Re: [Elecraft] CB band TX? - I'm shocked!

2007-12-23 Thread Phil Kane
On Thu, 20 Dec 2007 05:49:49 +, David Pratt wrote: >It is fortunate that the CB bands can be disabled in K3 >firmware. As Eric and Wayne will agree, if any ham transmitter or kit sold commercially transmits in the CB band, it must be type certified for such use before it can be marketed

Re: [Elecraft] CB band TX? - I'm shocked! [END of THREAD]

2007-12-20 Thread Eric Swartz - WA6HHQ, Elecraft
Guys - Seriously, let's end this thread for now. 73, Eric WA6HHQ Elecraft List Moderator ___ Elecraft mailing list Post to: Elecraft@mailman.qth.net You must be a subscriber to post to the list. Subscriber Info (Addr. Change, sub, unsub etc.): http

Re: [Elecraft] CB band TX? - I'm shocked!

2007-12-20 Thread Kevin Cozens
Fred (FL) wrote: Simple - it is illegal. You cannot use a HF ham rig to work in the marine bands, to work in the CB bands. Is this spelled out in the rules or is this from an interpretation of the rules? AFAIK, the issue with ham transmitters and CB radio is one of maximum output power. The

SV: [Elecraft] CB band TX? - I'm shocked!

2007-12-20 Thread Björn Mohr
Craig VK3HE wrote; >> Whats also concerning is that this decision has been made only from the perspective >> of US laws not even taking into consideration the international market. US hams seems to have an interesting relationship with CB, dating back to the time when FCC took the 27MHz band ou

Re: [Elecraft] CB band TX? - I'm shocked!

2007-12-20 Thread Eric Swartz - WA6HHQ Elecraft
Guys - Let's end this thread. It is one of those that will repeat forever ;-) The K3 was primarily designed for ham band coverage with a wider general coverage receive. Its not guaranteed to TX at full power everywhere outside the ham bands when so enabled, though it should cover most MARS fr

[Elecraft] CB band TX? - I'm shocked!

2007-12-20 Thread Fred (FL)
Simple - it is illegal. You cannot use a HF ham rig to work in the marine bands, to work in the CB bands. Perhaps the FCC isn't watching all the time, but they can be directed to do so. It would be just illegal, for anyone to try to use a K3 or any FCC certified amateur HF rig to attempt to trans

RE: [Elecraft] CB band TX? - I'm shocked!

2007-12-20 Thread Larry K1UO
Richard Kent wrote: > > > > Maybe there was another > answer all along we did not know it. Maybe the popularity of the CB band > has > dwindled to the point that it is not the hot spot we remember. > or maybe the FCC will give us back the 11 meter band that used to be a Ham band! yeahr

Re: [Elecraft] CB band TX? - I'm shocked!

2007-12-20 Thread Joe-aa4nn
Not me, I am CW only and never get above 28.050mHz. de Joe, aa4nn ! > Whatever happened to minding your own business. If Joe wants to open his > radio to all freqs so be it. Maybe he has a good reason. Does it affect > anyone else? No. > ___ Elec

Re: [Elecraft] CB band TX? - I'm shocked!

2007-12-20 Thread Mike Fatchett W0MU
Whatever happened to minding your own business. If Joe wants to open his radio to all freqs so be it. Maybe he has a good reason. Does it affect anyone else? No. Ham Radio is starting to remind me of all the homeowner's associations that are run by older folks that have nothing better to do

RE: [Elecraft] CB band TX? - I'm shocked!

2007-12-20 Thread Richard Kent
-Original Message- Before Eric Stops this thread, This is a point I have wondered about for a long time. In the US, it has been illegal to use CB frequencies since the late 70's. To the hams this mean that transverters had only 2 Mhz to work with (28-30mhz) as an IF. This means that a 6

Re: [Elecraft] CB band TX? - I'm shocked!

2007-12-20 Thread Goody K3NG
David Pratt wrote: In a recent message Goody K3NG <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes >>I'm not in favor of breaking the law, but I think the chances of running into the FCC today are slim to none. If you don't identify with your ham callsign while using a ham rig on FRS or CB frequencies, it's unlike

Re: [Elecraft] CB band TX? - I'm shocked!

