Re: lute siting

2005-02-14 Thread Ed Durbrow
>Hope the folia was by Corbetta! Probably more Marais oriented. The Corbetta folia in Dm at the end of Le Guitar Royal is too harmonically sophisticated for their usages. I did here some substitution chords though. It would be a nice soundtrack album to have. >I don't think I have seen the fil

RE: Lute Editing Programmes

2005-02-14 Thread [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Hi Benjamin, I use Finale 2004 and have great results. I've been using the program since version 3.0 and find it quite easy to use. The version I have now let's me create templates for any number of strings and tunings and prints out beautifully. People complain about the learning curve, which is

help with interview of Crawford Young

2005-02-14 Thread Ed Durbrow
I interviewed Crawford Young a year and a half ago. The editors of the LSA Quarterly have been encouraging me to finish transcribing the interview for an upcoming issue. I transcribed about 30 minutes and still have another 60 minutes or so to go. I just have been so busy and it's been hard to

My thumb... and lute's neck

2005-02-14 Thread Arto Wikla
Dear lutenists Dr. Marion Ceruti wrote: > Maybe a musicologist will discover a > manuscript that explains all this so we can stop wondering about it. > Until that time, I will try to keep my left thumb out of sight of the > audience when playing. Well, in an original and old (about 1990) phot

Re: Antwort: left hand thumb to stop bass notes

2005-02-14 Thread [EMAIL PROTECTED]
-- Initial Header --- >From : "Roman Turovsky" [EMAIL PROTECTED] To : "Vance Wood" [EMAIL PROTECTED],"lute list" lute@cs.dartmouth.edu Cc : Date : Mon, 14 Feb 2005 21:32:45 -0500 Subject : Re: Antwort: left hand thumb to stop bass notes > > As to the u

Re: lute siting

2005-02-14 Thread Howard Posner
Monica Hall wrote: > Another example perhaps of how uninformed film makers are about musical > matters. Everything is authentic to the last detail except the music. You've seen a period movie in which everything is authentic to the last detail? To get on or off this list see list information

Re: Antwort: left hand thumb to stop bass notes

2005-02-14 Thread Nancy Carlin
I have been working on the layout of the next LSA Quarterly and there is an ad from the Boston Early Music Festival which mentions the Borus Goudenow opera that they are putting on and in the small print it mentioned (along with a nice lute duet concert by Paul O'Dette & Stephen Stubbs) a concer

Re: Antwort: left hand thumb to stop bass notes

2005-02-14 Thread Edward Martin
I agree with Jim. For my lutes, I always have the "acceptable & appropriate" position of the thumb behind the neck,. but when I play my alto & soprano vihuelas, the thumb pops up naturally. No, I do not stop notes with the thumb. ed At 09:43 PM 2/14/2005 -0500, James A Stimson wrote: >De

Re: Antwort: left hand thumb to stop bass notes

2005-02-14 Thread Roman Turovsky
> One thing to bear in mind when looking at 16th-century portrayals of > lutenists is the character of the lutes and their necks. If the neck is > narrow, as on a five- or six-course lute, with an "elliptical" shape, the > neck naturally settles in the "V" between the thumb and forefinger. For > th

Re: Antwort: left hand thumb to stop bass notes

2005-02-14 Thread James A Stimson
Dear All: One thing to bear in mind when looking at 16th-century portrayals of lutenists is the character of the lutes and their necks. If the neck is narrow, as on a five- or six-course lute, with an "elliptical" shape, the neck naturally settles in the "V" between the thumb and forefinger. F

Re: left hand thumb to stop bass notes

2005-02-14 Thread David Cassetti
Now all this discussion has me wondering if F. da Milano might have used his left thumb for the following passage at the end of one of his fantasias: 1 1.2 0 _ |__c_|___c:||| |__d_|___c:||| |

Re: Antwort: left hand thumb to stop bass notes

2005-02-14 Thread Vance Wood
That may be true, but were the playing complex counterpoint and doubled strings? If this is so perhaps we should study Gypsy 7 string guitar technique. VW - Original Message - From: "Roman Turovsky" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: "Vance Wood" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; "lute list" Sent: Monday, Febr

Fw: Sv: lute siting

2005-02-14 Thread G. Crona
- Original Message - From: "G.R. Crona" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Sent: Tuesday, February 15, 2005 3:16 AM Subject: [Vds: Sv: lute siting] > >> >> Fra: G.R. Crona <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> >> Dato: 2005/02/14 Mon PM 02:21:41 CET >> Til: Ed Durbrow <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> >> CC:

