Re: [WISPA] What is WISPA? was Promotion of services on-list

2007-05-20 Thread Marlon K. Schafer
- Original Message - From: Chadd Thompson [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: WISPA General List wireless@wispa.org Sent: Friday, May 18, 2007 8:07 PM Subject: RE: [WISPA] What is WISPA? was Promotion of services on-list Butch, Thanks for taking the time to reply with a well thought out

RE: [WISPA] What is WISPA? was Promotion of services on-list

2007-05-18 Thread Chadd Thompson
Please don't take this in a negative tone because it is not meant to be, I know it is hard to judge tone through an email. It astounds me that you would make the statement above but not understand why it is your obligation to pay the $25 a month it costs to pay your part. If you cannot pay $25

RE: [WISPA] What is WISPA? was Promotion of services on-list

2007-05-18 Thread Butch Evans
On Fri, 18 May 2007, Chadd Thompson wrote: I am sorry but as I mentioned above I can not see from the outside what WISPA is doing or has going on. Maybe I am not paying close enough attention, I don't know. I'll just mention TWO examples. Direct $ for $ examples, too. You may not be using

RE: [WISPA] What is WISPA? was Promotion of services on-list

2007-05-18 Thread Cliff Leboeuf
Butch, I have also seen more valuable information shared amongst paid members such as contracts for towers, roof rights and end-user agreements. Each of these documents could be well-worth the annual fee individually. You also get voting rights which help you steer WISPA's direction.

RE: [WISPA] What is WISPA? was Promotion of services on-list

2007-05-18 Thread Robert Norris
Well as a new member to Wispa I have already got back half my dues by using Kris Twomey, and I am gonna look at Frank Muto's product. Robert -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Butch Evans Sent: Friday, May 18, 2007 10:19 AM To: WISPA General

Re: [WISPA] What is WISPA? was Promotion of services on-list

2007-05-18 Thread Mark Nash
Same here with Kris Twomey, and I AM now using Frank Muto's Postini product... He gives a good discount to WISPA members, gave a 30-day trial, and spent alot of time on the phone with me in training. Now it's like Spam? What spam? from my customers that I have turned it on for. Mark Nash

RE: [WISPA] What is WISPA? was Promotion of services on-list

2007-05-18 Thread Chadd Thompson
Butch, Thanks for taking the time to reply with a well thought out professional response to my questions. Those are just 2 examples, both of which were posted right here on this free list. Sorry if what I was asking didn't come across the correct way. I am not worried about the

Re: [WISPA] What is WISPA? was Promotion of services on-list

2007-05-18 Thread George Rogato
Chadd Thompson wrote: Does WISPA seek input from members when dealing with issues like this? Or is everything decided by a group of officers? In other words how does the ORG run on a day to day basis, how are decisions made, how does it decide what battles to fight, how does it determine what

RE: [WISPA] What is WISPA? was Promotion of services on-list

2007-05-18 Thread Butch Evans
On Fri, 18 May 2007, Chadd Thompson wrote: Sorry if what I was asking didn't come across the correct way. I am not worried about the monetary value of what membership gives, that information has been well advertised. There seems to be great support from vendors and such to WISPA members. In

[WISPA] What is WISPA? was Promotion of services on-list

2007-05-17 Thread Peter R.
(In response to Lonnie and Mac) 1) It takes money for an organization to do things. Sometimes vendors put up that money so that their customer base thrives. (Some times they do not). 2) It's always hard to get dues-paying members, especially when the most value is the listserv. (Again, it

Re: [WISPA] What is WISPA? was Promotion of services on-list

2007-05-17 Thread Lonnie Nunweiler
I'm going out on a limb and will voice some things that have been suppressed. I get your point that you think I am a freeloader and do not contribute. My problem for not joining is not a money one, but rather one of principle. I did get involved early on and saw that there was still an old

RE: [WISPA] What is WISPA? was Promotion of services on-list

2007-05-17 Thread Jeff Broadwick
Lonnie, I've been quiet through this whole thing, but I have to speak up here. CALEA is a reality here, and I believe that something like it will soon be a reality in Canada. Shouting at the Capitol building from outside the fence may feel good, but it gets nothing accomplished. The FACT is

Re: [WISPA] What is WISPA? was Promotion of services on-list

2007-05-17 Thread Lonnie Nunweiler
I am not saying that CALEA is not real and I actually agree that is required, BUT, did the group have to agree with the rushed timing and especially agree to meet a standard that was not even defined? They could have argued for some prior consultation to make sure the requirements were not a

Re: [WISPA] What is WISPA? was Promotion of services on-list

2007-05-17 Thread George Rogato
Lonnie Nunweiler wrote: My suspicion is you'll get the support if you represent what people want. People vote with their feet and pocketbooks. I've seen a lot of good people leave. I've seen a lot of good people forced out because the GOB's could not stand them. And I've seen a lot of good

Re: [WISPA] What is WISPA? was Promotion of services on-list

2007-05-17 Thread Sam Tetherow
Inline... Matt Liotta wrote: Lonnie Nunweiler wrote: I am not saying that CALEA is not real and I actually agree that is required, BUT, did the group have to agree with the rushed timing and especially agree to meet a standard that was not even defined? Specifically, CALEA does not require

Re: [WISPA] What is WISPA? was Promotion of services on-list

2007-05-17 Thread Lonnie Nunweiler
Agreed. Lonnie On 5/17/07, Matt Liotta [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Lonnie Nunweiler wrote: I am not saying that CALEA is not real and I actually agree that is required, BUT, did the group have to agree with the rushed timing and especially agree to meet a standard that was not even defined?

