Re: [Talk-ca] Proposal to tag Yonge Street in Toronto and York Region as Primary

2020-07-17 Thread Kevin Farrugia
Maybe we look at volume and connectivity to higher orders of road and/or connectivity to other municipalities as the criteria? In some areas these will also happen to be former provincial highways (ex: parts of former Hwy 7, parts of former Hwy 10/Hurontario, Main St (Hamilton), etc.) while

Re: [Talk-ca] Proposal to tag Yonge Street in Toronto and York Region as Primary

2020-07-17 Thread john whelan
What Jarek says makes sense to me. I suspect many of the map users don't live where the use the map. Having said that could we come up with something that could be applied across Canada or is that too much to ask for? Thanks John On Thu, Jul 16, 2020, 22:39 Jarek Piórkowski wrote: > On Thu,

Re: [Talk-ca] Proposal to tag Yonge Street in Toronto and York Region as Primary

2020-07-16 Thread Jarek Piórkowski
On Thu, 16 Jul 2020 at 11:30, Andrew Deng via Talk-ca wrote: > Hello, I believe Yonge Street in Toronto and York Region (Regional Road 1) > should be tagged as highway=primary rather than highway=secondary as it is > tagged now. > Here are some reasons I believe why: > 1) Yonge Street is

Re: [Talk-ca] Proposal to tag Yonge Street in Toronto and York Region as Primary

2020-07-16 Thread Kevin Farrugia
Yeah, it changes from place to place and what has historically been the standard. I'm not against changing the standard, maybe we just need a better or updated definition for what can be a primary road in Ontario. Perhaps we make some standards for the heavily urbanised areas of Ontario where

Re: [Talk-ca] Proposal to tag Yonge Street in Toronto and York Region as Primary

2020-07-16 Thread Andrew Deng via Talk-ca
I thought the tagging would be similar to the US, where roads are tagged based on its traffic volume and importance which is why I thought Yonge should be Primary. I see now. --   Andrew Student On Thursday, July 16, 2020, 08:31:48 p.m. EDT, Kevin Farrugia wrote: Hey Andrew, I'm in

Re: [Talk-ca] Proposal to tag Yonge Street in Toronto and York Region as Primary

2020-07-16 Thread Kevin Farrugia
Hey Andrew, I'm in agreement with Justin. I think it's too urban a road, with urban speed limits along almost its entire length and many traffic lights. I definitely wouldn't consider the part of Yonge through downtown Toronto (or most of Toronto for that matter) to be Primary, with truck

Re: [Talk-ca] Proposal to tag Yonge Street in Toronto and York Region as Primary

2020-07-16 Thread Justin Tracey
In Canada, highway=primary is typically used for what I would call "highway-like" roads.[0] IMHO, Yonge is a "major" road, but has too many cross streets to be really considered highway-like, at least for most of its length. You can look at some of the other highway=primary roads in the area to

[Talk-ca] Proposal to tag Yonge Street in Toronto and York Region as Primary

2020-07-16 Thread Andrew Deng via Talk-ca
Hello, I believe Yonge Street in Toronto and York Region (Regional Road 1) should be tagged as highway=primary rather than highway=secondary as it is tagged now. Here are some reasons I believe why: 1) Yonge Street is considered the "Main Street" of Toronto, Thornhill, Richmond Hill, and