Resource Roads are tricky for me. They often have access restrictions and
may be closed and barricaded once a lease expires or a forestry block has
been replanted. (at least in Manitoba) I use either
highway=track
tracktype=grade3
or
highway=path
FIXME: verify accesibility by trucks and ATVs, may
Voir discussion en français / See English discussion below
Paul Norman,sat. november 2012 6h37
Subject : Internal CanVec conflicts
Is it the communities view that it is okay to import CanVec without
reconciling the internal differences between the layers?
My view is that importing data
Hi Paul,
It probably won't come to you as a surprise if I would say it is
acceptable, but to a certain degree. A map with no data is not a map. A
map with inconsistent data is still a map, but obviously something is
not right. A map with perfectly consistent data doesn't need to tell the
Hi Pierre,
I'm glad to see you're taking a constructive approach towards the
discussion initiated by Paul :) I definitely agree something needs to be
done to make imports more manageable, especially the Canvec import.
There is also an amount of work left behind as I mentioned in my other
Frank Steggink november 13 2012 15h37
answering Paul Norman
However, time is limited, so I eventually decided
to stop. The reasons which motivated me doing imports are no longer
enough to continue. It is
partially due to the criticism of you and
others. If my contributions are not
Frank Steggink november 13 2012 16h13
Apart from the inconsistencies, there is for example also the Geobase import.
In 2009 the available Geobase data didn't contain road names in Québec, and by
then it was also not clear when it would contain names. So there are many areas
which have roads
Bonjour,
Je suis un nouveau participant au projet OSM, par contre je ne suis pas un
débutant en cartographie et je saisis assez bien les termes de la discussion
en cours. Mon intérêt est le canot-camping en région éloigné et la plus-part
de mes zones dintérêt sont au nord du 49 (au Québec),
Canvec data appears to be produced with a maximum of 2K nodes per way. I assume
that this was an attempt by the Canvec people to meet the max 2K node criteria
of the OSM database. When the split occurs in a way that is a member of a
multipolygon, there's not a problem. Otherwise, as Paul has
I have wondered about setting up a snapshot-server and loading CanVec on it
then setting up a P2 deployment pointing at it.
The problem with splitting by layers is that OSM data is not divided by
layers (including planet files). In general if you have interdependent
layers and you want to use
9 matches
Mail list logo
