Currently, Tuscany does not generate any error for both cases (marked as "Error"). I will open a Jira to log this down as Mike suggested
Gilbert On Mon, Jun 2, 2008 at 1:09 PM, ant elder <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > I think right now our binding.ws services (or Axis2 services) will work with > either SOAP 1.1 or 1.2, and the response from the service will use the same > soap version as the request. Thats the default Axis2 behaviour, not sure if > its possible to change to restrict that. So right now the Tuscany code only > uses the soap intent for references. So those two marked as "Error" below > will actually just work with the current Tuscany code. > > ...ant > > On Mon, Jun 2, 2008 at 5:01 PM, Gilbert Kwan <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > >> The following table shows all combinations: >> >> Service Require vs Reference Require: >> ============================ >> None vs None: OK >> None vs soap: OK >> None vs soap.1_1: OK >> None vs soap.1_2: OK >> soap vs None: OK >> soap vs soap: OK >> soap vs soap.1_1: OK >> soap vs soap.1_2: OK >> soap.1_1 vs None: OK >> soap.1_1 vs soap: OK >> soap.1_1 vs soap.1_1: OK >> soap.1_1 vs soap.1_2: Error >> soap.1_2 vs None: OK >> soap.1_2 vs soap: OK >> soap.1_2 vs soap.1_1: Error >> soap.1_2 vs soap.1_2: OK >> >> I guess there are only 2 scenarios should generate error. Right? >> >> Thanks >> Gilbert >> >> >> >> >> On Mon, Jun 2, 2008 at 6:17 AM, Mike Edwards >> <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: >> > Gilbert Kwan wrote: >> >> >> >> I defined a service requires soap.1_2 >> >> >> >> <component name="BComponentSOAP12"> >> >> <implementation.java class="....BServiceSOAP12Impl"/> >> >> <service name="BServiceSOAP12"> >> >> <interface.java interface="....BServiceSOAP12"/> >> >> <binding.ws requires="soap.1_2"/> >> >> </service> >> >> </component> >> >> >> >> and a reference by ws binding which requires soap.1_1 >> >> >> >> <component name="AComponent15"> >> >> <implementation.java class="....AServiceImpl"/> >> >> <reference name="b1" target="BComponentSOAP12/BServiceSOAP12"> >> >> <interface.java interface="..BServiceSOAP12"/> >> >> <binding.ws requires="soap.1_1" >> >> uri="http://localhost:8080/BComponentSOAP12"/> >> >> </reference> >> >> </component> >> >> >> >> I got no warning, error message, or exception. Is it fine? >> >> What is the proper behaviour of this scenario? >> >> >> >> Thanks >> >> Gilbert >> >> >> > Gilbert, >> > >> > That looks like an error to me. Both sides need to be using the same >> SOAP >> > level. >> > >> > Looks like a failure of the policy matching between the two ends - I >> suggest >> > raising a JIRA for this one. >> > >> > >> > Yours, Mike. >> > >> >
