Hi, Jonathan and Ode! Thanks for your input.
The electrodes remained in the vessel throughout the run. This was done because it was a control experiment for weak- current electrolysis. On reflection, I can identify at contamination or extraneous factors, though there are reasons to discount each of them. 1) The process took place in an environment with large amounts of chalk dust generated every day, i.e. a school. But chalk dust is mostly large particulate. On the other hand, some portion of it is small enough to collect in people's lungs and make them cough. 2) The process took place in a place illuminated by fluorescent lights. And Svedberg discovered that UV will sinter metallic silver in water into CS. On the other hand, the glass tube in a fluorescent light blocks the large amounts of UV generated inside the tube. 3)The process took place in a place that received direct sunlight for much of the day. On the other hand, the panes of window glass block out most of the UV in sunlight. So it still remains a mystery to me. One thing I have learned, though, is a greater respect for the Tyndall Effect. I also wonder why it is not exploited more, especially as a quantitative metric. We have sophisticated electronics to measure pH, conductivity, total dissolved solids, temperature, time control and so forth. Tyndallometry was put on a quantitative basis in the age of Victorian and Edwardian science, long before the availability of electronics. The light sources back then we heliostats and carbon arc lamps, which are vastly inferior compared to the laser diode pointers affordable by all of us today. In fact, there are now green laser diode pointers on the market that might make it possible, when used with a red laser diode, for ordinary people to do Tyndall spectroscopy. Do-it-yourself Tyndallometry and Tyndall spectroscopy would give us a handle on particle size distribution and concentrations of particulate surface area. If I am not mistaken, these have important clinical implications. And after all, our primary goal is enhancement of health. Well, thank you for your comments. They have already given me a lot of food for thought. Best wishes, Matthew

