Re: How to add a field to the reply that contains data from the request?

2004-12-05 Thread Peter T. Breuer
"Also sprach Anson Rinesmith:" > If you feel so strongly about changes needing to be made, then why not make > an official comment to the RFC and try to make things better? An RFC is, by > the way, a Request For Clarification. I don't feel at all strongly about it. I feel about as strongly about

Re: How to add a field to the reply that contains data from the request?

2004-12-05 Thread Peter T. Breuer
"Also sprach Michael Griego:" > On Sat, 2004-12-04 at 21:16, Peter T. Breuer wrote: > > No I haven't. I'm sure radius is fine. OTOH I'm quite sure the rfc is > > probably a load of badly written rubbish, because they normally are. > > So? Is ther

Re: How to add a field to the reply that contains data from the request?

2004-12-04 Thread Peter T. Breuer
"Also sprach Mitchell, Michael:" > When you're given a gift for FREE do you give it back complaining that > the shade of red is not quite what you wanted? Nobody gave me a gift - I was kind enough to evaluate your product. I didn't have to. It took time to do so. If I were paying you for it I w

Re: How to add a field to the reply that contains data from the request?

2004-12-04 Thread Peter T. Breuer
"Also sprach Michael Griego:" > All I have to say is that your attitude normally determines the response > you get. You came in here telling many people who have worked with > RADIUS for a long time how the specs are wrong and how you are much No I haven't. I'm sure radius is fine. OTOH I'm quite

Re: How to add a field to the reply that contains data from the request?

2004-12-04 Thread Peter T. Breuer
"Also sprach Anson Rinesmith:" > > >I particularly like this one (at end of 4.3): > > > Attributes > > > The Attribute field is variable in length, and contains a list > > of zero or more Attributes. > > >!!! Yeah. Are they trying to make a pastiche comedy sketch takeoff of >

Re: How to add a field to the reply that contains data from the request?

2004-12-04 Thread Peter T. Breuer
"Also sprach Anson Rinesmith:" > >Well, as everyone could have guessed, they talk aboout "fields". > > > A summary of the RADIUS data format is shown below. The fields > > are transmitted from left to right. > > > >They then switch to calling them "attributes", for no good reason. >

Re: How to add a field to the reply that contains data from the request?

2004-12-04 Thread Peter T. Breuer
"Also sprach Alan DeKok:" > > Then why is it showing a different reply below? > > > > Because it is NOT saying "I sent no response" here! It should. > > When you don't get mail, does the post office send you a letter > saying "you didn't get mail today?" If I ask them to tell me when I get a r

Re: How to add a field to the reply that contains data from the request?

2004-12-04 Thread Peter T. Breuer
"Also sprach [EMAIL PROTECTED]:" > Right. Notice however, that there are many different and sometimes > contracdicting > conventions. Would you agree that it is perfectly reasonable for a RADIUS > implementation (and its documentation) to use the conventions that are > detailed in > the RADIUS RF

Re: How to add a field to the reply that contains data from the request?

2004-12-04 Thread Peter T. Breuer
"Also sprach Alan DeKok:" > "Peter T. Breuer" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > Because the other is in capital letters, called PPP, and does not begin > > with an "x" or contain a "-", all things which would indicate > > variables. I

Re: How to add a field to the reply that contains data from the request?

2004-12-04 Thread Peter T. Breuer
"Also sprach David Luyens:" > Could you share your config with us? Here is radiusd.conf. I have stripped every line that begins with " *#", and every empty line. --- prefix = /usr/home/ptb exec_prefix = ${prefix} sysconfdir = ${prefix}/etc local

Re: How to add a field to the reply that contains data from the request?

2004-12-04 Thread Peter T. Breuer
below (apart from browning me off, showing your subtle disdain for what had been written, etc? :( )? The above 6 words of yours are sufficient and complete in themselves, surely! Don't you trust them? > -Oorspronkelijk bericht- > "Also sprach Alan DeKok:" > >

Re: How to add a field to the reply that contains data from the request?

2004-12-03 Thread Peter T. Breuer
"Also sprach Alan DeKok:" > "Peter T. Breuer" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > I don't presently know where all this stuff should go, since I have > > only been using the server for 30 mins, and am pleased to be able to > > get it to work an

Re: How to add a field to the reply that contains data from the request?

2004-12-03 Thread Peter T. Breuer
"Also sprach Jason Lixfeld:" > joeuser Login-LAT-Node == FOO > ARAP-Security-Data = FOO Well, I think you are right in principle, but it doesn't seem to quite work for me. I have ptb Auth-Type := Local, User-Password == "XX", Login-LAT-Node == User-Se

Re: How to add a field to the reply that contains data from the request?

2004-12-03 Thread Peter T. Breuer
"Also sprach Jason Lixfeld:" > Pardon my possible stupidity, but in looking at how to solve my own > problems, I came across this from man 5 users: Hi. I don't presently know where all this stuff should go, since I have only been using the server for 30 mins, and am pleased to be able to get it

How to add a field to the reply that contains data from the request?

2004-12-03 Thread Peter T. Breuer
freeradius 1.0.1 on FreeBSD 4.10 I believe I want to add a ARAP-Security-Data = FOO field to the reply, where I receive Login-LAT-Node = FOO How can I do this? I believe I want to use the exec echo module, but I see no clear example of how. I have set program = "/bin/echo A