Re: [expert] Shorewall Follies - It's drivin' me NUTS!!

2002-12-05 Thread Mark Weaver
Jim C wrote: Jack Coates wrote: I know the shorewall question can be resolved, but as KevinO points out it shouldn't be resolved by someone who's not fully aware of the issues at stake. In the last five days I've gotten nearly a thousand denied attempts to relay spam mail through my server clog

Re: [expert] Shorewall Follies - It's drivin' me NUTS!!

2002-12-05 Thread Mark Weaver
Jack Coates wrote: I know the shorewall question can be resolved, but as KevinO points out it shouldn't be resolved by someone who's not fully aware of the issues at stake. In the last five days I've gotten nearly a thousand denied attempts to relay spam mail through my server clogging up my logs

RE: [expert] Shorewall Follies - It's drivin' me NUTS!!

2002-11-30 Thread Franki
ut the GUI, then I will. more FYI :-) rgds Frank -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]]On Behalf Of Jim C Sent: Sunday, 1 December 2002 2:32 AM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: [expert] Shorewall Follies - It's drivin' me NUTS!! Why not suggest

RE: [expert] Shorewall Follies - It's drivin' me NUTS!!

2002-11-30 Thread Franki
s iptables rules... Its on the same site as gShield. rgds Frank -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]]On Behalf Of Jim C Sent: Sunday, 1 December 2002 2:26 AM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: [expert] Shorewall Follies - It's drivin' me NUTS!!

Re: [expert] Shorewall Follies - It's drivin' me NUTS!!

2002-11-30 Thread J. Grant
Just use smoothwall.org its great, even if the developers are cocky and not arogant :) JG Jim C wrote: Why not suggest it? Surely they must have a means of getting input from thier users and if they don't have a suggestion box perhaps they should get one. Want to buy your Pack or Services f

Re: [expert] Shorewall Follies - It's drivin' me NUTS!!

2002-11-30 Thread Jim C
Why not suggest it? Surely they must have a means of getting input from thier users and if they don't have a suggestion box perhaps they should get one. Franki wrote: yeah, the new 2.8 version of gShield has alot of extra stuff I hadn't expected.. Its one very good firewall.. I've been using i

Re: [expert] Shorewall Follies - It's drivin' me NUTS!!

2002-11-30 Thread Jim C
Man, where were you 4 weeks ago. ;-) Franki wrote: yes, its called gShield.. (http://muse.linuxmafia.org/gshield.html) ... wrappers for this sort of thing, though. Want to buy your Pack or Services from MandrakeSoft? Go to http://www.mandrakestore.com

RE: [expert] Shorewall Follies - It's drivin' me NUTS!!

2002-11-30 Thread Franki
n't.. even support for stuff you have to patch iptables to use. rgds Frank -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]]On Behalf Of Ron Stodden Sent: Saturday, 30 November 2002 11:32 PM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: [expert] Shorewall Follies - It&#x

Re: [expert] Shorewall Follies - It's drivin' me NUTS!!

2002-11-30 Thread Ron Stodden
Jack Coates wrote: and I also recommended Monmotha for a reason :-) It's a lot easier than shorewall because it only battens down the external interface. I find gShield rated better than MonMotha. I use it. Very easy to install as well. http://muse.linuxmafia.org/gshield.html -- Ron. [Melb

RE: [expert] Shorewall Follies - It's drivin' me NUTS!!

2002-11-30 Thread Franki
m: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]]On Behalf Of Jim C Sent: Saturday, 30 November 2002 10:48 AM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: [expert] Shorewall Follies - It's drivin' me NUTS!! Jack Coates wrote: > I know the shorewall question can be resolved, but as KevinO points out >

Re: [expert] Shorewall Follies - It's drivin' me NUTS!!

2002-11-29 Thread James Sparenberg
On Fri, 2002-11-29 at 18:48, Jim C wrote: > Jack Coates wrote: > > I know the shorewall question can be resolved, but as KevinO points out > > it shouldn't be resolved by someone who's not fully aware of the issues > > at stake. > > > > In the last five days I've gotten nearly a thousand denied at

Re: [expert] Shorewall Follies - It's drivin' me NUTS!!

2002-11-29 Thread Jim C
Well I've got the shorewall rules for samba figured out. Please correct my work if I've made any mistakes. Port 445 is the port that XP/2K use for this purpose and the website did not take XP/2K into account. Port 631 is a network printer which may be important when I get around to putting u

Re: [expert] Shorewall Follies - It's drivin' me NUTS!!

2002-11-29 Thread Jack Coates
On Fri, 2002-11-29 at 18:48, Jim C wrote: > Jack Coates wrote: > > I know the shorewall question can be resolved, but as KevinO points out > > it shouldn't be resolved by someone who's not fully aware of the issues > > at stake. > > > > In the last five days I've gotten nearly a thousand denied at

Re: [expert] Shorewall Follies - It's drivin' me NUTS!!

2002-11-29 Thread Jim C
Jack Coates wrote: I know the shorewall question can be resolved, but as KevinO points out it shouldn't be resolved by someone who's not fully aware of the issues at stake. In the last five days I've gotten nearly a thousand denied attempts to relay spam mail through my server clogging up my logs

Re: [expert] Shorewall Follies - It's drivin' me NUTS!!

2002-11-29 Thread Jack Coates
http://www.monkeynoodle.org/lrp/lrp-firewall-faq.html you can grep /etc/services to see what the port is supposed to be used for. As far as what is really using it, netstat -atun and lsof might give you some clues, as well as telnet localhost [portnumber]. On Fri, 2002-11-29 at 15:21, Jim C wrote

Re: [expert] Shorewall Follies - It's drivin' me NUTS!!

2002-11-29 Thread Jack Coates
I know the shorewall question can be resolved, but as KevinO points out it shouldn't be resolved by someone who's not fully aware of the issues at stake. In the last five days I've gotten nearly a thousand denied attempts to relay spam mail through my server clogging up my logs right now in chunks

Re: [expert] Shorewall Follies - It's drivin' me NUTS!!

2002-11-29 Thread Jim C
OK, same problem. Where can I find out the most common uses for individual ports and how can I find out what a linux box is using those ports for? Jim C wrote: Thanks Sebastien. As you can see, there are only three files that are different and only two of those matter. There is a problem howeve

Re: [expert] Shorewall Follies - It's drivin' me NUTS!!

2002-11-29 Thread Jim C
Yes it is a poort security practice IF you have something to protect.  My system is a simple home system and of course I have limited resources that dictate weather or not I even get a firewall or fileserver.  Perhaps someday when I have an old box I can use as a firewall I will set things up t

Re: [expert] Shorewall Follies - It's drivin' me NUTS!!

2002-11-28 Thread KevinO
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 This probably isn't what you want to hear but... A firewall should be a firewall and NOT a file server. It is poor security practice to put anything on a firewall box that is not absolutely required. Use your existing box as a file server and get ano

[expert] Shorewall Follies - It's drivin' me NUTS!!

2002-11-28 Thread Jim C
HAaaAAAaaalp! ;-) Background: Server is Mdk 9.0 and my two clients are XP boxes. I can't get Samba, shorewall and Connection Shareing to play nice on the same box. If two of them work then the third does not. The shorewall website says to add these rules to /etc/shorewall/rules: []# cat rule