Michael Reichert wrote: > You are aware that the RFC phase has to bee at least two weeks long?
Thanks for reminding that, I indeed think I was too hasty. There are still some unresolved questions, like the one about interchanges (see tagging@). > Why does your validator find lots of errors on the S-Bahn relations in > Berlin? I don't understand what's wrong with: > > > stop node 1806004219 is not connected to a station in route (relation 14981, > "S-Bahnlinie S41: Innenring im Uhrzeigersinn") > > The stop node is on a way referenced by the route relation. That was a bug in the validator: it did not consider stations with railway=halt. I have fixed it just now. > PS I am working on a Public Transport version 2 validator, too. > > https://github.com/geofabrik/osmi_pubtrans3 Awesome, the more validators the better. I check only metro systems, which are harder to map properly than other public transport route types. alan_gr wrote: > I'm not clear how it is decided which systems are included and which aren't. > In Spain, why is Bilbao in while Valencia, Seville, Malaga are out? I can't > see a difference in how the last three are tagged in OSM compared to Bilbao. Thanks Alan for pointing out the missing systems. I used a list from a wikipedia page, and it didn't include light rail networks. I have found the second list, and will add these later. Ilya _______________________________________________ talk mailing list talk@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk
