--- On Mon, 10/6/08, Bosco - Goanet Volunteer [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
#1) You publicly stated what was not true about your rejected message.
I publicly stated that I was asked to send my questions to the Goanet
moderators, not knowing that the address [EMAIL PROTECTED] did not refer to
On Mon Oct 6 05:01:51 PDT 2008 Santosh Helekar wrote:
Let me see if I understand what this answer says:
RESPONSE: As much as you may try to frame the exchange here, the fact
remains:
#1) You publicly stated what was not true about your rejected message.
#2) Even though Cornel has publicly
Santosh Helekar wrote:
Regarding what the rejection message said, it asked me to send my
questions to the Goanet moderators. --- Santosh
This statement of mine can only be false if Goanet-Admin does not
refer to the Goanet moderators.
RESPONSE: Your statement is FALSE because what you
--- On Sun, 10/5/08, Bosco - Goanet Volunteer [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
RESPONSE: No! Goanet moderators are individuals who moderate Goanet; Goanet
Admin manage and run different aspects of Goanet - its members can moderate
Goanet too. The names of Goanet moderators have not been
published
Date: Sun, 5 Oct 2008 22:47:34 -0400
From: Bosco - Goanet Volunteer [EMAIL PROTECTED]
You were not advised to send YOUR questions to the Goanet moderators as
much as you would like others to believe. You were told to direct your
questions to Goanet Admin. Simple as that!
Mario responds:
Hi Cornel,
At the outset, let me assure you that I have a lot of respect for you and
commend you for your achievements, which you recounted on Goanet. Having
said that, sometimes you seem to have a difficult time to get a message. In
fact in my review of your many writings, you have a knack
On Fri, Oct 3, 2008 at 5:25 PM, Bosco - Goanet Volunteer
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
RESPONSE: FALSE!! The moderator did the right thing and asked the poster to
direct his questions to [EMAIL PROTECTED] .
This is quite a mystery! The above is a response to my following statement:
Regarding
Hi Gilbert
Thank you for indicating that brief reasons for post rejections by Goanet
moderators would be helpful when they are deemed inappropriate. That is
indeed all critics of Goanet moderation have been asking for since Jan/Feb
2008. I am glad you have noted this point and responded to it
Hi Mervyn,
Goanet moderators advise posters who aim to be amusing to use a smiley :=)). I
do not see that in your alleged non-provocative posts that you label as
amusing +/- having crossed the line.
As far as Goan posts without the :=)) being amusing, I assumed that the author
of those
If the following fact is true - regarding hundreds of unexplained post
rejects on Goanet, I would suggest the moderators should find more dramatic /
drastic means to deal with the authors of these innumerable inappropriate
posts. This would be better than the moderators wasting their valuable
Bosco wrote:
Question: Are you implying that you do not write to Goanet to antagonize and
provoke fellow Goanetters??
Bosco,
I am on Goanet for only one reason: To learn.
I think that life is to short to go around antagonizing people. I certainly
do not want to be a provoker. Maybe in
For reasons unknown (???), this poster has potrayed my text as his own in
this thread:
http://lists.goanet.org/pipermail/goanet-goanet.org/2008-October/081418.html
--- On Wed, 10/1/08, Santosh Helekar chimbelcho at gmail.com wrote:
Santosh Helekar had a message rejected recently (as he
Mervyn,
I dont know what you mean when you say 'real time'.
1. Nobody, repeat nobody, on Goanet is on unmoderated post.
2. If a moderator is online when someone posts, and is moderating at that
time, chances are that an uncomplicated post will go through almost
instantaneously
Considering
Dear Goanetters,
There have been emails from a handful of people seeking to cast aspersions
on Goanet moderation. As chair of Goanet I would like to address the
specific issues that have been raised.
First off, Id like to remind you that Goanet's Rules are published on
Goanet's website at
Date: Tue, 30 Sep 2008 22:00:31 -0700 (PDT)
From: Herman Carneiro [EMAIL PROTECTED]
We endeavor to provide an explanation for every message we reject and we
save a copy of the rejected post for a period of time. Those of you who
state that your messages are being rejected without an explanation
From: Herman Carneiro
Those of you who state that your messages are being rejected without an
explanation are habitual violators of Goanet's Rules and the moderators
have afforded you more than you fair share of explanations, which you
have chosen to ignore.
Mario responds:
I'm not sure
--- On Wed, 10/1/08, Santosh Helekar [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Santosh Helekar had a message rejected recently (as he disclosed) and he has
concluded who the moderator was. However he fails to mention that he was
provided an explanation in the rejection note but did not follow through on
the
PROTECTED]
Subject: [Goanet] Goanet Moderation
Message-ID:
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Dear Goanetters,
There have been emails from a handful of people seeking to cast aspersions
on Goanet moderation. As chair of Goanet I would like to address the
specific issues that have been raised.
First off, I?d like
Bosco - Goanet Volunteer wrote:
In essence, there should be no need to moderate Goanet. Goanet's Rules are
clear and concise. They are published on Goanet's website at www.goanet.org
and are regularly published here. They have been tweaked to their current
status over years of experience.
Herman Carneiro wrote:
Conducting witch-hunts to identify moderators who reject posts and
lambasting them publicly is unfair and uncalled for. While moderators are
encouraged to add their names to rejection notices, it is not a
requirement, and it is not surprising that some of our moderators
To paraphrase an infamous cliché, Hell hath no fury like a Goan whose
message was rejected for posting on Goanet.
There has been much bafflegab on this issue over the past few days by a
couple 'experts' in this field. Since Mervyn asked two 'simple' questions, I
will acquiesce to his
Folks,
I have 800 unopened emails in my inbox. I have not been able to follow this
debate closely.
What I do want to point out is that moderation is a thankless job. Having said
this,
some of the moderators here have spent YEARS of effort trying to make Goanet
work.
And they have mostly
22 matches
Mail list logo
