> I'm merged with some recent changes and prepared a final
> draft of the webrevs for the bison and gm4 changes before
> I submit the WebRTI and do my putbacks:
> http://cr.grommit.com/~dermot/

webrev-bison-03
===============

One comment concerning "webrev" or perhaps your wx active file.  It
looks like you have the CR listed as "6521207," (note the trailing
comma) rather than "6521207".

usr/src/cmd/bison/install-sfw
usr/src/cmd/bison/install-bison

        The changes between these two files are fine but I want to
        confirm that you did a "workspace filemv" (or "sccsmv") between
        install-sfw to install-bison.  It sort of looks like you did
        this (the SCCS id incremented) but the file name of
        install-bison looks like you froze the ident string before
        doing the move.

        Also, "install-bison" has a bug of other CRs listed in the
        webrev.  It's unclear to me why you have them there (they
        definitely should not be there) although again perhaps this is
        confusion on the part of webrev and the rename taking place.

usr/src/pkgdefs/SUNW0sfw/prototype_com

        It looks like there are a few duplicate entries

        Lines 216-219 - Duplicates for "da", "de", "es" and "et".

        Line 286 - Duplicate for "fr".

        Lines 380-382 - Duplicates for "hr", "id" and "it".

        Line 416 - Duplicate for "ja".

        Lines 441-443 - Duplicates for "nl", "pt_BR" and "ru".

        Lines 508-509 - Duplicates for "sv" and "tr".

usr/src/pkgdefs/SUNWbison/prototype_com

        Could you please sort the list of entries based on file name
        (third field?)

usr/src/pkgdefs/SUNWbisonS/prototype_com

        Could you please sort the list of entries based on file name
        (third field?)

usr/src/pkgdefs/SUNWsfinf/prototype_com

        As these are in blocks based by component, could you just sort
        that initial block (since "sfw" comes before "share".)

webrev-gm4-05
=============

usr/src/cmd/gm4/install-sfw
usr/src/cmd/gm4/install-gm4

        Same comment as above concerning bison's install-* files.

        And same comment concerning extraneous CRs listed for
        "install-gm4".

usr/src/pkgdefs/SUNWgm4S/prototype_com

        Could you please sort the list of entries based on file name
        (third field?)

usr/src/pkgdefs/SUNWsfinf/prototype_com

        As these are in blocks based by component, could you just sort
        that initial block (since "sfw" comes before "share".)

One final meta-comment - from the /usr/gnu case, conflicting commands
like GNU m4 are supposed to have the "standard" command's man page
augmented to reflect the language in section 2.7 of the umbrella case.
Please be sure to file a CR under solaris/manpage/section1 for this to
be done for m4(1).

dsc

Reply via email to