[LUTE] Re: Re-tuning the diapason of a 7c

2012-05-02 Thread Ed Durbrow
On May 3, 2012, at 1:06 AM, Joshua Burkholder wrote: > I actually think a a 7th course in D and fingering the third fret will work > fine for me in the majority of stuff I want to play Right now my 7th course is old and fingering the 3rd fret is really sharp. I have to remember to really push

[LUTE] Re: Re-tuning the diapason of a 7c

2012-05-02 Thread Daniel Winheld
The 7 course configurtation can be superior- in somewhat the same way & for the same reasons that an 11 course Baroque lute is far more elegant, architecturally sounder, easier to handle, and tonally balanced than the 13 course bass rider thing- but which is the model I own, because I play Wei

[LUTE] Re: Re-tuning the diapason of a 7c

2012-05-02 Thread William Samson
This isn't just a 7c problem. I play a 10c in transitional tunings and need to change the top couple of courses for viel ton tuning. My way of working is to concentrate on pieces for your current stringing. Once you've exhausted that repertoire, restring and retune for another repe

[LUTE] Re: Re-tuning the diapason of a 7c

2012-05-02 Thread Sam Chapman
Hi Joshua, I have a 7-course lute and I usually tune the 7th course to D. However, I keep an extra 7th course in the case, and if I'm playing lots of music where I need the 7th course in F I simply change it over. It takes about 5 minutes to change the course, and if you use plain gut strings they

[LUTE] Re: Re-tuning the diapason of a 7c

2012-05-02 Thread David van Ooijen
On 2 May 2012 17:39, Joshua Burkholder wrote: > I know that some people re-tune the 7th course from D to F as needed, but on > my rental lute this seems quite impossible. The diapason is stung to F and if > I drop it down to D it becomes far too wobbly and flabby. Hi Joshua, welcome to lute ca

[LUTE] Re: Re-tuning the diapason of a 7c

2012-05-02 Thread Edward Martin
It is on the 8th course. I have seen the practice of going with D on 7th, F on 8th, but I could never do that, as I predominantly play baroque lute, and inverting these 2 would be most treacherous, for me. ed At 01:20 PM 5/2/2012, Miles Dempster wrote: >Hi Ed, > >On your 8-course do you hav

[LUTE] Re: Re-tuning the diapason of a 7c

2012-05-02 Thread Leonard Williams
In my own limited experience with an 8 course, tuning the D down to a C (just one tone!) created the problem you cite. It took some time with a string calculator to find a string that would work at both pitches. (I used gimped gut with plain gut octave, btw.) Leonard On 5/2/12 11:39 AM, "Joshu

[LUTE-BUILDER] Re: Why no mahogany?

2012-05-02 Thread Woodford
Bill, Mahogany as an export timber arrived on the scene fairly late in terms of lute construction. Very little of it made its way into European cabinetry shops until the 18th century. Most of the mahogany growing at that time was in areas controlled by Spain and in 1622 Cuban mahogany was dec

[LUTE] Re: Info of the Add. MS. 15117, British Museum?

2012-05-02 Thread Alain
A copy of this MS is available for Django registered users at http://musickshandmade.com/lute/facbooks/view/22. Everybody has access to the contents at the same address. Alain On 5/2/2012 12:19 PM, David van Ooijen wrote: On 2 May 2012 21:13, Arto Wikla wrote: I happened to find one page of

[LUTE] Re: Re-tuning the diapason of a 7c

2012-05-02 Thread Edward Mast
After about three years playing an 8 course lute, I acquired a 7 course. It is the 7 course instrument I now most often play; I do find it the most comfortable for me. I tune the 7th course to D and stop the F as needed. Ned On May 2, 2012, at 12:06 PM, Daniel Winheld wrote: > Your post expla

[LUTE] Re: Info of the Add. MS. 15117, British Museum?