2007-12-20 Thread Leo Bricker K5LDB
I'm just a dumb ole country boy that somehow wound up in a big city. A few thoughts on this subject, in no particular order, would be as follows. 1. Plan before acting. 2. Use the right tool for the job. 3. Count to 10 before diving into something. 4. Use your common sense before using anything

Re: [Elecraft] CB band TX? - I'm shocked!

2007-12-20 Thread Jim Cundiff
Good morning all, I just had to reply to this thread. First let me say that I MEAN NO DISRESPECT TO ANYONE! JUST MY OPINIONS! Speaking as the past ARES EC for Baltimore, I see no reason to TX on out of band freqs. My group trained on several occasions with a REACT (the CB equivalent to AR

Re: [Elecraft] CB band TX? - I'm shocked!

2007-12-20 Thread Brendan Minish
On Thu, 2007-12-20 at 17:15 +1100, Shaun Oliver wrote: > I quite agree. even the vaunted yaesu ft817 with a few jumper > modifications can be made for general coverage tx. > shaun. the FT817 can have general coverage TX enabled and have it's region changed by software alone. A firmware reset res

Re: [Elecraft] CB band TX? - I'm shocked!

2007-12-20 Thread Craig
Whats also concerning is that this decision has been made only from the perspective of US laws not even taking into consideration the international market. In Australia there is a legal 27mhz marine band that is monitored and has full legal status just as the VHF FM marine band does. Its use i

Re: [Elecraft] CB band TX? - I'm shocked!

2007-12-19 Thread dj7mgq
Hi Michael, wondering if there is any RF design considerations that would restrict or limit transmission within its operating frequencies extremes. The bandpasses, I would assume. They appear to be fairly narrow. vy 73 de toby ___ Elecraft mailing

Re: [Elecraft] CB band TX? - I'm shocked!

2007-12-19 Thread Thom LaCosta
On Wed, 19 Dec 2007, Mike Fatchett W0MU wrote: Or better yet a list of those that were fined or sanction for attempting to assist in an emergency. In my nearly 30 years as a ham I can't ever recall someone getting in trouble for trying to help. Based on my own experience with regulators and

Re: [Elecraft] CB band TX? - I'm shocked!

2007-12-19 Thread Shaun Oliver
I quite agree. even the vaunted yaesu ft817 with a few jumper modifications can be made for general coverage tx. shaun. On 20/12/2007 4:49 PM, the old scribe known as David Pratt was able to impart this pearl of wisdom: In a recent message Goody K3NG <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes I'm not in favo

Re: [Elecraft] CB band TX? - I'm shocked!

2007-12-19 Thread David Pratt
In a recent message Goody K3NG <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes I'm not in favor of breaking the law, but I think the chances of running into the FCC today are slim to none. If you don't identify with your ham callsign while using a ham rig on FRS or CB frequencies, it's unlikely anyone, even the FC

RE: [Elecraft] CB band TX? - I'm shocked!

2007-12-19 Thread Ron D'Eau Claire
Here on the Oregon coast where hurricane force winds are a regular event several times each winter, our community emergency team relies on Amateur radio, CB and "Family Radio" for communications. However, I'd not want to combine them into one rig. That would prevent simultaneous use by several pe

Re: [Elecraft] CB band TX? - I'm shocked!

2007-12-19 Thread michael taylor
On Dec 19, 2007 1:52 PM, Ken Kopp <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Eric's reply (below) reads as if the K3 will TX in the 27 mHz > CB band as built. Surely no self-respecting Elecraft owner I was wondering, my understanding is that this transmit limitation is a firmware based restriction, so _in theo

Re: [Elecraft] CB band TX? - I'm shocked!

2007-12-19 Thread Goody K3NG
I'm not in favor of breaking the law, but I think the chances of running into the FCC today are slim to none. If you don't identify with your ham callsign while using a ham rig on FRS or CB frequencies, it's unlikely anyone, even the FCC will know a difference, or even care. The FCC can't eve

[Elecraft] CB band TX? - I'm shocked!

