Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-13 Thread David W. Fenton
On 13 Oct 2007 at 0:52, A-NO-NE Music wrote: > David W. Fenton / 07.10.12 / 0:05 AM wrote: > >Does Sibelius already do Unicode and handle double-byte character > >sets transparently? > > Double-byte char sets isn't Unicode, you know that, right? Yes. That's why I didn't say just Unicode. I was

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-13 Thread Johannes Gebauer
On 13.10.2007 Stan Lord wrote: Two people I know to whom I introduced Fin. moved over to Sib. a few years ago. They said they couldn't spare the time to learn Finale. Yes. You know, I know quite a lot of such people. This issue comes up every now and then, and every time it ended with the st

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-13 Thread Stan Lord
On 11 Oct 2007, at 17:47, Brian Appleby wrote: I have been a Finale user since Version 1 - my serial number is under 000650. I actually attended a hotel room demo by Phil Farrand at NAMM 1988, before the program was released. So I'm a Finale geezer. Me too. My serial no. is below 00026

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-12 Thread A-NO-NE Music
David W. Fenton / 07.10.12 / 0:05 AM wrote: >Does Sibelius already do Unicode and handle double-byte character >sets transparently? Double-byte char sets isn't Unicode, you know that, right? Randolph Peters / 07.10.12 / 10:42 AM wrote: >But I guess your larger point is that Unicode translation a

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08 - Sibelius competitive upgrade special price

2007-10-12 Thread Ray Horton
Here is a loud, clear and easy way to get the $99.97 price, and I am told if you order it here you'll get it overnight. (Free shipping) : http://www.sweetwater.com/store/detail/Sibelius5Comp/ Ray Horton John Howell wrote: At 7:16 AM -0700 10/12/07, George Ports wrote: How do I go about i

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-12 Thread Eric Dannewitz
Because someone said all their products except one were available on the Mac John Howell wrote: At 10:41 AM -0800 10/12/07, Eric Dannewitz wrote: One of them does not, and the ear training program is a version behind for Mac. And this is unusual why? My understanding is that Off

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-12 Thread John Howell
At 10:23 PM -0400 10/12/07, Bob Morabito wrote: H John--this isn't entirely correct-- The link is "Buy Now" and it says the following (previously posted) Correct, but the implication (to me, at least) is that the $199 price IS the 50% off price, rather than the 50% off price being $99. No b

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-12 Thread Bob Morabito
H John--this isn't entirely correct-- The link is "Buy Now" and it says the following (previously posted) Thanks http://www.sibelius.com/shop/educational.html Attention FINALE® Users! Sibelius 5 Competitive Upgrade Sibelius 5 Competitive Upgrade US$199 50% off, click Buy Now Finale, En

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-12 Thread John Howell
At 1:32 PM -0700 10/12/07, George Ports wrote: Thank you Bob, Am looking forward to trying out Sibelius 5. Hope I don't run into too many problems while trying to learn it. Is there a Sibelius forum as good as the Finale forum? George Better. There's a company man on the list and he ac

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-12 Thread John Howell
At 10:41 AM -0800 10/12/07, Eric Dannewitz wrote: One of them does not, and the ear training program is a version behind for Mac. And this is unusual why? My understanding is that Office 2007 for Mac won't be released until 2008!! John -- John R. Howell Virginia Tech Department of Music B

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-12 Thread John Howell
At 7:16 AM -0700 10/12/07, George Ports wrote: How do I go about it? Looked at the website and could only find it for $199. Can you direct me to obtaining it? Thanks, George Ports You have to click on "Order" or whatever the link is, and then it will show up, unexplained, with the $99 price.

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-12 Thread dhbailey
David W. Fenton wrote: [snip]> So, it's really no trivial task, and it wouldn't at all surprise me if some of the meagerness of recent released Finale versions were due to the fact that significant resources are being expended on a long- term rewrite of the entire codebase to enable Unicode in s

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-12 Thread Bob Morabito
t;Bob Morabito" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: Sent: Friday, October 12, 2007 9:26 AM Subject: Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08 Hi George: http://www.sibelius.com/shop/educational.html Attention FINALE® Users! Sibelius 5 Competitive Upgrade Sibelius 5 Competitive Upgrade US$199