2012-05-02 Thread David van Ooijen
On 2 May 2012 21:13, Arto Wikla wrote: > I happened to find one page of the Add. MS. 15117, British Museum, among my > That page was  the "Willow Song" as a lute song with handwritten tabulature. Years and years ago that page was on display in the British Museum when I visited. Next to handwritt

[LUTE] Info of the Add. MS. 15117, British Museum?

2012-05-02 Thread Arto Wikla
Dear lutenists, I happened to find one page of the Add. MS. 15117, British Museum, among my files - actually in an unexpected folder containing computer science... That page was the "Willow Song" as a lute song with handwritten tabulature. Not bad. Does anyone here happen know more of that m

[LUTE] Re: Re-tuning the diapason of a 7c

2012-05-02 Thread Sean Smith
Aha, thanks, Ed. Plan your tension in between and split the tension difference. Makes sense to me. Converting it to something else entirely? Sigh. Ok, just kidding. (And yes, I know it's the most athentic way to build a baroque lute) s On May 2, 2012, at 11:05 AM, Edward Martin wrote:

[LUTE] Re: Re-tuning the diapason of a 7c

2012-05-02 Thread Sean Smith
Joshua, There's a lifetime's worth of music in 16th century. If you put on one more course to accomodate Dowland more power to you. Me? I guess I've been shedding courses over my years at it having discovered the renaissance guitar lately. (Mrs Smith, who doesn't share our love of nuance

[LUTE] Re: Re-tuning the diapason of a 7c

2012-05-02 Thread Joshua Burkholder
Thanks Alan, the plucking close the bridge seems like good tip indeed. As for a 6-, 7-, and 10-course lute being the perfect set up for the renassaince, why, I'm already a third of the way there! As long as I don't get interested in baroque or continuo playing! On May 2, 2012, at 19:59, Alan Ho

[LUTE] Re: Re-tuning the diapason of a 7c

2012-05-02 Thread Miles Dempster
Hi Ed, On your 8-course do you have the D on the 7th or 8th course? Miles On 2012-05-02, at 2:05 PM, Edward Martin wrote: > Hi Sean, > > Actually, I do not have a 7-course lute at the moment, I use an > 8-course for renaissance lute, as for the reasons cited. i did have > a 7-course, whic

[LUTE-BUILDER] Why no mahogany?

2012-05-02 Thread William Samson
Dear Collective Wisdom, I see that mahogany is never recommended as a lute building material (except perhaps for neck blocks). I wonder why this should be? Are there no surviving old lutes that used it? I do know that the Jacquemart-Andree vihuela is now believed to have dark mah

[LUTE] Re: Re-tuning the diapason of a 7c

2012-05-02 Thread Edward Martin
Hi Sean, Actually, I do not have a 7-course lute at the moment, I use an 8-course for renaissance lute, as for the reasons cited. i did have a 7-course, which was converted to an 11-course, Frei. When I used it as a 7-course lute, I essentially had it strung with a string in-between the 2 to

[LUTE] Re: Re-tuning the diapason of a 7c

2012-05-02 Thread Sean Smith
If you haven't yet ordered a lute, I would consider an 8 course, which in my opinion is more versatile.A It even allows you to cheat and play 10 course music... Very true, Bruno, I loved exploring the Vallet and Ballard books for years on my 8c, turning singers on to Airs de cours

[LUTE] Re: Re-tuning the diapason of a 7c

2012-05-02 Thread Nancy Carlin
Hi Joshua, I have 6 and 9 course orpharions and find that almost all mainstream renaissance music works on the 6 course. There are some pieces where you need to move low Ds and Fs up an octave, but after a while you do this automatically. Where the 6 course is limited is the few pi

[LUTE] Re: Re-tuning the diapason of a 7c

2012-05-02 Thread Joshua Burkholder
Dear Bruno, Well, I didn't really want to start a 7C vs 8c debate, since I get the impression this fairly well-trodden ground for you guys on this list. I have considered an 8-course, in fact it was my initial plan, and can see the attractiveness of its flexibility. But I really feel most attra

