----- Original Message -----
From: Marshall Dudley <[email protected]>

Hope you don't mind me bouncing my views around like this Marshall.

> Ivan Anderson wrote:
>
> > CS kills pathogens by inhibiting the enzyme required for oxygen
> > metabolism, and by binding with the electron rich SH groups of the
> > cell wall and from there binding with the DNA (or is it RNA)
disabling
> > the reproduction of the cell.
>
> That is what the Silver Institute reports.  However there is more to
it than
> that.  If this were the only way that it kills pathogens then it
would not
> have any effect for anaerobic bacteria which do not metabolise
oxygen.
> There is more to it than that.  It is apparent that it kills by more
> mechanisms than just that one, but I have yet to have heard anything
that
> sounds reasonable for the other mechanisms except for the catalytic
> oxidation of anerobic pathogens.

The bonding to the cell wall and disrupting the membrain, the bonding
to DNA, and the disabling of proteins, even the disabling of enzymes
may be found to be affective against anaerobic bacteria.
I don't deny that the catalytic oxidation effect of silver could be an
effective manner for the disabling of pathogens. For this effect to
occur the silver should be elemental, and requires the presence of
free oxygen or hydrogen peroxide or an oxidisable salt.

> I have no idea if it stops reproduction of the cell, since in every
> experiment we have done and had done, it kills the cell outright,
> immediately.  One thing that it does it it causes oxidation of the
pathogen,
> and when you oxidize proteins and amino acids, which is what elicits
an
> immune response, they break down into water, carbon dixoide and so
forth
> which do not elicit an immune response.

Well of course the petri dish is not the body. Silver ions certainly
do oxidise parts of the pathogen I agree, but transfering an electron
does not, I should think, cause the disintigration of such large,
complex organisms.
The immune response, as far as I can gather, is caused by the
attachment of an antibody to a marker site on the pathogen or foreign
material (antigen) and has nothing to do with oxidation. Signals are
sent which mobilises the macrophages and the 'complement system', an
army of protein dregrading enyzmes which will burst unwanted cells and
prepare cellular debris and foreign particles for elimination by the
macrophages.
The oxidation of cells if vigorous enough may degrade pathogens, and
make the job of the immune system easier, but these structures are
complex and large, and to degrade them into component parts such as is
required for elimination is beyond simple oxidation, in my
understanding, without affecting body tissue.

> > In these cases the cell is not destroyed is it, the cell remains
but
> > is deactivated.
>
> When a cell is oxidized then it is broken down into water, carbon
dioxide
> and so forth.
>
> > How can a particle many times smaller than the
> > pathogen destroy it.
>
> Well lets see.  If I light a match it will be destroyed by oxygen
which is
> MUCH smaller than the match.  Same thing goes for bacteria, when
they are
> oxidized they are destroyed.  Silver catalyzes the oxidation of the
> pathogen, it breaks down into smaller molecules which are more
stable.

Ha ha, touche! However the air contains about 20% oxygen, the
percentage of CS in the blood stream is extremely small, and one has
to strike a match to provide the energy for the reaction to procede.

> > To be destroyed the pathogen must be subjected to
> > the cleaving and disposal abilities of specialised enzymes
> > (macrophages) which are called into action by other components of
the
> > immune system(antigens), which identify, lock on to sites on the
> > pathogen in a fail safe, cascading method.
>
> Not true.  Cooking destroys pathogens.  That is why canning works.
Alcohol,
> most petrochemicals, heat, freezing sometimes, even dehydration can
all kill
> various pathogens.  Oxidation definitely kills pathogens, that is
why
> hydrogen peroxide works, and that is how silver works.

Well of course these examples are hardly relevent, and you don't
address the point. Killing a pathogen is not the same as destroying
it, a dead pathogen is still a pathogen, and must be dissasembled into
component parts to be destroyed. Silver does not do this.

> > The disabled pathogen may
> > release toxins during this process, and the action of enzymes in
the
> > immune system when dealing with large numbers of invaders is
generally
> > accompanied by an elevation in temp etc.,hence one feels lousy.
But as
> > far as I know it is the immune system which must identify and
dispose
> > of any foreign bodies, dead or alive.
> >
>
> The immune system destroys pathogens, usually by identifying markers
on the
> protein coat.  The kidneys and liver must dispose of these bodies
and/or
> toxins.  If it is too much for these organs to take care of, then
you will
> sweat out much of it.

See above.

snip

> > Silver ions disrupt membranes, disables proteins, inhibits enzymes
and
> > bonds with DNA. No doubt some organisms are killed outright but
surely
> > the inability to reproduce or metabolise is just another form of
> > death. How long does it take for the immune system to deal with
such
> > disabled cells?
>
> That is why CS is so nice.  It kills them outright in a matter of
minutes,
> whereas many antibiotics only prevent them from dividing, which may
require
> days to take care of them.

CS does not exhibit a complete kill in many cases. And it can take
days before the infection is eliminated.

> Marshall

Ivan.



--
The silver-list is a moderated forum for discussion of colloidal silver.

To join or quit silver-list or silver-digest send an e-mail message to: 
[email protected]  -or-  [email protected]
with the word subscribe or unsubscribe in the SUBJECT line.

To post, address your message to: [email protected]
Silver-list archive: http://escribe.com/health/thesilverlist/index.html
List maintainer: Mike Devour <[email protected]>