Re: Antwort: left hand thumb to stop bass notes

2005-02-14 Thread Roman Turovsky
> As to the use of the LH thumb to stop strings. In order to do this it is > necessary to couch the neck in the palm of the left hand. If this was an > occasional event the musician was required to make this shift and then shift > back to the more raised fingers anchored thumb position. I find t

Re: Antwort: left hand thumb to stop bass notes

2005-02-14 Thread Vance Wood
To whom it may concern: Not meaning to be rude but due to the way this site is set up it is sometimes impossible to determine whose message I may be responding to. With that in mind I will share some of the things I know and some of the things I think I know and perhaps guess at a couple of others

Re: lute siting

2005-02-14 Thread carlos flores
>Another example perhaps of how uninformed film makers are about musical >matters. Everything is authentic to the last detail except the music. > >Cheers > >Monica > Oh yeah, its sometimes just ridiculous:) --like for example on this movie i saw sometime ago, there was this real romantic scen

Re: Lute Editing Programmes

2005-02-14 Thread demery
[EMAIL PROTECTED] said: > Indeed, there are lute tablatures available on the programme. However, not > for several important tunings if one is to generalize the software so it can deal with any tuning, and one expects the program to handle playback, there will be a need for the program to be

Re: Lute Editing Programmes

2005-02-14 Thread demery
Roman Turovsky <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> said: > One major problem in Sibelius is that the input is MOUSE based, which means > it is a lot more harmful to hands and wrists than DJANGO and FRONIMO that > permit keyboard input for the bulk of labor. well, my software allows and encourages the use of the

Re: Antwort: left hand thumb to stop bass notes

2005-02-14 Thread demery
Denys Stephens <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> said: > Dear Vance, > Forgive me for challenging you on this, but it's my understanding > that the lute typically in use for the greater part of the 16th century > was a 6 course instrument however, it was towards the end of that century that wider necks with mo

Re: R: Lute Editing Programmes

2005-02-14 Thread Lutebets
In a message dated 2/14/05 3:29:03 PM, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: << Fronimo had MIDI playback capability from the very beginning, even directly from tablature. 8^) Francesco >> Hi, Francesco -- Woops, very sorry for the oversight! I must have remembered this detail incorrectly because when I

Re: Re: Antwort: left hand thumb to stop bass notes

2005-02-14 Thread Dr. Marion Ceruti
-Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Feb 14, 2005 2:38 PM To: Denys Stephens <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Cc: lute@cs.dartmouth.edu Subject: Re: Re: Antwort: left hand thumb to stop bass notes In fact, one > of the > prime examples of pictorial evidence of what we are talking > abou

Re: Antwort: left hand thumb to stop bass notes

2005-02-14 Thread Dr. Marion Ceruti
Dear Denys, >Dear Marion, I think it's probably possible to play the entire 6 course lute repertoire without ever resorting to using the left hand thumb to stop a note. I think too, that one could argue that a left hand technique for the lute closely based on modern classical guitar methodology is

Re: Lute Editing Programmes

2005-02-14 Thread Roman Turovsky
> Dana Emery's re-emergance onto the lutenet has reminded me of a quetion I've > > been meaning to ask for ages. Does anyone have any suggestions as to what > > programmes to use for editing tablature? (On a Mac?)>> > > I use Sibelius and love it, and have learned to do basically what I want wi

Re: Re: Antwort: left hand thumb to stop bass notes

2005-02-14 Thread s.walsh
In fact, one > of the > prime examples of pictorial evidence of what we are talking > about is the well known supposed portrait of Francesco da Milano, which > could give us cause to reappraise our ideas of what his playing > technique was actually like. We can be sure that he habitually played

Re: Antwort: left hand thumb to stop bass notes

2005-02-14 Thread Denys Stephens
Dear Marion, I think it's probably possible to play the entire 6 course lute repertoire without ever resorting to using the left hand thumb to stop a note. I think too, that one could argue that a left hand technique for the lute closely based on modern classical guitar methodology is the most effi

R: Lute Editing Programmes

2005-02-14 Thread Francesco Tribioli
> Fronimo is great for Windows platform, though it doesn't have > the feature I love in Sibelius, which is its midi playback capability. Fronimo had MIDI playback capability from the very beginning, even directly from tablature. 8^) Francesco To get on or off this list see list information at

Re: Antwort: left hand thumb to stop bass notes

2005-02-14 Thread Vance Wood
Dear Denys: Actually by the 1650's the Lute was having additional courses added to it and most of the six course instruments were being converted. I agree, it is possible on a six course Lute. However I don't see how it would be possible to play much of Milano's music that way and still preserve

Re: Lute Editing Programmes

2005-02-14 Thread Lutebets
Hi, Benjamin -- In a message dated 2/14/05 9:36:17 AM, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: << Hello, Dana Emery's re-emergance onto the lutenet has reminded me of a quetion I've been meaning to ask for ages. Does anyone have any suggestions as to what programmes to use for editing tablature? (On a Mac