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-12 Thread George Ports
t: Friday, October 12, 2007 9:26 AM Subject: Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08 Hi George: http://www.sibelius.com/shop/educational.html Attention FINALE® Users! Sibelius 5 Competitive Upgrade Sibelius 5 Competitive Upgrade US$199 50% off, click Buy Now Finale, Encore, Mosaic, and Sibe

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-12 Thread George Ports
Thanks Aaron, I was able to get Sibelius. George - Original Message - From: "Aaron Sherber" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: ; Sent: Friday, October 12, 2007 9:12 AM Subject: Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08 At 10:16 AM 10/12/2007, George Ports wrote: >How do I go

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-12 Thread David W. Fenton
On 12 Oct 2007 at 9:42, Randolph Peters wrote: > David W. Fenton wrote: > > > >Does Sibelius already do Unicode and handle double-byte character > >sets transparently? > > I don't know first hand how well Sibelius handles Unicode. Their web > site says yes, but Michael Good says no. Perhaps some

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-12 Thread Bruce Clausen
<[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: Sent: Friday, October 12, 2007 7:16 AM Subject: Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08 How do I go about it? Looked at the website and could only find it for $199. Can you direct me to obtaining it? Thanks, George Ports - Original Message - From: "Bruce Cla

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-12 Thread David W. Fenton
On 12 Oct 2007 at 3:51, dhbailey wrote: > I'm still wondering what the reason for their early release of version > 2k8 was, and I can only guess that part of it was to get pre-order > income into the second quarter to make their financial picture look > better, and continue the upgrade income i

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-12 Thread Michael Good
Hi Randolph, > I don't know first hand how well Sibelius handles Unicode. > Their web site says yes, but Michael Good says no. I think you must have misunderstood something that I said or wrote. I apologize for any confusion there. Sibelius 5 has native Unicode support built-in and it works gr

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-12 Thread dhbailey
Fisher, Allen wrote: On the search page: http://www.smartmusic.com/findmusic/default.aspx More than 30,000 titles and counting! The SmartMusic practice system includes more than 30,000 solo and ensemble titles and 50,000 exercises for woodwind, brass, string, and vocal musicians. Access the li

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-12 Thread Eric Dannewitz
One of them does not, and the ear training program is a version behind for Mac. Kim Patrick Clow wrote: On 10/11/07, Eric Dannewitz <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: The problem with Sibelius educational software is that it runs on Windows only. The stuff is excellent, but..windows only? St

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-12 Thread Eric Dannewitz
Um, the website doesn't really reflect the updates. There was one yesterday, and there was no jazz band updates. There hasn't been any update in over a month for the Jazz band titles. The last one I saw was the watered down, terrible version of Gordon Goodwin's The Jazz Police. Fisher, Allen w

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-12 Thread Eric Dannewitz
Except that they don't have the COMPLETE content of those books. The Standard Of Excellence and Yamaha instrumental methods are missing a few to quite a few of the exercises. Tyler Turner wrote: I assume you're talking about the new ensemble literature? If you look at all of the content, there

RE: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-12 Thread Fisher, Allen
: [Finale] Re: Finale '08 | | I asked: | >I think SmartMusic is a very interesting program that actually does | >what it says it does, but where is the repertoire? | | Fisher, Allen replied: | >New repertoire is being released regularly. From the front page of | >www.smartmusic.com:

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-12 Thread Lora Crighton
--- Brian Appleby <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > At some point in the future I'm going to want an > Intel Mac running > the latest version of OSX, and then the whole > thing's going to blow > up on me - I'll probably have to tuck my old > computers in a corner to > run Finale archives, and

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-12 Thread Bob Morabito
]> To: Sent: Thursday, October 11, 2007 8:15 PM Subject: Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08 Hi, all. Actually you can buy Sib5 for $99 as a Finale Competitive Upgrade. But this offer, as of now, is only good for the month of October. BC - Original Message - From: "Aaron Sh

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-12 Thread Tyler Turner
--- Randolph Peters <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Tyler Turner wrote: > >Now SmartMusic's growth greatly outpaces Finale's. > > Growth rates can look impressive when the sample > numbers are small. > It is always a mistake to assume that early growth > rates will be > similar in the future in a