2007-12-19 Thread Ken Kopp
Eric, please read your message (below), not for what you probably meant to say, but for what the words actually say. It tells the reader that "high power TX in the CB band " is always blocked, and doesn't say "TX in the CB band is blocked". Your wording clearly indicates that it only blocks

Re: [Elecraft] CB band TX? - I'm shocked!

2007-12-19 Thread Mike Fatchett W0MU
Or better yet a list of those that were fined or sanction for attempting to assist in an emergency. In my nearly 30 years as a ham I can't ever recall someone getting in trouble for trying to help. On 12/19/07 6:45 PM, "Thom LaCosta" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > On Wed, 19 Dec 2007, Phil Kane

Re: [Elecraft] CB band TX? - I'm shocked!

2007-12-19 Thread Thom LaCosta
On Wed, 19 Dec 2007, Phil Kane wrote: And what excuse are you going to rely on if the FCC declares that the "out-of-band" communication did not meet the very specific and narrow "window" permitting "any frequency, any power"? Based on your professional expertise and history, it might be va

Re: [Elecraft] CB band TX? - I'm shocked!

2007-12-19 Thread Phil Kane
On Wed, 19 Dec 2007 18:12:05 -0500, Goody K3NG wrote: > Recently our county has been getting its act together in regards > to Emcomm, so we've been doing drills and educational programs at > meetings. As an amateur, you need to be prepared to communicate > on non-ham frequencies, like FRS or CB.

Re: [Elecraft] CB band TX? - I'm shocked!

2007-12-19 Thread Thom LaCosta
On Thu, 20 Dec 2007, KBG Luxford wrote: The local Radio Frequency Authority took a sensible attitude. A ham rig is not "type approved" for the CB frequency, but the Department apparently took the view that the regulations never envisioned that type of emergency need, and that the preservation

Re: [Elecraft] CB band TX? - I'm shocked!

2007-12-19 Thread KBG Luxford
There has been at least one case of emergency in the Oz outback where the ability to transmit on a CB frequency by a ham has brought a welcome response. The local Radio Frequency Authority took a sensible attitude. A ham rig is not "type approved" for the CB frequency, but the Department app

RE: [Elecraft] CB band TX? - I'm shocked!

2007-12-19 Thread Ed Lambert
Amen Ed KD3Y > -Original Message- > From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:elecraft- > [EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Goody K3NG > Sent: Wednesday, December 19, 2007 6:12 PM > To: Elecraft List > Subject: Re: [Elecraft] CB band TX? - I'm shocked! > > I don

Re: [Elecraft] CB band TX? - I'm shocked!

2007-12-19 Thread Goody K3NG
I don't see a problem with CB transmit capabilities. In fact, I think it should be configurable by the end user. Let me explain. Recently our county has been getting its act together in regards to Emcomm, so we've been doing drills and educational programs at meetings. As an amateur, you ne

Re: [Elecraft] CB band TX? - I'm shocked!

2007-12-19 Thread Thom LaCosta
At 01:52 PM 12/19/2007, Ken Kopp wrote: Eric's reply (below) reads as if the K3 will TX in the 27 mHz CB band as built. Surely no self-respecting Elecraft owner would soil his radio by transmitting in the CB band! Aw come onit's a matter of law, not self respectand the radio can't get

Re: [Elecraft] CB band TX? - I'm shocked!

2007-12-19 Thread Eric Swartz - WA6HHQ, Elecraft
Hi Ken - My email said exactly the opposite :-) The K3 -always- blocks TX in the CB band (except out the 0 dBm transverter port.) 73, Eric WA6HHQ Ken Kopp wrote: Eric's reply (below) reads as if the K3 will TX in the 27 mHz CB band as built. Surely no self-respecting Elecraft owner woul

[Elecraft] CB band TX? - I'm shocked!

2007-12-19 Thread Ken Kopp
Eric's reply (below) reads as if the K3 will TX in the 27 mHz CB band as built. Surely no self-respecting Elecraft owner would soil his radio by transmitting in the CB band! The radio should self-destruct if a user attempted to transmit there. It should -always- block CB band transmit. I don't