Re: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

2012-08-23 Thread Jeff Berkowitz
I don't know, but there was a Fredrick's of Hollywood ad on the page. Coincidence? I think not. ;-) Jeff On Thu, Aug 23, 2012 at 7:26 AM, OrionWorks - Steven V Johnson < svj.orionwo...@gmail.com> wrote: > from Jed: > > ... > > > ... > ... > > > http://www.modellismo.net/forum/statico-kits-info-e-

Re: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

2012-08-23 Thread James Bowery
On Thu, Aug 23, 2012 at 6:10 PM, Abd ul-Rahman Lomax wrote: > It would be like buying a thousand expensive integrated circuits without > having independent evaluation of them, and without working with a > development kit with one of them. > No its not. Its like doing a systems test rather than

RE: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

2012-08-23 Thread OrionWorks - Steven Vincent Johnson
>From Abd, >> > And we need reporters who will look more carefully. Any volunteers? > >>I volunteer you. > Great. Thanks. I accept, any idea about funding? I would suggest you contact Mr. Krivit and ask him how he funds his NET reporting. Unfortunately, I don't think Mr. Krivit likes you. Rega

Re: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

2012-08-23 Thread Andre Blum
On 08/23/2012 07:05 PM, Abd ul-Rahman Lomax wrote: At 09:39 AM 8/23/2012, Andre Blum wrote: Rossi's attempt to scale up did not fail, too. We don't know that. Generally, in his post, Mr. Blum made a number of statements, as if they were fact, that are not from independent sources. [etc, etc.

Re: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

2012-08-23 Thread James Bowery
On Thu, Aug 23, 2012 at 6:10 PM, Abd ul-Rahman Lomax wrote: > Actually, I don't think it's useful to ridicule Rossi, but pointing out > how his business strategy, if he actually has functioning E-Cats in the 10 > KW range or so, is preposterous, isn't ridiculing him. It's pointing to the > obviou

Re: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

2012-08-23 Thread Abd ul-Rahman Lomax
At 09:52 AM 8/23/2012, James Bowery wrote: While the Capronismo is humorous (did they envision ground effect?) the comparison really isn't fair. Rossi's 1MW heat plant is low complexity and makes a lot of sense from the standpoint of industrial learning curve: Base it on a standard unit of r

Re: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

2012-08-23 Thread Abd ul-Rahman Lomax
At 09:39 AM 8/23/2012, Andre Blum wrote: Rossi's attempt to scale up did not fail, too. We don't know that. Generally, in his post, Mr. Blum made a number of statements, as if they were fact, that are not from independent sources. Like the claim that the 1 MW E-cat is "industrially certified

Re: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

2012-08-23 Thread Abd ul-Rahman Lomax
At 01:48 PM 8/23/2012, Terry Blanton wrote: On Thu, Aug 23, 2012 at 10:44 AM, Jones Beene wrote: > Ha! … LOL we have talked about this marvel before ­ and as being the perfect > “Rossi metaphor”. Looks reliable to me: 3 engines, 9 wings, 27 windows, seating 81, someone had a trinity fetish

Re: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

2012-08-23 Thread Abd ul-Rahman Lomax
At 01:30 PM 8/23/2012, OrionWorks - Steven V Johnson wrote: After a very thorough analysis of the status of CF reporting was summed up by Abd, he concludes with: > And we need reporters who will look more carefully. Any volunteers? I volunteer you. Great. Thanks. I accept, any idea about fund

Re: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

2012-08-23 Thread Jed Rothwell
Terry Blanton wrote: > Looks reliable to me: > > 3 engines, 9 wings, 27 windows, seating 81, > > someone had a trinity fetish > I missed that! That's hysterical. - Jed

Re: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

2012-08-23 Thread Terry Blanton
On Thu, Aug 23, 2012 at 10:44 AM, Jones Beene wrote: > Ha! … LOL we have talked about this marvel before – and as being the perfect > “Rossi metaphor”. Looks reliable to me: 3 engines, 9 wings, 27 windows, seating 81, someone had a trinity fetish T

Re: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

2012-08-23 Thread OrionWorks - Steven V Johnson
After a very thorough analysis of the status of CF reporting was summed up by Abd, he concludes with: > And we need reporters who will look more carefully. Any volunteers? I volunteer you. Regards Steven Vincent Johnson www.OrionWorks.com www.zazzle.com/orionworks

