Re: Tomcat and JRE redistribution

2007-07-19 Thread Mark H. Wood
On Wed, Jul 18, 2007 at 01:06:04PM -0400, broken connection wrote: At the end, the only thing that should matter to TOMCAT or ANT is that they should be able to find the classes in the JREso I don't understand, why you guys don't recommend this Because if everybody did it that way,

Re: Tomcat and JRE redistribution

2007-07-19 Thread broken connection
Are you sure that you even have a problem? Yes, certainly i do ... :( Thanks a lot Mark...that was some excellent stuff there...but see there's some difference between making a installer for a production level software or making one for demo purpose... As I told before,its a simple web app

Re: Tomcat and JRE redistribution

2007-07-19 Thread Christopher Schultz
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Mark, Mark H. Wood wrote: Wearing my sysadmin. hat: I would say that it is perfectly okay for your install package to *use* its own copy of JRE to run its own copy of Ant to install your product. It is NOT OKAY to leave these behind like muddy

Re: Tomcat and JRE redistribution

2007-07-19 Thread Christopher Schultz
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Broken, broken connection wrote: As I told before,its a simple web app for the BA's just for some proof of concept and if I try to get too techie. If this is a POC, why not just walk over to their computers and install the JRE and Tomcat manually,

Tomcat and JRE redistribution

2007-07-18 Thread broken connection
Hi Friends, I am trying to make an installer for a small Tomcat web application and so i am planning to include Tomcat in the cd itself. I have read the license agreement for both Tomcat and JRE and I guess I can do that as long as I distribute the appropriate license files.I have two doubts:

Re: Tomcat and JRE redistribution

2007-07-18 Thread Christopher Schultz
Broken, broken connection wrote: I have read the license agreement for both Tomcat and JRE and I guess I can do that as long as I distribute the appropriate license files. You might want to re-read the JRE license agreement. It used to be that you needed to force your users to separately

Re: Tomcat and JRE redistribution

2007-07-18 Thread broken connection
Thanks Chris, But if I make the users run the JRE installer and install it anywhere they want to.then how would the Tomcat silent install locate the JRE. The whole purpose of why I was suggesting to include JRE inside Tomcat was to resolve this path issue to JRE. The end-users of the app

Re: Tomcat and JRE redistribution

2007-07-18 Thread Steve Ochani
Thanks Chris, But if I make the users run the JRE installer and install it anywhere they want to.then how would the Tomcat silent install locate the JRE. I don't know the details about the installer you are making but if you can access the registry then have the installer look in this

Re: Tomcat and JRE redistribution

2007-07-18 Thread broken connection
Thanks Steve, My installer is totally ant-based and it does not have the capability to search the registry and locate the entries...instead if you could tell me which location in the Tomcat points to this JRE, I could over-write that value instead...i think that would be much easier. If I am not

RE: Tomcat and JRE redistribution

2007-07-18 Thread Caldarale, Charles R
From: broken connection [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: Tomcat and JRE redistribution If I am not wrong, it use to be in catalina.bat but Tomcat6 does not ships that file anymore... The .bat files are in the .zip download, not the .exe. - Chuck THIS COMMUNICATION MAY CONTAIN

Re: Tomcat and JRE redistribution

2007-07-18 Thread Christopher Schultz
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Broken, broken connection wrote: My installer is totally ant-based Heh. How are you running ant if you don't know where the JRE is located? I'm guessing that the JRE is already on the PATH so you might be good-to-go already. and it does not have

RE: Tomcat and JRE redistribution

2007-07-18 Thread Caldarale, Charles R
From: broken connection [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: Tomcat and JRE redistribution At the end, the only thing that should matter to TOMCAT or ANT is that they should be able to find the classes in the JREso I don't understand, why you guys don't recommend this You're

Re: Tomcat and JRE redistribution

2007-07-18 Thread Christopher Schultz
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Broken, broken connection wrote: At the end, the only thing that should matter to TOMCAT or ANT is that they should be able to find the classes in the JRE... Tomcat and Ant don't need to be able to fine JRE classes. When the JRE starts up, it will