A quick answer to Arthur Carlson question,

>Ranger George seemed to think that the expectations that the Earth was
>smaller greatly inhibited the discovery of the actual size. The ancient
>Greeks had believed in a rather small value, and who could question their
>authority? It was also an important point of theology at that time that the

This is partially correct. It was Columbus who thought the Earth was only
2000 miles in diameter due to a poor measurement he made. The Greeks had
determined the diameter to better than 10% and maybe 1% depending on which
size of "stadia", their unit of measurement, you use. The Portuguese knew
the correct size and thats why they said bye bye to Columbus. Not because
they believed he would fall off the the edge of the Earth but because if
Columbus was going to sail West to China as he intended he would perish in
the storms of the huge ocean if he didn't run out of food & water first.
I'm afraid Columbus was lucky not smart that he bumped into the Americas.

Cheers,

Professor John P.G.Shepherd
Physics Department
University of Wisconsin-River Falls
410 S. 3rd. St.
River Falls,WI 54022

Phone (715)-425-3196, eve. (715)-425-6203
Fax (715)-425-0652

44.88 degrees N, 92.71 degrees W.

Reply via email to