David Roberson <[email protected]> wrote:

> If you have a method of determining the actual shape in time of the energy
> being released by the active LENR wire please give me that information.   I
> can not imagine it being only 3 watts instantaneous as you seem to be
> implying.


As far as I can tell it is. It is hard to separate out the spike from the
pulse and the anomalous heat but I do not see any indication that the
anomalous heat is much higher at one point than another. It gradually fades
away at the end. As I said in the report, you cannot tell when exactly it
stops; you can only see that losses exceed anomalous heat sometime in the
evening.

When you download the spreadsheets you have as much information as I do.



>   That would suggest that the same number of joules in each second are
> constantly being generated throughout the pulse repetition period.  I would
> certainly think that as the structure cools down, less heat is generated.


There is no anomalous heat effect proportional to input power. If it were
proportional, I would suspect an instrument artifact. Cold fusion does not
work like that. It is triggered by some sort of stimulation -- such as heat
or laser light -- and then it goes off on its own, at its own pace, at a
power level completely unrelated to the stimulus power.



>   And, if past experience is a guide then the rate of production falls off
> very quickly as the temperature drops.
>

I do not think so. Pd-D systems producing heat after death continue for a
long time as they cool down.



> To recap, I am currently using your data from Oct. 21, 2014 to model the
> amount of heat generated by Mizuno's device during that day.


The spreadsheet shows temperature changes every 24.4 seconds. There is a
large lag between the water temperature and the reactor body temperature,
and on the scale of individual readings there is a lot of noise. Despite
these problems, you can derive power in watts by multiplying the
temperature difference from one reading to the previous one, and
multiplying that number by 4.12 (conversion factor) * 4000 g (of water) /
24.4 s. This results is extremely noisy so I suggest you data smooth it
with the spreadsheet function, making it an average over several minutes.
You will see that it never gets anywhere near 40 W, and most of the time it
is far lower than 4 W -- which you think is the pump input power. As I
said, I cannot imagine where you got that number.

As I have often pointed out, the heat from the pump has already driven the
system up by 0.6 deg C after the first 90 minutes, and can drive it no
higher. So you will not see any sign of the pump in the minute-to-minute
changes after that. When there is only the pump running and ambient is
stable, the Delta T change over 24 s is zero, and the Delta T change over
24 minutes is zero, and if ambient were stable then you would find that
over 24 hours, days or weeks it is . . . zero, exactly. This is dead
obvious from the data. Why Gigi does not understand it I cannot say. He
clearly does not understand calorimetry. If you think you are detecting 4 W
from the pump -- or 4 W from anything for that matter -- you do not
understand this either.

If you do not data smooth the segments you will find huge power changes, up
100 W in one reading and down 80 W in the next. This is noise. It is caused
by the instrument electronics and by water swirling around in the tank. You
can simulate it at home with a thermocouple in a pot of water over a stove,
for example.

I averaged out power over 10 segments of 24 s each, graphed that, and then
computed total energy from those instantaneous power measurements. The
answer is about the same as taking energy from the total change in
temperature for the whole day, which is the method I use. The second
answer, from the 10-segment average power, is slightly higher. It is
probably more accurate, because it captures heat before the heat "leaks"
from the reactor. The difference is minor because the insulation is good
and the temperature difference from ambient is small.

- Jed

Reply via email to