[LUTE] Nylgut Oud strings

2012-05-02 Thread Bruno Fournier
Hi, A I'm interested in trying out Mimmo's Nylgut Oud strings on my Moroccan Oud.A Anyone has experience with them? I note that like all Oud string sets, the 3 rd string is wound.A I personally prefer a non-wound string on the 3rd course.A I currently use gut on my first 3 co

[LUTE] Re: Re-tuning the diapason of a 7c

2012-05-02 Thread Bruno Fournier
Hello A If you haven't yet ordered a lute, I would consider an 8 course, which in my opinion is more versatile.A It even allows you to cheat and play 10 course music...A A Bruno On Wed, May 2, 2012 at 11:48 AM, Braig, Eugene <[1]brai...@osu.edu> wrote: It's be

[LUTE] Re: Re-tuning the diapason of a 7c

2012-05-02 Thread Eugene Kurenko
And what about 8c lute with reentrant tuning in basses? 7th course=D and 8th course=F 2012/5/2 Arto Wikla <[1]wi...@cs.helsinki.fi> Dear Joshua, welcome to the gang! I think you can make the same 7th work in F and D. My example: 7-course Venere, 58 cm, the 7th course:

[LUTE] Re: Re-tuning the diapason of a 7c

2012-05-02 Thread Arto Wikla
Dear Joshua, welcome to the gang! I think you can make the same 7th work in F and D. My example: 7-course Venere, 58 cm, the 7th course: Aquila's new nylgut octave 94 NNG Aquila's type D string 195 D The tensions are (a'=440Hz) in F 3.657 Kg / 3.935 Kg in D 2.586 Kg / 2.782 Kg F is quite

[LUTE] Re: Re-tuning the diapason of a 7c

2012-05-02 Thread Joshua Burkholder
Thanks Daniel, I do come to the lute from the guitar, though with a hiatus of 6 or 7 years in between, so I am not finding the learning curve too steep, even though I was not a particularly accomplished guitar player. Fortunately I'm a freelancer who works from home and so have a lot of time to

[LUTE] Re: Re-tuning the diapason of a 7c

2012-05-02 Thread Joshua Burkholder
Eugene, Well I have considered (and tried) an 8-course, and understand their advantages, but the music I'm most interested in is mostly 6 and 7 course, and so I feel like I don't really need the extra course. In any case, let's leave aside my choice of lute for the moment (though your advice is

[LUTE] Re: Re-tuning the diapason of a 7c

2012-05-02 Thread Daniel Winheld
Your post explains why the 8 course lute was developed, or as I like to call it, the "Double 7" . I have never found a string material of any sort that would stand up to a scordatura range exceeding a whole tone. Even going for a compromise tension (say an ideal E/E-flat) would still be unsatisf

[LUTE] Re: Re-tuning the diapason of a 7c

2012-05-02 Thread Braig, Eugene
It's beginning to sound like an 8-course might actually better suit your needs. While short lived in period, they seem pretty ubiquitous today. Best, Eugene -Original Message- From: lute-...@cs.dartmouth.edu [mailto:lute-...@cs.dartmouth.edu] On Behalf Of Joshua Burkholder Sent: Wednes

[LUTE] Re-tuning the diapason of a 7c

2012-05-02 Thread Joshua Burkholder
Dear lute-listers, A question from a beginner: First to introduce myself, my name is Joshua and I've been playing the lute for several months now; I have been on the list for a couple weeks and am really enjoying following your discussions. I have a rental 7-course and I am now in the process

[LUTE] Fw: Bach’s Lute Suites: This Moth is Blessed

2012-05-02 Thread Gary Digman
Hi Roman, I'm confused. Are you saying that the gamba parts are subordinate to the organ, that the gamba is accompanying the organ and not the other way around. Gary - Original Message - From: "Roman Turovsky" To: ; "Gary Digman" Sent: Tuesday, May 01, 2012 4:11 AM Subject: Re: [LUT