Hi,

>>>> http://www.sdsc.edu/~jeff/spam/cbc.html
[...]

> Setup a blacklist blocking ANY ip and you are ranked #1 in this test.
> Its of no use at all IMHO.

Yes, certainly, and I guess it was a loaded question of me to ask,
because it was almost too obvious that I thought I was missing
something. I don't think it's _completely_ useless though, because the
two leaders are for the most part reputable and don't just block ANY
IP.

Raymond, I remember your name from reading at surbl.org (actually, you
must go to www.surbl.org, heh). Is this the list you recommend?

I somewhat agree with the comment about barracuda being accountable,
but mxtools is apparently running the business side of things at
SURBL, and for large systems you need to pay, so I would assume they
want you to come back to renew.

I'm sure searching could probably eventually find something, but does
anyone know or have links that show the surbl and barracuda motivation
behind their service? Of course it is to block spam, but what does
barracuda expect to gain by making it free, for example, where surbl
charges for theirs? They simply hope people will contribute back to it
to make it better for their appliance customers?

An occasional FP is almost equally as subjective as anything else, and
a difficult metric in which to place any comparison value.

Would a more detailed and thorough comparison be any use? IOW, number
of changes per day, how many total entries, etc, or is everyone okay
with how it is currently?

Thanks,
Alex

Reply via email to