Hi, JJ! The Tyndall Effect is very handy to check up on the CS production process. But it can yield the two types of erroneous conclusions to which statistical inferences are prone.
The false-negative type: Silver is generated but TE is weak or absent. The false-positive type: Silver is not generated but a TE is present. Others have discussed the occurrence of the false-negative outcome. I have done some experimental batches using low currents running for several days, with bubbler mixing. As a control experiment, I shut off the current and allowed the bubbler to mix the water. After several days I noticed a Tyndall Effect, even though no CS was produced. The Tyndall Effect is a remarkable indicator and I would not do without it. It could be made into a quantitative procedure. Tolman and Vliet invented a "tyndallmeter" described by Strutt in 1918 (Strutt, Proc.Roy. Soc., London, 94A, 453, 1918.) But it is liable to false-negative and false-positive conclusions when used alone. A false-positive would be more serious than a false-negative, it seems to me. It's better to have an overly potent brew than a weak brew thought to be potent, but is not. If false-positive conclusions can be prevented by switching to another mixing method, I would do it. But I would continue using a qualitative Tyndall Effect as a handy check. Best regards, Matthew

