Re: Rack awareness support for Mesos

2016-06-17 Thread Du, Fan
lto:vinodk...@apache.org <mailto:vinodk...@apache.org>> <mailto:vinodk...@apache.org <mailto:vinodk...@apache.org> <mailto:vinodk...@apache.org <mailto:vinodk...@apache.org>>> <mailto:vinodk...@apache.org <mailto:vin

Re: Rack awareness support for Mesos

2016-06-16 Thread Joris Van Remoortere
; >> -- >> >> Aaron Carey >> Production Engineer - Cloud Pipeline >> Industrial Light & Magic >> London >> 020 3751 9150 &g

Re: Rack awareness support for Mesos

2016-06-15 Thread james
oris Van Remoortere; vinodk...@apache.org <mailto:vinodk...@apache.org> <mailto:vinodk...@apache.org <mailto:vinodk...@apache.org>> <mailto:vinodk...@apache.org <mailto:vinodk...@apache.org> <mailto:vinodk...@apache.org

Re: Rack awareness support for Mesos

2016-06-15 Thread Joris Van Remoortere
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/MESOS-3059 >> >> -- >> >> Aaron Carey >> Production Engineer - Cloud Pipeline >> Industrial Light & Magic >> London >> 020

Re: Rack awareness support for Mesos

2016-06-14 Thread james
@apache.org <mailto:vinodk...@apache.org> <mailto:vinodk...@apache.org <mailto:vinodk...@apache.org>> Subject: Re: Rack awareness support for Mesos Hi everyone Let me summarize the discussion about Rack awareness in the

Re: Rack awareness support for Mesos

2016-06-14 Thread Du, Fan
ser@mesos.apache.org>; d...@mesos.apache.org <mailto:d...@mesos.apache.org> Cc: Joris Van Remoortere; vinodk...@apache.org <mailto:vinodk...@apache.org> Subject: Re: Rack awareness support for Mesos Hi everyone Let me summarize the discussion about Rack

Re: Rack awareness support for Mesos

2016-06-14 Thread Joris Van Remoortere
gt;> ________________ >> From: Du, Fan [fan...@intel.com <mailto:fan...@intel.com>] >> Sent: 14 June 2016 07:24 >> To: user@mesos.apache.org <mailto:user@mesos.apache.org>; >> d...@mesos.apache.org <mailto:d...@mesos.apac

Re: Rack awareness support for Mesos

2016-06-14 Thread Du, Fan
user@mesos.apache.org <mailto:user@mesos.apache.org>; d...@mesos.apache.org <mailto:d...@mesos.apache.org> Cc: Joris Van Remoortere; vinodk...@apache.org <mailto:vinodk...@apache.org> Subject: Re: Rack awareness support for Mesos Hi everyone Let me summarize

Re: Rack awareness support for Mesos

2016-06-14 Thread Joris Van Remoortere
uction Engineer - Cloud Pipeline > Industrial Light & Magic > London > 020 3751 9150 > > > From: Du, Fan [fan...@intel.com] > Sent: 14 June 2016 07:24 > To: user@mesos.apache.org; d...@mesos.apache.org > Cc: Joris Van Remoortere;

RE: Rack awareness support for Mesos

2016-06-14 Thread Aaron Carey
7:24 To: user@mesos.apache.org; d...@mesos.apache.org Cc: Joris Van Remoortere; vinodk...@apache.org Subject: Re: Rack awareness support for Mesos Hi everyone Let me summarize the discussion about Rack awareness in the community so far. First thanks for all the comments, advices or challenges! :)

Re: Rack awareness support for Mesos

2016-06-13 Thread Du, Fan
Hi everyone Let me summarize the discussion about Rack awareness in the community so far. First thanks for all the comments, advices or challenges! :) #1. Stick with attributes for rack awareness For compatibility with existing framework, I tend to be ok with using attributes to convey the r