Re: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

2012-08-23 Thread Abd ul-Rahman Lomax
At 09:08 AM 8/23/2012, Jed Rothwell wrote: Craig Brown wrote: First of all, I would be ecstatic if Rossi's eCat was proven, but the constant regurgitative reportage of "Rossi Says this, Rossi says that" being pumped out by certain reporters has me reaching for the vomit bag on an almost daily

Re: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

2012-08-23 Thread James Bowery
While the Capronismo is humorous (did they envision ground effect?) the comparison really isn't fair. Rossi's 1MW heat plant is low complexity and makes a lot of sense from the standpoint of industrial learning curve: Base it on a standard unit of replication with a minimal connecting infrastruct

RE: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

2012-08-23 Thread Jones Beene
From: Jed Rothwell * The megawatt reactor looks impressive to such people as well. To me, it looks like a gigantic white elephant. It is a distraction, and an absurd waste of time and effort… but I would no more crank up the whole thing than I would try to fly the Caproni Ca-60 Transaereo

Re: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

2012-08-23 Thread Andre Blum
The difference between Celani's 21 W and Rossi's 16 kW is unimportant, in my opinion. They are equally close to commercialization. The 16 kW looks more impressive to people who do not understand the technical issues. The megawatt reactor looks impressive to such people as well. To me, it look

Re: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

2012-08-23 Thread OrionWorks - Steven V Johnson
from Jed: ... > The difference between Celani's 21 W and Rossi's 16 kW is unimportant, in my > opinion. They are equally close to commercialization. The 16 kW looks more > impressive to people who do not understand the technical issues. The > megawatt reactor looks impressive to such people as we

Re: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

2012-08-23 Thread Jed Rothwell
Craig Brown wrote: First of all, I would be ecstatic if Rossi's eCat was proven, but the constant regurgitative reportage of "Rossi Says this, Rossi says that" being pumped out by certain reporters has me reaching for the vomit bag on an almost daily basis. Yup, it is silly. But why get upse

Re: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

2012-08-22 Thread James Bowery
Again, I say, WHOOSH OK, so maybe I placed the fulcrum a bit to far and the arm broke. On Wed, Aug 22, 2012 at 6:59 PM, Jed Rothwell wrote: > James Bowery wrote: > > When the cold fusion research community finally comes up with devices >> meeting your criteria, the world will be grateful t

RE: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

2012-08-22 Thread Craig Brown
that moment there's a lovely second hand bridge in New York that I am willing to sell for a good price. Original Message -------- Subject: Re: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed From: "Puppy Dog" <d...@inbox.lv> Date: Thu, August 23, 2012 12:

Re: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

2012-08-22 Thread Puppy Dog
Axil,Be nice to Jed. He is a talking head, not a reporter. He also is an amateur librarian. This may help educate the Vortex crew a little: We must not have a slop of divergent definitions, right?Definition: A reporter is someone who is employed to investigate and report news stories, either for a

RE: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

2012-08-22 Thread OrionWorks - Steven Vincent Johnson
Jed sed: Regarding the enigma known as Rossi. > ...I learned a long time ago not to ignore intuition, but not to fully trust it either. ...and the wisdom to know the difference. Good komment, Jed. Regards, Steven Vincent Johnson www.OrionWorks.com www.zazzle.com/orionworks

Re: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

2012-08-22 Thread Jed Rothwell
Axil Axil wrote: > Unlike many journalists practicing today who believes in a desk job or > "research" on a computer screen, an old school journalist wants to have > first hand impressions, gathered from talking with real people and from > going on location. > That is true. Although in the case

Re: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

2012-08-22 Thread Axil Axil
The spirit of my post was to emphasize the importance of “old school journalism” as an ideal of what journalism should be. Unlike many journalists practicing today who believes in a desk job or "research" on a computer screen, an old school journalist wants to have first hand impressions, gathered

Re: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

2012-08-22 Thread Jed Rothwell
Axil Axil wrote: > Meet Rossi; look him in the eye; gage the man, is he a man we can trust? > NO!!! No he is not. If he said it was raining I would go outside to see for myself. I compiled a whole list of contradictory claims that made, that are logically or physically mutually exclusive. If any

Re: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

2012-08-22 Thread Jed Rothwell
James Bowery wrote: When the cold fusion research community finally comes up with devices > meeting your criteria, the world will be grateful to you Mr. Gibbs. > Because of your strong stand for serious scientific proof, in the end, > science will win because of your steadfastness. Oh give me