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-12 Thread Aaron Sherber
At 10:16 AM 10/12/2007, George Ports wrote: >How do I go about it? Looked at the website and could only find it for $199. >Can you direct me to obtaining it? Go to http://www.sibelius.com/shop/professional.html There's a box in the middle of the page that says "Attention FINALE Users". Click o

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-12 Thread George Ports
How do I go about it? Looked at the website and could only find it for $199. Can you direct me to obtaining it? Thanks, George Ports - Original Message - From: "Bruce Clausen" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: Sent: Thursday, October 11, 2007 8:15 PM Subject: Re: [Finale] Re:

RE: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-12 Thread Tyler Turner
--- Randolph Peters <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > >Just added - Over 95 band, jazz band, and orchestra > titles, Rubank > >Advanced Volume 1, and The Yamaha Advantage, > >Book 1 > > I don't want to minimize this achievement, but a > higher order of > magnitude is what I think is needed for a cri

RE: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-12 Thread Randolph Peters
I asked: I think SmartMusic is a very interesting program that actually does what it says it does, but where is the repertoire? Fisher, Allen replied: New repertoire is being released regularly. From the front page of www.smartmusic.com: Just added - Over 95 band, jazz band, and orchestra tit

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-12 Thread Randolph Peters
David W. Fenton wrote: Does Sibelius already do Unicode and handle double-byte character sets transparently? I don't know first hand how well Sibelius handles Unicode. Their web site says yes, but Michael Good says no. Perhaps someone can clarify this question with regards to Sibelius 5. B

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-12 Thread Bruce Clausen
Hi, all. Actually you can buy Sib5 for $99 as a Finale Competitive Upgrade. But this offer, as of now, is only good for the month of October. BC - Original Message - From: "Aaron Sherber" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: ; Sent: Thursday, October 11, 2007 5:23 PM Subject:

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-12 Thread Christopher Smith
shirling & neueweise wrote: Sadly, I think the last tee-shirt was Finale 97 or 98 2004, sleek, black, sexy, i feel like a real man wearing it Funny, whenever I wear mine, everyone thinks I look like a geek, and they point and laugh. Except when I wore it to the Sibelius demo g

RE: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-12 Thread Fisher, Allen
| I think SmartMusic is a very interesting program that | actually does what it says it does, but where is the | repertoire? New repertoire is being released regularly. From the front page of www.smartmusic.com: Just added - Over 95 band, jazz band, and orchestra titles, Rubank Advanced Volum

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-12 Thread David W. Fenton
On 11 Oct 2007 at 17:51, Randolph Peters wrote: > MM's notation programs are still by far the biggest earners. And > there is still a lot of growth potential here that I don't see being > tapped. For example, where is the development in those Asian markets > (e.g., China, Korea) that have a hug

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-12 Thread Kim Patrick Clow
On 10/11/07, Eric Dannewitz <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > The problem with Sibelius educational software is that it runs on > Windows only. The stuff is excellent, but..windows only? Stupid. Not true, it runs on Mac platform, according to Daniel Spreadbury. Kim

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-12 Thread dhbailey
Tyler Turner wrote: [snip] My hope is that as SmartMusic continues to pick up a greater share of the load, it will eventually allow MakeMusic to relax on Finale's schedule and fix many older issues. SmartMusic is really a blessing for Finale, because it requires the company to maintain its inte

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-12 Thread David W. Fenton
On 11 Oct 2007 at 10:47, Brian Appleby wrote: > Bottom line is, Finale 2006 does pretty well everything I require. I've refrained until now from replying because: 1. I'm no a professional copyist. 2. I use Finale pretty occasionally, though I have lots of work invested in it. 3. I never upgra

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-11 Thread Tyler Turner
--- Eric Dannewitz <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > I think MakeMusic, if the trend continues, is not > going to be the maker > of an excellent notation program. They will be known > for their > SmartMusic stuff, perhaps even changing their name > from MakeMusic (like > they did from Coda to Mak

RE: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-11 Thread Stu McIntire
> It seems that some big-wig at MakeMusic has as his pet hobby-horse > SmartMusic Accompaniment system ... The Boston Globe has a front page story today about how schools all over MA are now using SmartMusic: http://www.boston.com/news/education/k_12/articles/2007/10/11/harried_school s_trumpet_d

