Re: [pfSense Support] PF and UT not working

2008-07-27 Thread ram
On Fri, Jul 25, 2008 at 9:16 PM, Tim Nelson [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I agree... and also try completely removing the Untangle box from the network to see if the problem clears up. Hi thanks all the people support. let me clarify as the people asking why iam using both the product simple

Re: [pfSense Support] PF and UT not working

2008-07-27 Thread RB
simple reason, UT does not have capitive portal. So you're just wanting to use the captive portal on pfSense? What services on the UT are you using? Fact of captive portal which is MAC based, and UT is a b-router so passing it's own MAC. See the m0n0wall and pfsense mail lists for support on

Re: [pfSense Support] PF and UT not working

2008-07-27 Thread ram
On Sun, Jul 27, 2008 at 7:03 PM, RB [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: simple reason, UT does not have capitive portal. So you're just wanting to use the captive portal on pfSense? What services on the UT are you using? iam using all the Services of UT, iam using PF for authentication and DHCP

Re: [pfSense Support] PF and UT not working

2008-07-27 Thread Curtis LaMasters
Does Untangle have the ability to do a TCP dump? I could enable that in the inside interface and then the outside interface on UT, compare the two and see what you come up with. It may be worthwhile to do this on the external side of pf as well. If UT's bridge mode is truly bridge, then you

Re: [pfSense Support] Snort Install Missing

2008-07-27 Thread Chris Buechler
On Sat, Jul 26, 2008 at 5:53 PM, Paul Peziol [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Is there plans for snort or replacment in the 1.3 verions or what can I do as a replacement for it. I was planning on putting it in on a network that has a few webservers on it to help secure it alittle more. Any

Re: [pfSense Support] Manual Outbound NAT Question

2008-07-27 Thread Chris Buechler
On Sat, Jul 26, 2008 at 5:00 AM, Bryan Derman [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Re: There is nothing in your config that requires AON, ... --- You're correct. It was historical* and I've now reduced/fixed/tested/deployed the config: Now: http://www.derman.com/Misc/router/pfSenseReduced.html

Re: [pfSense Support] PF and UT not working

2008-07-27 Thread RB
On Sun, Jul 27, 2008 at 8:22 AM, ram [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: iam using all the Services of UT, iam using PF for authentication and DHCP Server Since you seem either uninterested or incapable of telling us anything other than I have object foo with all the knobs turned on and most of us

Re: [pfSense Support] Manual Outbound NAT Question

2008-07-27 Thread Bryan Derman
Re: Can you open a bug ticket at http://cvstrac.pfsense.org with specific steps on replicating the problem? --- Yes, I've been working towards producing an MFE (minimal faulty example). Think I have it, (hopefully) just need a final QA pass. If that's it, then it looks like it's related to having

Re: [pfSense Support] PF and UT not working

2008-07-27 Thread ram
Mr RB I belive you do not have Idea what exactly UT Does UT claims that they have webfilter, IDS, Firewall, SPAM protection lot more you can refer their features, ( iam yet to test) so iam not comparing the any products here, so iam not going to do marketing call since i have situation where

Re: [pfSense Support] PF and UT not working

2008-07-27 Thread Chris Buechler
On Sun, Jul 27, 2008 at 12:04 PM, Curtis LaMasters [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Does Untangle have the ability to do a TCP dump? I could enable that in the inside interface and then the outside interface on UT, compare the two and see what you come up with. It may be worthwhile to do this on the

Re: [pfSense Support] PF and UT not working

2008-07-27 Thread sai
how is your network setup? 1 PC ---switch UT ---pfsense or 2 PC ---switch ---pfsense UT I would suggest trying 2 since you just want the CP on pfsense sai On Sun, Jul 27, 2008 at 9:53 PM, Chris Buechler [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: On Sun, Jul 27, 2008 at 12:04 PM, Curtis LaMasters