Re: Rack awareness support for Mesos

2016-06-08 Thread Du, Fan
On 2016/6/8 0:58, james wrote: Do I have access to the jira system by default joining this list, or do I have to request permission somewhere? (sorry jira is new to me so recommendations on jira, per mesos, in a document, would be keen.) You need a JIRA account, sign up one here: https://iss

Re: Rack awareness support for Mesos

2016-06-07 Thread Jeff Schroeder
On Tuesday, June 7, 2016, Du, Fan wrote: > > > On 2016/6/6 23:48, Jörg Schad wrote: > >> Hi, >> thanks for your idea and design doc! >> Just a few thoughts: >> a) The scheduling part would be implemented in a framework scheduler and >> not the Mesos Core, or? >> > > I'm not sure which level of sc

Re: Rack awareness support for Mesos

2016-06-07 Thread Joris Van Remoortere
+dev. @Fan, I responded on the JIRA with some next steps. Thanks for bringing this up! — *Joris Van Remoortere* Mesosphere On Tue, Jun 7, 2016 at 12:58 PM, james wrote: > On 06/07/2016 09:57 AM, Du, Fan wrote: > >> >> >> On 2016/6/6 21:27, james wrote: >> >>> Hello, >>> >>> >>> @Stephen::I gue

Re: Rack awareness support for Mesos

2016-06-07 Thread james
On 06/07/2016 09:57 AM, Du, Fan wrote: On 2016/6/6 21:27, james wrote: Hello, @Stephen::I guess Stephen is bringing up the 'security' aspect of who get's access to the information, particularly cluster/cloud devops, customers or interlopers? ACLs should play in this part to address sec

RE: Rack awareness support for Mesos

2016-06-07 Thread Aaron Carey
: Du, Fan [fan...@intel.com] Sent: 07 June 2016 16:16 To: Jörg Schad; user@mesos.apache.org Subject: Re: Rack awareness support for Mesos On 2016/6/6 23:48, Jörg Schad wrote: > Hi, > thanks for your idea and design doc! > Just a few thoughts: > a) The scheduling part would be implemente

Re: Rack awareness support for Mesos

2016-06-07 Thread Du, Fan
On 2016/6/6 23:48, Jörg Schad wrote: Hi, thanks for your idea and design doc! Just a few thoughts: a) The scheduling part would be implemented in a framework scheduler and not the Mesos Core, or? I'm not sure which level of scheduling part do you indicate, For the "Future" section of proposal

Re: Rack awareness support for Mesos

2016-06-07 Thread Du, Fan
On 2016/6/6 21:27, james wrote: Hello, @Stephen::I guess Stephen is bringing up the 'security' aspect of who get's access to the information, particularly cluster/cloud devops, customers or interlopers? ACLs should play in this part to address security concern. @Fan:: As a consultant

Re: Rack awareness support for Mesos

2016-06-06 Thread Charles Allen
There are a lot of things in Mesos which require a-priori communication between an agent and a framework in order to properly set resource usage expectations (example: what does 1 cpu mean?). I'm not seeing how having customizations in core mesos per "way of looking at resources" is scalable and fu

Re: Rack awareness support for Mesos

2016-06-06 Thread Jörg Schad
Hi, thanks for your idea and design doc! Just a few thoughts: a) The scheduling part would be implemented in a framework scheduler and not the Mesos Core, or? b) As mentioned by James, this needs to be very flexible (and not necessarily based on network structure), afaik people are using labels on

Re: Rack awareness support for Mesos

2016-06-06 Thread james
Hello, @Stephen::I guess Stephen is bringing up the 'security' aspect of who get's access to the information, particularly cluster/cloud devops, customers or interlopers? @Fan:: As a consultant, most of my customers either have or are planning hybrid installations, where some codes ru

Re: Rack awareness support for Mesos

2016-06-06 Thread Stephen Gran
Hi, This looks potentially interesting. How does it work in a public cloud deployment scenario? I assume you would just have to disable this feature, or not enable it? Cheers, On 06/06/16 10:17, Du, Fan wrote: > Hi, Mesos folks > > I’ve been thinking about Mesos rack awareness support for a