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-11 Thread Christopher Smith
On 11-Oct-07, at 12:47 PM, Brian Appleby wrote: [comprehensive stuff snipped] Bottom line is, Finale 2006 does pretty well everything I require. I always thought linked parts would be nice, but I've tried to work with the implementation in 2007 and 2008 a bit, and always decided it wasn'

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-11 Thread Aaron Sherber
At 06:06 PM 10/11/2007, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: >"Sibelius crossgrade"? Is that some kind of crossover program between >Finale and Sibelius? Each program can be bought at a discount by owners of the other, with proof of ownership. Sibelius usually sells for $600. Finale owners can normally b

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-11 Thread Randolph Peters
Tyler Turner wrote: Now SmartMusic's growth greatly outpaces Finale's. Growth rates can look impressive when the sample numbers are small. It is always a mistake to assume that early growth rates will be similar in the future in any statistical analysis. MM's notation programs are still by

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-11 Thread arabushk
"Sibelius crossgrade"? Is that some kind of crossover program between Finale and Sibelius? > Daniel Wolf <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > >> Would it be possible now, from the list membership, to get a more >> accurate sense of the number of us who are (a) a long-term, professional >> users of Finale,

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-11 Thread Brian Appleby
I have been a Finale user since Version 1 - my serial number is under 000650. I actually attended a hotel room demo by Phil Farrand at NAMM 1988, before the program was released. So I'm a Finale geezer. I run a small publishing company specializing in young band music - we have a catalog

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-11 Thread dennis
Eric wrote: > It's good and all that SmartMusic is starting to make them money. It has > it's pluses and minuses, there are a lot of things I like and dislike > about it. But they really shouldn't drop the ball with their flagship > product, especially when all they need to do is fix bugs and compl

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-11 Thread dhbailey
Tyler Turner wrote: --- dhbailey <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: It seems that some big-wig at MakeMusic has as his pet hobby-horse SmartMusic Accompaniment system and won't allow the resources to be allocated fairly so that Finale's problems can be properly addressed, all the while the accounting

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-11 Thread Eric Dannewitz
Tyler Turner wrote: I believe you're going to be pretty surprised by how all this turns out in the future. Take a look at the news from yesterday regarding the success of SmartMusic. The last 3 month quarter saw subscriptions jump from 61,000 to nearly 76,000. As the company predicted, SmartMusic

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-11 Thread Tyler Turner
--- dhbailey <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > It seems that some big-wig at MakeMusic has as his > pet hobby-horse > SmartMusic Accompaniment system and won't allow the > resources to be > allocated fairly so that Finale's problems can be > properly addressed, > all the while the accounting shows t

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-11 Thread Eric Dannewitz
Oh man, I feel soinferior now. shirling & neueweise wrote: Sadly, I think the last tee-shirt was Finale 97 or 98 2004, sleek, black, sexy, i feel like a real man wearing it ___ Finale mailing list Finale@shsu.edu http

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-11 Thread Barbara Touburg
dhbailey wrote: Barbara Touburg wrote: I have one! A very large blue one! (guess where it came from - thanks, Carla!) Eric Dannewitz wrote: Or tee-shirts. I need my tee-shirts! You got a T-shirt for your Fin2k8 upgrade? No, YEARS ago, can't remember when. I whined a bit at the Coda

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-11 Thread Andrew Levin
I'm working on a project for A-R Editions. They're sticking with Finale 2006 because of bugs introduced in 2007. Andrew Levin ___ Finale mailing list Finale@shsu.edu http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-11 Thread David Woodcock
Thought I should contribute as well (a) have been a professional Finale user since 1992, mostly with film and recording orchestras in UK and New Zealand, upgraded faithfully to every version. Last purchase was 2007 (b) very concerned about some bugs, especially flipping accidentals, and disapp

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-11 Thread dennis
Daniel Wolf <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Would it be possible now, from the list membership, to get a more > accurate sense of the number of us who are (a) a long-term, professional > users of Finale, (b) have serious concerns about bug fixes, and (c) iare > either skipping an '08 upgrade or switc

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-11 Thread John Howell
At 6:01 PM -0400 10/10/07, Christopher Smith wrote: On Oct 10, 2007, at 4:43 PM, shirling & neueweise wrote: additional weight could be given to such a compilation as you have suggested if responders gave an indication of how many potential finale users they have suggested use sibelius inste

