Imagine how far a person can go with the support of crowd sourced enabling and excuse making. ;)
On Wed, Apr 13, 2016 at 11:29 AM a.ashfield <a.ashfi...@verizon.net> wrote: > Jed, > > My reading of IH's statement is quite different. I don't recall them > saying there was no heat. They said THEY could not duplicate Rossi's > results. That is not the same thing. > > There has been quite a lot of speculation that the dispute is really about > whether they have received sufficient know how from Rossi to make E-Cats > that run with a high COP for a long time. Not that the 1 MW plant does not > work. IH did not SAY that it didn't. As far as we know the ERV report > said that it did work. > > Jed wrote. > > I do not know if there is another complete report, but I do know that the >> I.H. observer disagrees with the Penon report, for good reasons." >> >> Earlier I thought you wrote that Penon was incompetent and the report >> valueless > > > I think he is incompetent based on his 2012 report, as I said. I.H. says > they disagree with the report. They say there is no heat. That makes the > report valueless. I trust I.H.'s expertise in calorimetry more than I trust > Penon's. > > > >> Now you say the report damns Rossi. >> > > That's what I.H. says, not me. They say there is no heat. That damns the > report. > > > >> Earlier you wrote there were two ERV's. Now it seems there is only one. >> > > I think there are three people involved, Penon, Barry West and Fulvio > Fabiani. That is my reading of the legal paper that Eric Walker kindly dug > up. I do not know who is responsible for what, or how many reports were > written, but in any case, I am sure that I.H. strongly disagrees with the > Penon report. They made that clear in the press release and in additional > comments to me. I hope the details will all be published eventually, but I > cannot say when that might happen. > > > >> Rossi stated that he wanted to release the report but had not on his >> attorney;s advice. How dO you know better? >> > > I cannot discuss that now. I hope I can later today. Sorry to be > mysterious, but I really do hope I can say something definitive about that > topic soon. The rest, including the report, may remain shrouded in mystery. > > - Jed > > >
