Re: Mind, Body, Spirit in Clinical Psychology & Psychiatry

2006-03-26 Thread Annette Taylor, Ph. D.
Yeah Robin for remembering this one! I actually have it in the bathroom as reading material for my teen-aged son, who thinks he doesn't like school. You'd be surprised the education he gets in the 'library' at home! Annette Quoting Robin Abrahams <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>: Jeffry Ricker <[EMAIL

Re: Mind, Body, Spirit in Clinical Psychology & Psychiatry

2006-03-26 Thread Robin Abrahams
Jeffry Ricker <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Thus, there really is nothing that cannot be discussed in my psychology courses (except for the psychology of extraterrestrials and teapots, as well as the psychology of extraterrestrial teapots).Jeffry--You evidently have never seen the cover

Re: Mind, Body, Spirit in Clinical Psychology & Psychiatry

2006-03-26 Thread Jeffry Ricker
On Mar 26, 2006, at 4:11 PM, Louis Schmier wrote:Jeff, I was being serious. JIn a way, so was I. It seems to me that "psychology" has become a "one-size-fits-all" kind of category. Anything to do with mind and behavior is accepted as a part of psychology. Lay people, in particular, think of psychol

RE: Mind, Body, Spirit in Clinical Psychology & Psychiatry

2006-03-26 Thread Louis Schmier
Jeff, I was being serious. J   Make it a good day.   --Louis-- Louis Schmier    www.therandomthoughts.com Department of History    : www.newforums.com/L_Schmier.htm Valdosta State University Valdosta, Georgia 31698    /\  

Re: Mind, Body, Spirit in Clinical Psychology & Psychiatry

2006-03-26 Thread Jeffry Ricker
On Mar 26, 2006, at 3:41 PM, Jeffry Ricker wrote:Extraterrestrial PsychologyOh, I forgot one: the psychology of tea pots. Jeffry P. Ricker, Ph.D.ChairDivision of Social & Behavioral Sciences-

Re: Mind, Body, Spirit in Clinical Psychology & Psychiatry

2006-03-26 Thread Jeffry Ricker
On Mar 26, 2006, at 2:29 PM, Louis Schmier wrote:what material is not acceptable, universally unacceptable, in your discipline?Extraterrestrial Psychology Jeffry P. Ricker, Ph.D.ChairDivision of Social & Behavioral Sciences

RE: Mind, Body, Spirit in Clinical Psychology & Psychiatry

2006-03-26 Thread Gary Klatsky
] Sent: Sunday, March 26, 2006 4:30 PM To: Teaching in the Psychological Sciences Subject: RE: Mind, Body, Spirit in Clinical Psychology & Psychiatry   Gary, I would take issue with you.  A discussion of the holocaust as a hoax does take place in the holocaust classes I teach.  I would think a sim

RE: Mind, Body, Spirit in Clinical Psychology & Psychiatry

2006-03-26 Thread Louis Schmier
Gary, I would take issue with you.  A discussion of the holocaust as a hoax does take place in the holocaust classes I teach.  I would think a similar discussion on intelligent design, especially since our democracy is based on it—“endowed by their Creator”—would take place in a biology cla

RE: Mind, Body, Spirit in Clinical Psychology & Psychiatry

2006-03-26 Thread Wendi K. Born
I am not sure whether or not this would address the concerns of your specific student, but I have found that a small window of personal (rather than intellectual) understanding goes a long way. I ALWAYS assign the book, Undercurrents: A life beneath the surface by Martha Manning, when I teach

RE: Mind, Body, Spirit in Clinical Psychology & Psychiatry

2006-03-26 Thread Gary Klatsky
: Louis Schmier [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Sunday, March 26, 2006 3:35 PM To: Teaching in the Psychological Sciences Subject: RE: Mind, Body, Spirit in Clinical Psychology & Psychiatry   Martin, I meant no slight.  I sought a clarification, but you answered the question.   Do I dete

RE: Mind, Body, Spirit in Clinical Psychology & Psychiatry

2006-03-26 Thread Louis Schmier
Martin, I meant no slight.  I sought a clarification, but you answered the question.   Do I detect a potential bias of what the professor deems acceptable or unacceptable psychology.  If that’s the case, then there’s a subjectivism in the teaching of psych.  Of course, that’s true in any di

RE: Mind, Body, Spirit in Clinical Psychology & Psychiatry

2006-03-26 Thread Martin Bourgeois
Title: RE: Mind, Body, Spirit in Clinical Psychology & Psychiatry Christopher, teach what?  Everything that occurs in the name of psychology or only that which the professor accepts as proper psychology?   --Louis-- Louis Sch

Mind, Body, Spirit in Clinical Psychology & Psychiatry

2006-03-26 Thread Louis Schmier
Christopher Green wrote: > As a teacher of the subject, you are not obliged to justify, to each and > every person's satisfaction, everything that takes place in the name of > psychology. You are only required to teach it. As students, they are not > obliged to accept everything that takes pla

Re: Mind, Body, Spirit in Clinical Psychology & Psychiatry

2006-03-26 Thread Christopher D. Green
Jeffry Ricker wrote: My question (which I know has been discussed in the past with respect to other topics): how would you have dealt with this student's rejection of a scientific approach to treating mental disorders? As a teacher of the subject, you are not obliged to justify, to each and

Mind, Body, Spirit in Clinical Psychology & Psychiatry

2006-03-26 Thread Pollak, Edward
Jeffry Ricker wrote "The other day in my abnormal-psychology course, I taught about the uses of ECT for the treatment of mental disorders. It turned out that what really was bothering the student is that "science" does not take into account the whole person, especially the spiritual asp

Re: Mind, Body, Spirit in Clinical Psychology & Psychiatry

2006-03-26 Thread Robert Wildblood
This always seems to come up in Abnormal psychology and my typical response is first the "psychology is a science" argument, and if that doesn't suffice, then I turn the discussion as to how almost all medications, vaccinations, etc. have a certain level of possible of fatality, but that doesn't pr

RE: Mind, Body, Spirit in Clinical Psychology & Psychiatry

2006-03-26 Thread Miguel Roig
Hi Jeff. Something that has worked for me personally and that I also used with those students who raise these issues in class is that one needs to attempt to compartmentalize our personal dualistic views with professional/scientific ones. Science is materialism, period. Because many of us ar

Mind, Body, Spirit in Clinical Psychology & Psychiatry

2006-03-25 Thread Jeffry Ricker
The other day in my abnormal-psychology course, I taught about the uses of ECT for the treatment of mental disorders. I stated that ECT is used to treat major depressive episodes in those with psychosis, those who are nonresponsive to antidepressant medications, those who are highly suicidal, and a