At 02:36 PM 7/17/2009, you wrote:
I referred to Piantelli the other day. It turns out I have no papers by
him at LENR-CANR.org. There are several by his co-author Focardi, such as:
Focardi, S., et al., Large excess heat production in Ni-H systems. Nuovo
Cimento Soc. Ital. Fis. A, 1998. 111A: p. 1233.
http://lenr-canr.org/acrobat/FocardiSlargeexces.pdf
I think Piantelli is the leader of the group.
I have not heard if they responded to the critique by Cerron-Zeballos et al.
Cerron-Zeballos did a careful, year-long attempt to replicate, as you see
in the paper. As far as I can tell, they disproved the Focardi claims. I
with that more cold fusion experiments were replicated with this kind of care.
- Jed
Jed,
The Cerron-Zeballos work was not only incompetent, but
disingenuous: http://www.newenergytimes.com/v2/news/2008/NET29-8dd54geg.shtml
I find it incredulous that someone with your experience in science would
even suggest that any negative result might "disprove" another's claim. You
can explain and defend what you initially wrote on 7/17 any way you want.
But to me, your 7/17 message ("disproved," "kind of care") is
indistinguishable from spin.
Do you remember the phrase "Negative results can be obtained without skill
and experience"? (Bockris). Not only am I surprised that you appear to be
ignorant of my investigation, I am also surprised that you did not see
Britz's review of the Focardi-Piantelli response. I am also surprised that
you did not read (or appear to know about) the rebuttal paper in my library.
*************************************
Here is an excerpt from my investigation (Source:
http://www.newenergytimes.com/v2/news/2008/NET29-8dd54geg.shtml )
Piantelli-Focardi Group Responds to CERN
In November 1998, the Piantelli-Focardi group published "Large Excess Heat
Production in Ni-H Systems,"[14] again in Il Nuovo Cimento. The paper
directly responds to the most significant criticism of the 1996 CERN paper.
In the Piantelli-Focardi authors' introduction to their new paper, they
state that they modified the cell they reported in 1994 [3] with "an
improvement which allows the measurement and the monitoring of the external
surface temperature."
"With this new set-up," the Piantelli-Focardi group writes, "the external
temperature increase, together with the internal one, have been utilized to
characterize the excited state of the Ni sample. The existence of an
exothermic effect, whose heat yield is well above that of any known
chemical reaction, has been unambiguously confirmed by evaluating the
thermal flux coming from the cells."
*************************************
I also note that it is interesting that - coincidentally - there has been
other recent interest in the Piantelli work by some people in the LENR
field ever since ACS in March this year. Something is going on behind the
scenes and I don't know what it is. Carsten Steenberg, an associate of
Peter Hagelstein contacted me several weeks ago asking me to connect him
with Piantelli. Bob Huggins, a colleague of McKubre contacted me just a few
days ago for the same purpose.
I can understand that my article
"<http://www.newenergytimes.com/v2/news/2008/NET29-8dd54geg.shtml#dpnr>Deuterium
and Palladium Not Required" was a big problem for certain people in the
field who have been saying for many years that it's all (exclusively) about
Pd/D. Now you, Jed, are spreading ignorance and disinformation about the
Piantelli-Focardi work and thus the Ni/H work?
To top it all off Jed, you just completed a full index of all the papers on
my site. Despite that, you are ignorant of the response paper by Focardi et al?
Focardi, S., Gabbani, V., Montalbano, V., Piantelli, F. and Veronesi, S.,
"<http://www.newenergytimes.com/v2/library/1998/1998FocardiS-LargeExcessHeatProductionNiH.pdf>Large
Excess Heat Production in Ni-H Systems," Nuovo Cimento, Vol. 111A, p.
1233-1242, (1998)
How is it that you - somehow - learned about the Cerron-Zeballos paper but
not the response by Focardi et al?
Is it true that you wish that "more cold fusion experiments were replicated
with this kind of care"?
What gives Jed?
Steve