Jed said:"That is the wrong way to evaluate it. Look at energy, not power. The energy output is 2 to 3 times input, measured in the water alone.
The power of the 20 W pulse is irrelevant. You could probably improve the insulation and make it a smaller pulse with less power and less energy." I realize that this is what you believe, but all the graphs, simulation runs, etc. suggest that this may not be correct. I can change the wording so that it becomes the total output energy is only 40% greater than the input energy. That is what I see in the simulation results. How do you explain the fact that the temperature in the vicinity of the palladium wire drops very quickly after the pulse? There are many different measurements that prove to me that the excess power pulse is in sync with the heating pulse and not much beyond that time frame. For example, why use more than 1 pulse if that is all it takes to start a long term reaction? And, what does the large sharp transient that occurs as a result of the drive pulse mean? When the pump dies, why does the temperature of the water drop so quickly? I could point out many other bits of supporting evidence. There is no clear evidence that I have seen in support of the contention that the LENR heat continues to be generated throughout the entire time frame. I can explain from your graphs the exact reason for the peak temperature point that you are using to estimate the energy stored within the thermal capacity. The same reason causes the upward kink in the water temperature that is seen in the early morning hours. We apparently are not going to agree as long as you believe that the excess power is generated in a manner that can be assumed to mask the leakage power due to the pump. Once it is proven that the pump does not contribute power to the water, then I can entertain other possibilities such as your continuous power reaction concept. Gigi needs to connect his test pump to a 16 meter long 10 mm tubing of the same type as used in that test. Then we can measure the real amount of power leaked by that type of pump. Of course, plenty of information would be gained if Mizuno measures the flow rate in his test system by opening the tubing up and collecting the output water at the long open end. Is it possible for you to ask him how he determined that the water flow rate was 9 liters per minute? If he used a short piece of tubing I assume that is what he would have measured and the power loss would likely have been much lower due to the low pressure head. Until and unless additional data is obtained, it does not make sense to continue discussing this issue. Everything I see supports my position and apparently you are of the same opinion regarding yours. Lets wait for additional evidence from the pump vendor, etc. Until then I remain firm in the support of my simulation. Jed said:"It might also work with 10 W for a longer duration. I do not know whether this would work. Mizuno wants to stick with one standard power pulse so that he can compare results. He does not know whether this is the minimum effective pulse size. He has not tried a smaller one as far as I know. This may be much bigger than you need to trigger a reaction." The real question is exactly what type of reaction is being triggered? I find it easier to believe that the hot gas picks up energy from the heating and reacts when hot. That way the energy pulse follows the heating pulse and becomes nearly synchronized in time. That is how my model is set up and it matches the time domain response very well. On the other hand I am inserting a component that corresponds to pump power leakage which is close to the value that Gigi determined. If the excess energy is continuous over a very long time frame(many hours), it would act much like the pump contribution. We really need to get to the bottom of the pump behavior to answer these questions in a manner that everyone can accept. Dave