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-11 Thread shirling & neueweise
Sadly, I think the last tee-shirt was Finale 97 or 98 2004, sleek, black, sexy, i feel like a real man wearing it -- shirling & neueweise ... new music publishers mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] :.../ http://newmusicnotation.com ___ Finale mailing

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-11 Thread Eric Dannewitz
Sadly, I think the last tee-shirt was Finale 97 or 98 dhbailey wrote: Barbara Touburg wrote: I have one! A very large blue one! (guess where it came from - thanks, Carla!) Eric Dannewitz wrote: Or tee-shirts. I need my tee-shirts! ___ Fi

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-11 Thread dhbailey
Barbara Touburg wrote: I have one! A very large blue one! (guess where it came from - thanks, Carla!) Eric Dannewitz wrote: Or tee-shirts. I need my tee-shirts! ___ Finale mailing list Finale@shsu.edu http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-11 Thread dhbailey
shirling & neueweise wrote: posted the e-mail addresses of the COO, CTO, CEO and several others at MakeMusic and posted a copy of the letter he sent (with CC: to all of them) listing his concerns and complaints and he urged any/all of us to do the same. I did, writing my own letter and sendi

RE: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-10 Thread Richard Yates
- I am a long term amateur user (with six books published). - I will not upgrade to Fin2008 (the first I skipped in ten years). - I ill be reluctant to upgrade to 2009 unless bug fixes are made. - I check out each new Sibelius version to see if it can do what I need. Richard Yates >-Original

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-10 Thread shirling & neueweise
That description might apply to John Howell and me. 15 workstations (all of them) at my school upgraded this year to Sibelius 5, but not Finale. yeh i figgerd i could shake you out! 8-) -- shirling & neueweise ... new music publishers mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] :.../ http://newmusicnotation.c

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-10 Thread Barbara Touburg
I have one! A very large blue one! (guess where it came from - thanks, Carla!) Eric Dannewitz wrote: Or tee-shirts. I need my tee-shirts! ___ Finale mailing list Finale@shsu.edu http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-10 Thread Bruce Clausen
Thanks, David and Richard. Am tweaking happily away! BC - Original Message - From: "Richard Smith" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: Sent: Wednesday, October 10, 2007 2:23 PM Subject: Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08 Bruce Clausen wrote: On Fin's side, I don'

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-10 Thread Christopher Smith
On Oct 10, 2007, at 5:10 PM, Johannes Gebauer wrote: On 10.10.2007 Christopher Smith wrote: What did they say to you when they informed you that you would not be beta testing any more? They did not inform me at all. Nada. I eventually asked why I hadn't heard. It took them two weeks to r

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-10 Thread Christopher Smith
On Oct 10, 2007, at 4:43 PM, shirling & neueweise wrote: additional weight could be given to such a compilation as you have suggested if responders gave an indication of how many potential finale users they have suggested use sibelius instead, and if certain people could let MM know that

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-10 Thread Bruce Clausen
Bruce - Original Message - From: "Dean M. Estabrook" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: Sent: Wednesday, October 10, 2007 2:58 PM Subject: Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08 Ah, it has finally happened. The Finale List is now morphing into a Sibelius list. Not that there's an

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-10 Thread Eric Dannewitz
Or tee-shirts. I need my tee-shirts! shirling & neueweise wrote: No no no. You can't do that. Make them participate on a list? Then they would have to respond to feedback. They might be confronted with things that they need to fix. We won't get the new, fluffy Pokemon notation that will be i

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-10 Thread Eric Dannewitz
I think it was jef chippewa dhbailey wrote: A few months ago Bob Morabito (I think it was him -- if not, I apologize to whomever it was) posted the e-mail addresses of the COO, CTO, CEO and several others at MakeMusic and posted a copy of the letter he sent (with CC: to all of them) listin

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-10 Thread Dean M. Estabrook
Ah, it has finally happened. The Finale List is now morphing into a Sibelius list. Not that there's anything wrong with that, just an interesting example of Darwin's thesis. Dean On Oct 10, 2007, at 2:23 PM, Richard Smith wrote: Bruce Clausen wrote: On Fin's side, I don't yet see in Sib th