Re: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

2012-08-22 Thread Axil Axil
Instead of just passing on PESN Stories, try to draw some journalism lessens from its blogger. Go to where the first hand information is percolating and can be had by just asking the right question. In September, Rossi will hold a E-Cat user conference; go there; find out who is buying his reactor

Re: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

2012-08-22 Thread James Bowery
WHOOSH On Wed, Aug 22, 2012 at 6:19 PM, Randy Wuller wrote: > Actually, ultimately science is a very small part of this story if LENR > verifies. > > Sent from my iPhone > > On Aug 22, 2012, at 6:04 PM, James Bowery wrote: > > When the cold fusion research community finally comes up with device

Re: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

2012-08-22 Thread Randy Wuller
Actually, ultimately science is a very small part of this story if LENR verifies. Sent from my iPhone On Aug 22, 2012, at 6:04 PM, James Bowery wrote: > When the cold fusion research community finally comes up with devices meeting > your criteria, the world will be grateful to you Mr. Gibbs.

Re: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

2012-08-22 Thread James Bowery
When the cold fusion research community finally comes up with devices meeting your criteria, the world will be grateful to you Mr. Gibbs. Because of your strong stand for serious scientific proof, in the end, science will win because of your steadfastness. On Wed, Aug 22, 2012 at 2:23 PM, Mark G

Re: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

2012-08-22 Thread Terry Blanton
One of the most convincing things lately is Mike McKubre's presentation in 8 parts: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EtweR_qGHEc It's the old Pd/D experiments; but, it is compelling. T

Re: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

2012-08-22 Thread Jed Rothwell
Mark Gibbs wrote: > > Also, your expectation that "the media" should "have either, confirmed a > fraud OR confirmed something newsworthy" is equally nonsensical. > I would say you should only investigate something if you agree it is newsworthy and you intend to publish something about it. There

Re: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

2012-08-22 Thread David Roberson
spreading false hopes and I believe that you understand that. Dave -Original Message- From: Jojo Jaro To: vortex-l Sent: Wed, Aug 22, 2012 5:56 pm Subject: Re: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed Mark, Thanks for the story. It is appreciated. On the other hand

Re: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

2012-08-22 Thread Kelley Trezise
ut you really come across as having not an ounce of orginality. Zedshort - Original Message - From: Mark Gibbs To: vortex-l@eskimo.com Sent: Wednesday, August 22, 2012 1:49 PM Subject: Re: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed "it makes me wonder why the media...

Re: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

2012-08-22 Thread Jojo Jaro
From: Mark Gibbs To: vortex-l@eskimo.com Sent: Thursday, August 23, 2012 4:49 AM Subject: Re: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed "it makes me wonder why the media in this case seems so inept." ... you wonder because you have no idea what you'r

RE: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

2012-08-22 Thread Jones Beene
You should not be surprised that the public expects a very high level of journalistic insight and fairness from the most prestigious magazines. It's your job. One of the more respectable claimants in the field, generally ignored, is only a couple of hours drive from NYC. http://www.blacklig

Re: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

2012-08-22 Thread Randy wuller
one neither and it makes me wonder why the media in this case seems so inept. Ransom - Original Message - From: Mark Gibbs To: vortex-l@eskimo.com ; E-Cat newsletter ; Sterling Allan ; Hank Mills Sent: Wednesday, August 22, 2012 2:23 PM Subject: [Vo]:Re: Existence of

Re: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

2012-08-22 Thread Mark Gibbs
edia in this case seems so inept. > > Ransom > > > > - Original Message - > *From:* Mark Gibbs > *To:* vortex-l@eskimo.com ; E-Cat newsletter ; > Sterling > Allan ; Hank Mills > *Sent:* Wednesday, August 22, 2012 2:23 PM > *Subject:* [Vo]:Re: Existence

Re: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

2012-08-22 Thread Randy wuller
onder why the media in this case seems so inept. Ransom - Original Message - From: Mark Gibbs To: vortex-l@eskimo.com ; E-Cat newsletter ; Sterling Allan ; Hank Mills Sent: Wednesday, August 22, 2012 2:23 PM Subject: [Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

[Vo]:Re: Existence of 1,200C E-Cat Test Report Confirmed

2012-08-22 Thread Mark Gibbs
In the piece by Hank Mills it claims "PESN has obtained satisfactory confirmation that a report covering the test does indeed exist." ... the article then goes on to completely avoid any details as to what the "satisfactory confirmation" might be or who might consider it satisfactory. The piece co