thread Jesper Knudsen
[mailto:discussion-boun...@lists.contribs.org] On Behalf Of Shad L. Lords Sent: 11. marts 2014 15:20 To: Jonathan Martens Cc: discussion@lists.contribs.org Subject: Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT] On Tue, Mar 11, 2014 at 1:44 AM, Jonathan Martens wrote: On 10-3-2014 23:13

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2014-03-11 Thread Shad L. Lords
On Tue, Mar 11, 2014 at 1:14 PM, Jesper Knudsen wrote: > Can you elaborate on what exactly is being collected and how? > > > > Unless the data is not enough for the planned purpose I see absolutely no > need to create a separate script - that would be waste of good energy. > Currently ReleaseVers

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2014-03-11 Thread Jesper Knudsen
t: 11. marts 2014 20:54 To: Jesper Knudsen Cc: Jonathan Martens; discussion@lists.contribs.org Subject: Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT] On Tue, Mar 11, 2014 at 1:14 PM, Jesper Knudsen wrote: Can you elaborate on what exactly is being collected and how? Unless the

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2014-03-14 Thread Jesper Knudsen
ks, Jesper From: Shad L. Lords [mailto:slo...@lordsfam.net] Sent: 11. marts 2014 20:54 To: Jesper Knudsen Cc: Jonathan Martens; discussion@lists.contribs.org Subject: Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT] On Tue, Mar 11, 2014 at 1:14 PM, Jesper Knudsen wrote: Can you

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2015-01-17 Thread stephane de Labrusse
.@swerts-knudsen.dk] *Sent:* 11. > marts 2014 22:43 *To:* 'Shad L. Lords' *Cc:* 'Jonathan Martens'; > 'discussion@lists.contribs.org' *Subject:* RE: [discussion] Install > statistics for SME Server [SMOLT] > > > > Shad, > > > > Woul

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2015-01-24 Thread Jesper Knudsen
[mailto:discussion-boun...@lists.contribs.org] On Behalf Of stephane de Labrusse Sent: 18. januar 2015 00:28 To: discussion@lists.contribs.org Subject: Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT] -BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Hi All I would wake up this discussion Now the

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2015-01-25 Thread Jesper Knudsen
@swerts-knudsen.dk] Sent: 24. januar 2015 17:30 To: 'stephane de Labrusse'; 'discussion@lists.contribs.org' Subject: RE: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT] The PHP script that gathers the data from the Perl script you have linked to is availab

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2015-01-25 Thread stephane de Labrusse
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Le 25/01/2015 17:25, Jesper Knudsen a écrit : > And I would very much like to lead this project but ONLY if it's > something that is going to be widely - hence distributed as part of > the core SME. If its something that is shared in the forum, then >

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2015-01-25 Thread Terry Fage
On 26/01/2015 4:33 AM, stephane de Labrusse wrote: > Then you should open a bug, and see with Daniel, how we can do that > and see which Data will be gathered. If this is going to be done, it needs to be in the next ISO, no good talking about things as it just languishes in discussions. If it is

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2015-01-25 Thread Charlie Brady
On Sun, 25 Jan 2015, Jesper Knudsen wrote: > I also think that there should a central group that gathers stats for the > individual contribs (when they have been "approved") so that we know which > is used and which is not. Hundred years ago I made something called a > "egometer" basically just g

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2015-01-25 Thread stephane de Labrusse
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Le 25/01/2015 20:21, Charlie Brady a écrit : > > On Sun, 25 Jan 2015, Jesper Knudsen wrote: > >> I also think that there should a central group that gathers stats >> for the individual contribs (when they have been "approved") so >> that we know whic

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2015-01-25 Thread Jesper Knudsen
discussion@lists.contribs.org Subject: Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT] On Sun, 25 Jan 2015, Jesper Knudsen wrote: > I also think that there should a central group that gathers stats for > the individual contribs (when they have been "approved") so that we > know w

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2015-01-25 Thread Daniel Berteaud
Le 25/01/2015 19:10, Terry Fage a écrit : > On 26/01/2015 4:33 AM, stephane de Labrusse wrote: >> Then you should open a bug, and see with Daniel, how we can do that >> and see which Data will be gathered. > If this is going to be done, it needs to be in the next ISO, no good > talking about thing

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2015-01-25 Thread charlieb-contribs-discussion
On Sun, 25 Jan 2015, stephane de Labrusse wrote: > We could add a disclaimer in the installer anaconda if needed, but i'm > sure that every projects collect data on the use of their products. I am sure that they don't. > We (as free software) will do in transparency, And that is what I am advo

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2015-01-25 Thread stephane de Labrusse
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Le 25/01/2015 21:01, charlieb-contribs-discuss...@budge.apana.org.au a écrit : > I am sure that they don't. I have found one in 5 minutes https://developer.android.com/about/dashboards/index.html But I agree Google is the evil - -- Cordialement St

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2015-01-25 Thread Hsing-Foo Wang
On 01/25/2015 08:59 PM, Daniel Berteaud wrote: Le 25/01/2015 19:10, Terry Fage a écrit : On 26/01/2015 4:33 AM, stephane de Labrusse wrote: Then you should open a bug, and see with Daniel, how we can do that and see which Data will be gathered. If this is going to be done, it needs to be in t

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2015-01-25 Thread Charlie Brady
On Sun, 25 Jan 2015, stephane de Labrusse wrote: > -BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- > Hash: SHA1 > > Le 25/01/2015 21:01, charlieb-contribs-discuss...@budge.apana.org.au a > écrit : > > I am sure that they don't. > I have found one in 5 minutes I was saying that I am sure that not all projec

