Goo'day,

At 10:17 18/04/04, Will replied to:

In a message dated 4/17/2004 4:16:06 PM Pacific Daylight Time,
[EMAIL PROTECTED] writes:


> A key factor that makes CUI non-portable > to GUI is the embedded Input and Print statements in the code.

I respectfully disagree that this is key.

Aren't we forgetting what Ross (and others) offer in Visage (and whatever)? AFIK, "Visage" offers users a GUI in a TOTAL WINDOWS LOOK AND FEEL/BROWSER environment, without having to do a "total rewrite", but a "rewrite" none the less, re-using some portions, perhaps, of existing code. "Visage" seems to be more than a user interface. It's also supposedly (sorry, Ross, I've got no experience in "Visage") a much less involved NEW development environment....


Other MV so-called "GUI" approaches, (AccuTerm and wIntegrate scripts, for example) are offering the user a GUI with an almost-modern Windows look and feel, but without the bells and whistles, and are offering a GUI by applying Band-Aids to existing code. I really don't think that's a "development environment". I don't think "new development" is covered by this approach.

If we were all developing "new" applications, and we could afford it, I reckon we would all jump at "Visage"... Or some such.

I'd hazard a guess that the cost of "new" development in "Visage", together with the cost of "Visage", would come out less (Ross??) than the cost of the same level of development to the same level of "total" user interface in our known MV Terminal Emulation environs. The per-user outgoing cost of a MV TE capable of supporting the TE scripts (as opposed to the cost of IE6!!) is, IMHO, the crippling factor, here. Especially in the larger sites where everybody would be forced into using the "GUI-able" TE instead of the lower-cost/freebie ones.

What we're all (all of us software developers, that is) trying to do is maintain a "public acceptance" for our EXISTING software. Sales = Public Acceptance. Ross is out in front with "Visage", right up there with "Windows products", because he's been able to absorb the costs of development over a period of time, developing "Visage" and developing/redeveloping his applications using it as he goes. OK, he's paid more for his version of "Visage" but he got his version earlier than the rest of us; he and his people have far more experience with it than the rest of us; it was written for their express requirements; they know what its' capabilities are; they know its' shortcomings; they know what's planned for its' future, and he's selling licences to it to help in recovering his outlay. Most of the rest of us are looking at it, at its cost, at the cost of "redeveloping" using it, and going with it, or hoping that the lower initial outlay of providing TE scripts will suffice, or ......

At our level of the market, a Windows-driven "shareware" TE such as NetTerm - which offers "mouse awareness"and "hot-spots" (a "constant mouse position" for "Y" or "N" outside the TE "screen", etc) amongst other useable things, coupled with a "lightly-rewritten" development (basically now offering "lists" of acceptable input for user acceptance, where applicable - reducing the "guess work") of our existing applications to provide a "mouse aware" "shrink-wrapped" version in direct competition to the MYOBs,"Business Manager", Quicken's, etc, (5 to 20 users) at those sort of costs, is where we perceive our future. We don't want to sell millions of seats, but, rather, provide a "quality" "easy to use" "easy to understand" product that we can support from wherever we choose to be - and make a quid! OK, we don't have the banks clamouring to provide or accept detail in our "native" file format, but they *do* provide and accept .csv and .txt formats, and we have OPENSEQ with READSEQ/WRITESEQ in our quiver, so we're competitive....

Our biggest problem in the market is the discipline we insist on at input. Not the sequence of input, mind you, but not allowing users to "short cut", or ignore proper "audit" procedures..... After all, we're throwing ourselves squarely at the "Mums and Dads" "I only want to do......" commercial market.... If we can just convince a few of them that they can use the mouse to "point at" a selection, or use "arrow" keys to transverse a list of options, or even, at worst, use a keyboard to enter something (remapping <Tab> as <Enter> has helped!!), and that there is some discipline involved .......

With the ..SEQs we also offer the ability to import/export data to/from the MV database. So, any "office product", for example, Excel or Word or, God forbid, MS Access can be used as a front/back end. (I appreciate the subject is/was "Crystal Reports" but, frankly, I've never been asked for anything other than Excel, Word or MS Access interaction, except, years ago, Lotus....). Is it a major problem to write to a file and get your "office product" to pick up and convert that file, compared to "direct integration"? We don't think so .... and nor do our customers, especially when "cost of ownership" comes into the equation (I'd dearly love to have a "vertical product" designed for government departments! <g>).

After all event oriented apps also have input statements

Our "event orientation" is offering selections, "up and back" in a fixed sequence, with an ability at the end, of going "back" to any prompt for re-entry, with full validation at the point of entry. We find this overcomes having to "go back" and fill in the forgotten bits or "repair" the incorrect bits!! Our experience has shown that the current market's ("event driven") approach is a "non-event" in getting customer/operator approval of the product.....


I firmly believe if you can offer a "modern" looking SOLUTION to a propect's REQUIREMENTS, together with proper SUPPORT for your product (the degree of "modern-ness" being a moot point...), all other factors being equal, you'll sell enough to survive.....



I think you mean the key factor is that the programs are not event oriented.
That is, on a typical GUI form I can click and fill in any field in any
order, and then I submit the entire form. In a typical mv app, most programmers
would write it so the inputs happen in a definite order and there is no way to
change that order, on the fly.



Will -- u2-users mailing list [EMAIL PROTECTED] http://www.oliver.com/mailman/listinfo/u2-users



--
Incoming mail is certified Virus Free.
Checked by AVG Anti-Virus (http://www.grisoft.com).
Version: 7.0.230 / Virus Database: 262.8.3 - Release Date: 15/04/04

Regards,


Bruce Nichol
Talon Computer Services
ALBURY        NSW     2640
Australia

Tel: +61 (0)411149636
Fax: +61 (0)260232119

If it ain't broke, fix it till it is!


-- Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free. Checked by AVG Anti-Virus (http://www.grisoft.com). Version: 7.0.230 / Virus Database: 262.8.3 - Release Date: 15/04/04


-- u2-users mailing list [EMAIL PROTECTED] http://www.oliver.com/mailman/listinfo/u2-users

Reply via email to