Re: Antwort: left hand thumb to stop bass notes

2005-02-14 Thread Denys Stephens
Dear Vance, Forgive me for challenging you on this, but it's my understanding that the lute typically in use for the greater part of the 16th century was a 6 course instrument, and that the few surviving original necks are narrow (e.g. Gerle& Magno Dieffopruchar). Using left hand thumb stopping of

Re: left hand thumb to stop bass notes

2005-02-14 Thread Denys Stephens
Dear All, I did some research on this several years ago and subsequently wrote an article for the Lute Society which goes into the issue in too much length to reproduce here. However, the first paragraph might help to support the view that the left thumb was used to stop basses on 6 course lutes:

Re: Antwort: left hand thumb to stop bass notes

2005-02-14 Thread Vance Wood
In reality; unless you have only a six course Lute with a narrow neck I don't see how using the thumb to stop anything (but the mobility of the other four fingers) is going to be possible unless your thumb is very long, your neck very narrow and you are not playing counterpoint. Vance Wood. -

Lute Editing Programmes

2005-02-14 Thread Benjamin Narvey
Hello, Dana Emery's re-emergance onto the lutenet has reminded me of a quetion I've been meaning to ask for ages. Does anyone have any suggestions as to what programmes to use for editing tablature? (On a Mac?) I recently did some work for the Finn twins who created Sibelius, and they gave me

Re: temperaments

2005-02-14 Thread Dr. Marion Ceruti
-Original Message- From: LGS-Europe <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Sent: Feb 14, 2005 2:57 AM To: Stephan Olbertz <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, lute@cs.dartmouth.edu Subject: Re: temperaments Of course musicians complain, they're human. Especially fretted members. Singers don't notice, they just sing out o

Re: Double strings

2005-02-14 Thread Eugene C. Braig IV
At 05:19 AM 2/12/2005, Martin Shepherd wrote: >The modern 12-string guitar is tuned in octaves on the lowest three courses. More often, the lowest four, only b and e' being in unison. Best, Eugene To get on or off this list see list information at http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/

Re: Antwort: Re:Antwort: left hand thumb to stop bass notes

2005-02-14 Thread s.walsh
> > yes - after sending my previous message I thought the player in the > painting would look a bit like a Rock- or Blues-Guitarist. > > Best wishes > Thomas > It’s strange; I must have completely misremembered a discussion of the left hand thumb to fret notes in some lute music. Perhap

Antwort: Re:Antwort: left hand thumb to stop bass notes

2005-02-14 Thread thomas . schall
yes - after sending my previous message I thought the player in the painting would look a bit like a Rock- or Blues-Guitarist. Best wishes Thomas "[EMAIL PROTECTED]" Kopie: "s.walsh" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "lute" Thema: Re:Antwort: left hand thumb to stop bass notes > This would apply

Re:Antwort: left hand thumb to stop bass notes

2005-02-14 Thread [EMAIL PROTECTED]
> This would apply on the early romantic guitars with the more narrow neck > less than to modern classical guitars. Or in the blues guitar! Paolo > > Best wishes > Thomas > > > > > <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> am 14.02.2005 00:27:41 > > An:lute@cs.dartmouth.edu > Kopie: > > Thema: left hand th

Re: temperaments

2005-02-14 Thread LGS-Europe
Dear Stephan >> Do in your experience other ensemble members ever complain over having to cope with the cembalist's irregular temperament with lots of different half tone steps, thirds etc. ? << ;-) Of course musicians complain, they're human. Especially fretted members. Singers don't notice,

Antwort: left hand thumb to stop bass notes

2005-02-14 Thread thomas . schall
Hi! I don't think it makes much sense stopping strings with the LH thumb on the lute. Most old tutors suggest a position of the left hand similar to modern guitar technique (with the left hand thumb in the middle - or below - of the back of the neck). I don't think the lute player in the pai

Re: temperaments

2005-02-14 Thread Stephan Olbertz
Dear David, thanks for your answer. You wrote: > Jägermeister III. I have to play irregular temperaments occasionlly. > Werckmeister-variants, 'Bach' temperament (...?); things harpsichordist > invent. I can do this a little when playing continuo, because I can choose > which notes to use and whi

Re: left hand thumb to stop bass notes

2005-02-14 Thread Jon Murphy
Yup, completely different wrist position. I can't speak to the lute, as I'm too new (but I'm not sure I could find a use for a thumb stop except for an unusual "open" chord, or sequence. But the painting you direct us to could also be a "soft thumb" as the player turns to his fingers on the first c