Peter We just had this discussion, and as was pointed out during it, it -is- possible to import ODbL licensed data (assuming that all the other boxes wrt imports have been ticked) from a legal point of view with respect to the CTs.
This does not imply that it is desirable or not in a more general sense, just that the CTs do not prohibit it. Simon Am 24.05.2014 12:58, schrieb Peter Wendorff: > Hi Christian, > The BANO data is licensed under ODbl, but the database does not conform > to the Contributor terms, right? > > That's why importing or adding it to OSM is not possible IMHO. > > Adding it to (the osm installation of) nominatim on the other hand is a > bad idea, I think: > IMHO nominatim.openstreetmap.or should rely on OSM as a data source as > pure as possible. Adding different data sets might be useful to add > information not possible or out of scope of the osm database (like > importance factors using the wikipedia links), but BANO is a different > thing. > > If the BANO addresses are free and open enough for OSM, we should > encourage to work on bringing them to the OSM database itself (provided, > they are GOOD enough as well). How should anybody in France get > motivation to collect more addresses for the osm database itself, if > anything is available in BANO already? > > Nominatim as well as the maps presented by the project on osm.org IMHO > should show the strengths of OSM, and not lie about it by presenting > stuff that's not part of OSM (like addresses from different databases). > > regards > Peter > > P.S: Of course this is not meant to deal with the software as such, but > for the installations/instances "officially" part of OSM. Feel free to > set up an BANO nominatim server to show the strength of BANO instead. > > > Am 24.05.2014 11:57, schrieb Christian Quest: >> I'm happy to announce that we have finished our first building phase of the >> BANO (Base d'Adresses Nationale Ouverte) the first french adresses dataset >> available under an open license (ODbL). >> >> It contains data from: >> - OSM >> - available opendata datasets >> - automatically collected cadastre data >> >> The first experimental dataset are available for download at >> http://bano.openstreetmap.fr/data/ as: >> - shapefiles >> - csv files >> - github projet based on the csv files (this allows to have diff and >> archives of all versions) on https://github.com/osm-fr/bano-data >> >> This dataset has even been published on our national opendata portal: >> https://www.data.gouv.fr/dataset/base-d-adresses-nationale-ouverte-bano >> >> The global database contains around 17M addresses, and the current output >> dataset is around 12M addresses. >> >> It would be really great if this dataset could be added to Nominatim to >> extend its geocoding capabilities in France where we only have around 2M >> addresses currently. >> >> We're not pushing the community to import these data in OSM, but to fill >> the holes in street names first. >> >> >> >> _______________________________________________ >> talk mailing list >> [email protected] >> https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk >> > > > _______________________________________________ > talk mailing list > [email protected] > https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk >
signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature
_______________________________________________ talk mailing list [email protected] https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk

