Re: [MOSAIC] Building comprehension of questions-was heartbreak /response to Reading Mastery

2009-02-21 Thread Jan Sanders
Jennifer, I have a couple of quick questions... Is the student ELL? If so, what level? Maybe the questions are out of her English Language Development "zone". If worded differently, she may be able to answer them? Also, what reading level is she? Maybe she doesn't know how to put her thoughts i

Re: [MOSAIC] Building comprehension of questions-was heartbreak/response to Reading Mastery

2009-02-20 Thread Sheryl Gowan
Kristin, it makes perfect sense to me. I had the same experience my 1st year as a literacy coach. My principal was not on board with any of this "fluff" A 3rd grade teacher approached me and told me that something I said in one of our study groups made him realize that he didn't know how to teac

Re: [MOSAIC] Building comprehension of questions-was heartbreak/response to Reading Mastery

2009-02-20 Thread Renee
It isn't that the feds NEED programs and other methods of teaching reading to be testing quantitatively. It is that they WANT them to be. When the National Reading Panel met, they started out by systematically throwing out all research that didn't meet their overall, already-established pho

Re: [MOSAIC] Building comprehension of questions-was heartbreak/response to Reading Mastery

2009-02-20 Thread Kristin Mitchell
Elisa and others, I've been following this conversation with much interest (as I'm sure many are!) and I think I've already piped in with this, but I need to bring it up again (it's possible I never did in the first place, I'm almost 6 months pregnant and I left my brain at about 8 weeks!). La

Re: [MOSAIC] Building comprehension of questions-was heartbreak/response to Reading Mastery

2009-02-20 Thread Waingort Jimenez, Elisa
Amy, Thanks for the research link suggestions. I will look them up. I think the big difference is whether the developers of Direct Instruction programs, who also produced their own research saying their programs work, made profits from their programs based on their research results and marketin

Re: [MOSAIC] Building comprehension of questions-was heartbreak/response to Reading Mastery

2009-02-19 Thread Melissa Kile
n...@literacyworkshop.org > [mailto:mosaic-boun...@literacyworkshop.org] On Behalf Of Christi Poteet > Sent: February-19-09 7:20 PM > To: Mosaic: A Reading Comprehension Strategies Email Group; > mosaic@literacyworkshop.org > Subject: Re: [MOSAIC] Building comprehension of questions-was

Re: [MOSAIC] Building comprehension of questions-was heartbreak/response to Reading Mastery

2009-02-19 Thread W.Robertson
Group; mosaic@literacyworkshop.org Subject: Re: [MOSAIC] Building comprehension of questions-was heartbreak/response to Reading Mastery QAR would be awesome!! Phyllis Hostmeyer has a great website for QAR and many other comprehension strategies. Her website is www.PhylsQuil.com Christi A. P

Re: [MOSAIC] Building comprehension of questions-was heartbreak/response to Reading Mastery

2009-02-19 Thread Christi Poteet
...@literacyworkshop.org on behalf of cnjpal...@aol.com Sent: Thu 2/19/2009 8:23 PM To: mosaic@literacyworkshop.org Subject: [MOSAIC] Building comprehension of questions-was heartbreak/response to Reading Mastery I am just finishing up the second of two courses in my doctorate on "disciplined inquiry&

[MOSAIC] Building comprehension of questions-was heartbreak /response to Reading Mastery

2009-02-19 Thread CNJPALMER
I am just finishing up the second of two courses in my doctorate on "disciplined inquiry". One of the things I have learned is how to evaluate research articles. I thank you, Amy, for posting the research links...and I look forward to reading through your links when I get a few minutes. I