Re: [WISPA] What is WISPA? was Promotion of services on-list

2007-05-17 Thread Peter R.
You are comparing apples to grapes. The telcos have an embedded base and have billions of dollars to force their issues. FYI, the original order was in August 2005. So people actually had over 1 year to get ready. (timeline here: http://www.lasarletter.net/drupal/node/9) Lonnie Nunweiler

Re: [WISPA] What is WISPA? was Promotion of services on-list

2007-05-17 Thread John Scrivner
Lonnie Nunweiler wrote: I'm going out on a limb and will voice some things that have been suppressed. I get your point that you think I am a freeloader and do not contribute. My problem for not joining is not a money one, but rather one of principle. I did get involved early on and saw

Re: [WISPA] What is WISPA? was Promotion of services on-list

2007-05-17 Thread Sam Tetherow
Thanks for the link Peter, that answers my earlier comment to Matt concerning having 2 years to voice opinion. Sam Tetherow Sandhills Wireless Peter R. wrote: You are comparing apples to grapes. The telcos have an embedded base and have billions of dollars to force their issues. FYI,

RE: [WISPA] What is WISPA? was Promotion of services on-list

2007-05-17 Thread Jeff Broadwick
Well, that should bring JohnnyO out of the woodwork! :-) -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Lonnie Nunweiler Sent: Thursday, May 17, 2007 4:40 PM To: WISPA General List Subject: Re: [WISPA] What is WISPA? was Promotion of services on-list

Re: [WISPA] What is WISPA? was Promotion of services on-list

2007-05-17 Thread Matt Liotta
Sam Tetherow wrote: I don't want to drag this topic up again, BUT ;) Two years ago, did this apply to ISPs or just VOIP providers? I don't remember anyone on the lists talking about CALEA being for anything other than VOICE in various forms, but maybe my memory is selective, wouldn't be the

Re: [WISPA] What is WISPA? was Promotion of services on-list

2007-05-17 Thread Matt Liotta
Sam Tetherow wrote: Thanks for the link Peter, that answers my earlier comment to Matt concerning having 2 years to voice opinion. I didn't mean we had 2 years. What I meant was that it was in 2005 (almost 2 years ago) that the CALEA requirement was issued. -Matt -- WISPA Wireless List:

Re: [WISPA] What is WISPA? was Promotion of services on-list

2007-05-17 Thread Lonnie Nunweiler
People were allowed a LOT of leeway in taking shots at Mark. It got very personal, very quickly and I have no idea if people were reprimanded or not. He was definitely excluded by attacks from a select few who did not want any differing views. Why does everything have to hit the fight or

Re: [WISPA] What is WISPA? was Promotion of services on-list

2007-05-17 Thread George Rogato
Thanks Lonnie My only goal for WISPA is to unite us all, divided we fail. Even if I'm off base, I'm just one opinion. George Lonnie Nunweiler wrote: You have shown your good nature many, many times George. Thanks for the hard work and peace making. Are you sure you're not Canadian?

Re: [WISPA] What is WISPA? was Promotion of services on-list

2007-05-17 Thread Marlon K. Schafer (509) 982-2181
- Original Message - From: Lonnie Nunweiler [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: WISPA General List wireless@wispa.org Sent: Thursday, May 17, 2007 12:56 PM Subject: Re: [WISPA] What is WISPA? was Promotion of services on-list I am not saying that CALEA is not real and I actually agree that is

Re: [WISPA] What is WISPA? was Promotion of services on-list

2007-05-17 Thread Peter R.
Okay. So we have two parties here. Those that are loud and boisterous. And the lurkers and people who think WISPA has veered the wrong way. Well, elections are June 15. Your candidates are here: http://nominations.wispa.org/ Writing about what they see as the future. Read it - and ask them

Re: [WISPA] What is WISPA? was Promotion of services on-list

2007-05-17 Thread Michael Erskine
Lonnie Nunweiler wrote: You have shown your good nature many, many times George. Thanks for the hard work and peace making. He is a good man. Are you sure you're not Canadian? Peace making is not something peculiar to Canadians. In fact that is what American's do best. We make peace.

RE: [WISPA] What is WISPA? was Promotion of services on-list

2007-05-17 Thread Chadd Thompson
I will say this though - if you aren't a member, how do you have a say in what the Org does? Because the org is speaking on the behalf of all WISPS not just WISPA members. If the org is speaking on the behalf of all WISPS then all WISPS should be able to have some input on what is being taken

Re: [WISPA] What is WISPA? was Promotion of services on-list

2007-05-17 Thread John Scrivner
Chadd Thompson wrote: I will say this though - if you aren't a member, how do you have a say in what the Org does? Because the org is speaking on the behalf of all WISPS not just WISPA members. If the org is speaking on the behalf of all WISPS then all WISPS should be able to have some