Hi Guillaume, Globally I like it.
Some comments: 1) Link menu item: * How do we add a link to an email address? * How do we add a link to a generic URI? * How do we add an interwiki link? I think all these can be answered by providing a "Custom Link..." item in the drop down menu to let users enter whatever format they want. It would have 3 fields: - label - reference (this is the free form) - target 2) Insert menu item: * I don't like the "Insert TOC" too much since the TOC is a macro like other macros. BTW this is true for the table too but here I agree that table should be in this menu... which means BTW that for the implementation we need to filter out the table from the macro list... 3) Macro menu item: * Can categories be more than 1 level deep? * Can a macro be in more than 1 category? Note: This means that in the Macro descriptor implementation we need to add the notation of category which we don't currently have (we have macro description and parameters description). 4) Import menu item: * You didn't show the submenu items 5) Link Dialog Box - Browse tab * It's missing the ability to link to a subwiki (i.e. the wiki filter) 6) Link Dialog Box - Search tab * Again missing multiwiki * What if put the name of an attachment. How do I create a link to it from the search dialog box? 7) Link Dialog Box - Recently Modified * By everyone or by me only or both? 8) Link to a web page * Wrong dialog box.... 9) Link to a new page * What about a link to a page in another wiki? * New page title --> New page name. This is not the title! BTW In English there's no space before ":" 10) Link Settings * Not sure I like the fact that you can set tooltip/etc when creating the link. I'm not sure on this. Stopping here for now... need top lay with the kids a bit... Thanks -Vincent On Aug 21, 2008, at 7:06 PM, Guillaume Lerouge wrote: > Hi fellow XWiki users, > I've spent the last couple weeks working on designing mockups for > the new > version of the WYSIWYG editor that's currently in the works. > > I've put all my work on this page : > http://dev.xwiki.org/xwiki/bin/view/Design/NewWysiwygEditorInterface > > and I'd be glad to gather initial user feedback on these mockups. > Please > tell us what you think about them now so that we can improve the > screens > before implementation begins at full speed. > > Specifically, I'm wondering about the following things : > > - Can the text be improved to make things easier to understand ? > If so, > where ? > - Are some features harder to reach than they should ? > - Are dialog boxes & trays consistent with user models of how > edition > software usually behaves ? > - Do you see anything that will make an user wonder what's > happening and > where he / she should click next ? > > Please note that the colors are only indicative at this stage - a > designer > will improve my work before we get to the final stage. I'll try > incorporate > your feedback soon and will let you know how the subseuent > development goes. > > Thanks in advance, > > Guillaume > > -- > Guillaume Lerouge > Product Manager - XWiki > Skype ID : wikibc > http://blog.xwiki.com/ _______________________________________________ users mailing list users@xwiki.org http://lists.xwiki.org/mailman/listinfo/users
