Re: Hierarchies, decision making and a real-life example

2004-04-13 Thread Mike Copeland
G'day Harrison I returned from Easter break this bright Autumn morning to this!!! "The real issue for me is not only the separation of passion and responsibility, but also the assignment of responsibility in an arbitrary fashion. The way things are done in the "standard" bureaucratic hierarchy; t

Re: Hierarchies, decision making and a real-life example

2004-04-09 Thread Fr Brian S Bainbridge
Dear Chris's et al, One of the things I have observed that the words Hierarchy" and "Bureaucracy" hove gotten loaded with a lot of negativity and bad baggage, one way or another. That's perhaps rather unfortunate, even though it is true and deserved, as I see it. Because both concepts have a great

Re: Hierarchies, decision making and a real-life example

2004-04-09 Thread Harrison Owen
IST [mailto:osl...@listserv.boisestate.edu] On Behalf Of Michael Herman Sent: Friday, April 09, 2004 3:50 AM To: osl...@listserv.boisestate.edu Subject: Re: Hierarchies, decision making and a real-life example ah, brian, i'll add a few of your fellow aussies into this mix... i have always found fred and merrelyn e

Re: Hierarchies, decision making and a real-life example

2004-04-09 Thread Michael Herman
ah, brian, i'll add a few of your fellow aussies into this mix... i have always found fred and merrelyn emery's definition of "bureaucratic hierarchy" most helpful. bh, they say is characterized by "responsibility for the work (the taking care of things) resting or being vested one or more level

Re: Hierarchies, decision making and a real-life example

2004-04-08 Thread Chris Corrigan
chris macrae wrote: Does this sort of answer your question? Oh yes...more than answers it... Chi Meegwetch, Chris * * == osl...@listserv.boisestate.edu -- To subscribe, unsubscribe, change your options, vi

Re: Hierarchies, decision making and a real-life example

2004-04-07 Thread Julie Stuart
Chris, Chris, Nicolai... Well, you've flushed out this lurker anyway - although I like Lisa's(?) 'witness' better. In terms of measurement and quantifiable vs. qualifiable(?), much work has been happening here in Northern Ireland in recent times to find better ways for funders of community dev

Re: Hierarchies, decision making and a real-life example

2004-04-07 Thread chris macrae
is sort of answer your question? Chris Macrae www.valuetrue.com -Original Message- From: OSLIST [mailto:osl...@listserv.boisestate.edu] On Behalf Of Chris Corrigan Sent: 06 April 2004 17:13 To: osl...@listserv.boisestate.edu Subject: Re: Hierarchies, decision makin

Re: Hierarchies, decision making and a real-life example

2004-04-07 Thread Chris Corrigan
That's an awesome link Julie...thanks a lot. I have a huge list of people that will be keen to see this work. Chris * * == osl...@listserv.boisestate.edu -- To subscribe, unsubscribe, change your options, view t

Re: Hierarchies, decision making and a real-life example

2004-04-07 Thread Nicolai von Ertzdorff
`"...immediately privileges the quantifiable over the qualifiable"- Indeed "tricky"! Hi, I always supposed it to be the other way round. To have a look on what I want to qualify and then searching for the right scale for what I should quantify..so, my focus implies also a "hierarchy of results, I'

Re: Hierarchies, decision making and a real-life example

2004-04-06 Thread chris macrae
Chris Corrigan wrote Measurement uber alles is tricky because it immediately privileges the quantifiable over the qualifiable. And certainly, we need to measure things, but I'm leering of forcing qualitative experiences into measurement-friendly formats. By necessity it strips what is most import

Re: Hierarchies, decision making and a real-life example

2004-04-06 Thread Pannwitz, Michael M
cribe, unsubscribe, change your options, view the archives Visit: >http://listserv.boisestate.edu/archives/oslist.html > > > >-Original Message- >From: OSLIST [mailto:osl...@listserv.boisestate.edu] On Behalf Of Peggy >Holman >Sent: Friday, April 02, 2004 12:03 PM >To: osl..