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-10 Thread shirling & neueweise
posted the e-mail addresses of the COO, CTO, CEO and several others at MakeMusic and posted a copy of the letter he sent (with CC: to all of them) listing his concerns and complaints and he urged any/all of us to do the same. I did, writing my own letter and sending it to the same recipients

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-10 Thread Richard Smith
Bruce Clausen wrote: On Fin's side, I don't yet see in Sib the ability to tweak things, e.g. hairpins, expression placement, slurs, etc., but this may be that I haven't yet found the means of doing so. So far, I believe that Sib is more the way I like to work . . . but it is way too soon for a

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-10 Thread dhbailey
I believe that Sib is more the way I like to work . . . but it is way too soon for a really informed judgment. Bruce Clausen - Original Message - From: "Johannes Gebauer" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: Sent: Wednesday, October 10, 2007 11:37 AM Subject: Re: [Finale] Re: F

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-10 Thread Johannes Gebauer
On 10.10.2007 Christopher Smith wrote: What did they say to you when they informed you that you would not be beta testing any more? They did not inform me at all. Nada. I eventually asked why I hadn't heard. It took them two weeks to reply. Johannes -- http://www.musikmanufaktur.com http:/

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-10 Thread dhbailey
A few months ago Bob Morabito (I think it was him -- if not, I apologize to whomever it was) posted the e-mail addresses of the COO, CTO, CEO and several others at MakeMusic and posted a copy of the letter he sent (with CC: to all of them) listing his concerns and complaints and he urged any/al

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-10 Thread shirling & neueweise
No no no. You can't do that. Make them participate on a list? Then they would have to respond to feedback. They might be confronted with things that they need to fix. We won't get the new, fluffy Pokemon notation that will be included in Finale 2009. It will be a hit with the newly targeted p

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-10 Thread ThomaStudios
On Oct 10, 2007, at 12:15 PM, Daniel Wolfr wrote: Would it be possible now, from the list membership, to get a more accurate sense of the number of us who are (a) a long-term, professional users of Finale, (b) have serious concerns about bug fixes, and (c) iare either skipping an '08 upgrad

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-10 Thread Bruce Clausen
ctober 10, 2007 11:37 AM Subject: Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08 On 10.10.2007 Daniel Wolf wrote: Would it be possible now, from the list membership, to get a more accurate sense of the number of us who are (a) a long-term, professional users of Finale, (b) have serious concerns about bug fi

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-10 Thread Eric Dannewitz
No no no. You can't do that. Make them participate on a list? Then they would have to respond to feedback. They might be confronted with things that they need to fix. We won't get the new, fluffy Pokemon notation that will be included in Finale 2009. It will be a hit with the newly targeted pre

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-10 Thread Jack Ellis
I'm a long time user, but not for publishing. I use finale to compose and arrange for singing groups, including instrument accompaniments which I put on a sequencer. I upgrade when it looks like an improvement will help me, usually about every two years. I also monitor the list for others' exper

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-10 Thread Lora Crighton
--- Daniel Wolf <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Would it be possible now, from the list membership, > to get a more > accurate sense of the number of us who are (a) a > long-term, professional > users of Finale, Long-term, non-professional - current grad student in musicology, former choir librari

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-10 Thread dennis
Daniel Wolf: > From my own informal count on this list, at least twenty established, > long-term, professional users have indicated that they are not switching > to '08; most of them indicate that bug fixing is their main concern, > several of indicated a move to a competing product. I'm not sure

RE: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-10 Thread Lee Actor
> I've just reviewed most of the posts dealing with Finale '08, and -- > following what appears to be a consensus around here -- have decided to > stick with '07 until notice of further improvements in known bugs. > > I also took a look at some press statements on the MakeMusic site > announcing qu

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-10 Thread Christopher Smith
On Oct 10, 2007, at 2:37 PM, Johannes Gebauer wrote: I have had serious concerns about bug fixes for a long time. And, although I haven't decided to not buy Finale 2k8 (I may have to for compatibility reasons), I will not buy it yet. I do have serious concerns about the future of Finale in

Re: [Finale] Re: Finale '08

2007-10-10 Thread Johannes Gebauer
On 10.10.2007 Daniel Wolf wrote: Would it be possible now, from the list membership, to get a more accurate sense of the number of us who are (a) a long-term, professional users of Finale, (b) have serious concerns about bug fixes, and (c) iare either skipping an '08 upgrade or switching to a