WG Co-Chair hat ON
I have seen three comments on this draft in response to this WG last call -
which is perhaps on the very lower bound of what could be considered an
acceptable demonstration of WG consensus with the document.
There have been positive responses in favour of moving this document
I have reviewed the ROA format draft. In, general, I'm fine with
sending it to the IESG now. Thanks again to the editors for putting
together a readable doc.
As with the architecture document, I have some reservations about
publishing the data format documents before the validation
algorithm
I have read (and implemented) this document, and support it going
forward.
My only comment from this review is that the text "If it is present it
MUST be ignored by the relying party" in sections 2.1.6.4.3 and
2.1.6.4.4 is perhaps a bit strong. The text immediately following in
both cases is fine
Matt,
In hindsight I think that any recommendations of ordering should exist in
some other document (akin to the one you alluded to in the thread on
sidr-arch-09 refresh cycle) which covers more operational aspects.
Cheers
Terry
On 6/11/09 6:46 AM, "Matt Lepinski" wrote:
> Terry,
>
> Can you
Terry,
Can you elaborate on what you'd like to see in section 3 of the document?
My interpretation of your comment is that you would like to see a
prescribed (or recommended) order for the checks performed in ROA
validation. I am reluctant to put in such a prescribed ordering in this
document
I support this document going forward.
the only comment I have is that I'd prefer to see a preference order in
validation (section 3) to help relying party S/W writers to make efficient
choices in the validation path - but that isn't a stopping block for me.
Cheers
Terry
On 28/10/09 12:48 PM, "G
The WG chairs have received a Working Group Last Call request from the
authors of draft-ietf-sidr-roa-format-06.txt.
The document (and the draft history) is at
http://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-ietf-sidr-roa-format-06
The Last Call will end as of the close of business on Monday 23rd
November