Re: Hierarchies, decision making and a real-life example

2004-04-06 Thread Chris Corrigan
chris macrae wrote: Chris Macrae For 20 years researching social and organisational identities I was weary about measuring organisational relationships, but then the mathematician in me woke up. Measurements don't just determine wh

Re: Hierarchies, decision making and a real-life example

2004-04-05 Thread Chris Corrigan
chris macrae wrote: Chris- my view would be that its always possible that some organisations will get stuff done in spite of hierarchy's excesses Beyond possible: I think it happens ALOT. In really rigid hierarchies, like bureaucracies, my experience is that most stuff happens in spite of the

Re: Hierarchies, decision making and a real-life example

2004-04-05 Thread Meg Salter
m...@megsalter.com - Original Message - From: chris macrae To: osl...@listserv.boisestate.edu Sent: Friday, April 02, 2004 11:01 AM Subject: Re: Hierarchies, decision making and a real-life example Wonder if anyone could help me with NOT reinventing the wheel on an extended

Re: Hierarchies, decision making and a real-life example

2004-04-04 Thread chris macrae
Well nature says that as we all get more connected (and the technology of the net is I imagine unstoppable) then open boundary knowledge is vital Open Boundaries are how you cooperate as well as keep your own contextual/identifying gravity (which some would call your competitive focus) - you can w

Re: Hierarchies, decision making and a real-life example

2004-04-03 Thread Chris Corrigan
Ashley Cooper wrote: d and fluid. boundaries are especially effective if they are always invited to dissolve when they have outlived their usefulness. This is kind of a natural accountability, the accountability of consent. Very powerful stuff. I think we see it happen in Open Space a lot,

Re: Hierarchies, decision making and a real-life example

2004-04-03 Thread Ashley Cooper
3:08:39 AM > Subject: Re: Hierarchies, decision making and a real-life example > > chris macrae wrote: > > > I have decided I want to survey when is top-down organisational > > hierarchy useful (and not useful) as > > > > well as how can hierarchy interact

Re: Hierarchies, decision making and a real-life example

2004-04-03 Thread chris macrae
Chris- my view would be that its always possible that some organisations will get stuff done in spite of hierarchy's excesses But I don't see why understanding of organisations hasn't got beyond recognising that hierarchy is only one of several systems that a thriving people-investing organisation

Re: Hierarchies, decision making and a real-life example

2004-04-03 Thread Chris Corrigan
chris macrae wrote: I have decided I want to survey when is top-down organisational hierarchy useful (and not useful) as well as how can hierarchy interact with useful and not useful impacts on self-organisation, co-organisation, inter-organisation (as where 2 or more organsiations truly partn

Re: Hierarchies, decision making and a real-life example

2004-04-02 Thread Harrison Owen
riday, April 02, 2004 12:03 PM To: osl...@listserv.boisestate.edu Subject: Re: Hierarchies, decision making and a real-life example Ah, Michael, you caught me. I used the broad term (CAS) when really meaning that elusive subset sometimes called the conscious self-organizing system, sometimes named as an

Re: Hierarchies, decision making and a real-life example

2004-04-02 Thread chris macrae
Wonder if anyone could help me with NOT reinventing the wheel on an extended question about hierarchies (albeit not a pure open space question) I have decided I want to survey when is top-down organisational hierarchy useful (and not useful) as well as how can hierarchy interact with useful and n

Re: Hierarchies, decision making and a real-life example of group dynamics

2004-04-02 Thread Ilse Debler
ent: Friday, April 02, 2004 1:16 PM Subject: SV: Hierarchies, decision making and a real-life example Hello all of you wonderful people out there - and thank you for this list and all of your contributions!!! Peggy - So many wise words and thoughts and an analyses of what is going on

SV: Hierarchies, decision making and a real-life example

2004-04-02 Thread Eva P Svensson
05 Mobil 0706 - 89 85 50 e...@epshumaninvest.se -Ursprungligt meddelande- Från: OSLIST [mailto:osl...@listserv.boisestate.edu]För Peggy Holman Skickat: den 2 april 2004 06:42 Till: osl...@listserv.boisestate.edu Ämne: Hierarchies, decision making and a real-life example I am so tickled

Re: Hierarchies, decision making and a real-life example

2004-04-02 Thread Peggy Holman
y, April 01, 2004 10:29 PM Subject: Re: [OSLIST] Hierarchies, decision making and a real-life example > Dear Peggy, > and here I thought all systems and organizations (traditional or > whatever) are complex adaptive systems? > Also, I had the hunch from my long life in a "traditiona

Re: Hierarchies, decision making and a real-life example

2004-04-02 Thread Pannwitz, Michael M
Dear Peggy, and here I thought all systems and organizations (traditional or whatever) are complex adaptive systems? Also, I had the hunch from my long life in a "traditional" organization (and that enforces my question on all systems being CAS) that things there often appeared to happen regardless

Hierarchies, decision making and a real-life example

2004-04-01 Thread Peggy Holman
I am so tickled! I have been away from the list for a month and as a result read about 200 messages in one sitting. Perhaps because of this concentration, I noticed something that excites me. The thread on hierachy was moving into a discussion of the occurence of hierarchies in nature. The f