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2015-01-25 Thread Jesper Knudsen
: stephane de Labrusse Cc: j...@swerts-knudsen.dk; discussion@lists.contribs.org Subject: Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT] On Sun, 25 Jan 2015, stephane de Labrusse wrote: > -BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- > Hash: SHA1 > > Le 25/01/2015 21:01, charlieb-cont

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2015-01-25 Thread Terry Fage
On 26/01/2015 6:59 AM, Daniel Berteaud wrote: > > I agree, but it need some work: Good, thats at least more than one, some consensus :-) > > - How to enable it (opt-in, opt-out ? In the console of the initial > configuration ?) Opt out is the only option that should be offered, yes at the initia

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2015-01-25 Thread Dave Liquorice
On Mon, 26 Jan 2015 07:21:41 +1100, Terry Fage wrote: >>> I agree, but it need some work: > > Good, thats at least more than one, some consensus :-) +1 and +1 for the rest of Terry's comments until: >> - The hard part is what to do with this data. Should it be made publicly >> available, are the

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2015-01-25 Thread stephane de Labrusse
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Le 25/01/2015 22:19, Dave Liquorice a écrit : > A list of servers giving the number of active installations and > version per country should be pretty safe but a map you can zoom in > on and find an individual servers location, even very loosely, I > r

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2015-01-25 Thread Dave Liquorice
On Sun, 25 Jan 2015 22:26:38 +0100, stephane de Labrusse wrote: >> A list of servers giving the number of active installations and >> version per country should be pretty safe but a map you can zoom in >> on and find an individual servers location, even very loosely, I >> really don't like at all.

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2015-01-25 Thread Jesper Knudsen
city - it's irrelevant. -Original Message- From: discussion-boun...@lists.contribs.org [mailto:discussion-boun...@lists.contribs.org] On Behalf Of Dave Liquorice Sent: 26. januar 2015 01:23 To: discussion@lists.contribs.org Subject: Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2015-01-26 Thread stephane de Labrusse
ts.contribs.org > [mailto:discussion-boun...@lists.contribs.org] On Behalf Of Dave > Liquorice Sent: 26. januar 2015 01:23 To: > discussion@lists.contribs.org Subject: Re: [discussion] Install > statistics for SME Server [SMOLT] > > On Sun, 25 Jan 2015 22:26:38 +0100, stephane de

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2015-01-26 Thread Ian Wells
On 1/25/2015 11:59 AM, Daniel Berteaud wrote: Le 25/01/2015 19:10, Terry Fage a écrit : On 26/01/2015 4:33 AM, stephane de Labrusse wrote: Then you should open a bug, and see with Daniel, how we can do that and see which Data will be gathered. If this is going to be done, it needs to be in th

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2015-01-26 Thread Terry Fage
On 27/01/2015 2:42 AM, stephane de Labrusse wrote: > It is fun to see servers on a Map, because you see friends around you > and it is interesting to see the repartition per towns in a country. > Indeed if you take as example Australia, quite sure that all are in > the east and it is the same in Fr

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2015-01-26 Thread Charlie Brady
Terry, before we go building something new, how about we determine what information is already available from all the yum updates happening on a regular bases? On Tue, 27 Jan 2015, Terry Fage wrote: > On 27/01/2015 2:42 AM, stephane de Labrusse wrote: > > It is fun to see servers on a Map, bec

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2015-01-26 Thread Terry Fage
On 27/01/2015 9:41 AM, Charlie Brady wrote: > > Terry, before we go building something new, how about we determine what > information is already available from all the yum updates happening on a > regular bases? No problems, I know I sound a tad strident and do no dev work and just sit on the o

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2015-01-26 Thread Jesper Knudsen
--Original Message- From: discussion-boun...@lists.contribs.org [mailto:discussion-boun...@lists.contribs.org] On Behalf Of Charlie Brady Sent: 26. januar 2015 23:42 To: Terry Fage Cc: discussion@lists.contribs.org Subject: Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT] Terry, be

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2015-01-26 Thread Daniel Berteaud
Le 26/01/2015 23:03, Terry Fage a écrit : > On 27/01/2015 2:42 AM, stephane de Labrusse wrote: >> It is fun to see servers on a Map, because you see friends around you >> and it is interesting to see the repartition per towns in a country. >> Indeed if you take as example Australia, quite sure tha

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2015-01-27 Thread Terry Fage
On 27/01/2015 6:50 PM, Daniel Berteaud wrote: > Finally, we barely have resources to maintain the distro right now. > Having install stats is a good thing, but not our top priority I think. > > For all this reasons, I see no way we can have it ready for the next ISO. Thats OK, at least its a posi

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2015-01-27 Thread stephane de Labrusse
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Le 27/01/2015 08:50, Daniel Berteaud a écrit : > For all this reasons, I see no way we can have it ready for the > next ISO. I would agree, but I want to paraphrase someone who will recognize himself: Do something We will see after what and when. We

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2015-01-27 Thread Charlie Brady
On Tue, 27 Jan 2015, stephane de Labrusse wrote: > I would agree, but I want to paraphrase someone who will recognize > himself: Do something OK, so create a bug in the webserver/infrastructure category, to start data-mining the mirrorlists.contribs.org access logs, using GEO IP. _

Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT]

2015-01-28 Thread Jesper Knudsen
Subject: Re: [discussion] Install statistics for SME Server [SMOLT] On Tue, 27 Jan 2015, stephane de Labrusse wrote: > I would agree, but I want to paraphrase someone who will recognize > himself: Do something OK, so create a bug in the webserver/infrastructure category, to start data-mini