SK: The Cerron-Zeballos work was not only incompetent, but disingenuous: http://www.newenergytimes.com/v2/news/2008/NET29-8dd54geg.shtml

I find it incredulous that someone with your experience in science would even suggest that any negative result might "disprove" another's claim. You can explain and defend what you initially wrote on 7/17 any way you want. But to me, your 7/17 message ("disproved," "kind of care") is indistinguishable from spin.

JR: The tone of this message is inappropriate. (Also, you find it "incredible," not "incredulous." You have no skeptical doubts that I wrote the message.)

Negative results often disprove other people's claims. As I mentioned, many claims have been disproved by showing that they are real but they have prosaic causes. In some cases the opposite occurs: a result that is considered prosaic is shown to be anomalous in a replication (or analysis). Lewis (CalTech) is a good example. The original data was correct but the interpretation of it was mistaken.

SK: Jed, I apologize if I was not gentle with you. Please forgive me for not taking your sensitivities into account.

And yes, I do find it incredulous; not that you didn't write the message, but that you would have such an apparent breach in your application of science philosophy. But let me be more precise. Yes, I agree that a claim can be disproved. But I disagree that negative *results* can disprove positive *results* - which is what we're talking about in the Piantelli-Focardi work.

Experimental disproof would require Cerron-Zeballos to have gone into the Piantelli-Focardi lab and determine exactly how Piantelli-Focardi goofed - or explicitly analyzed Piantelli-Focardi's data, assuming they made a mistake.

But armchair quarterbacking for science experiments is the hallmark of pathological skepticism. This is how Lewis and Myerhof made fools of themselves in 1989 when they assumed that FP failed to take into account the matter of thermal gradients across the cell.

Therefore, even if Piantelli-Focardi never responded, Cerron-Zeballos never disproved Piantelli-Focardi. The way I see it - (forgive me again for being so direct - no offense intended but I don't beat want to beat around the bush) but here we have one of the strongest excess heat results on record - and you are using the same fallacious logic as that used by pathological skeptics.


JR: This addresses the major doubt raised by Cerron-Zeballos. But I still don't feel much confidence in their calorimetry.

SK: Explain what your "feelings" have to do with the Piantelli-Focardi nickel hydrogen work.

JR: Before I posted that message I discussed it with others, and they don't feel much confidence either.

SK: If your advisors have any authority or credibility, name your advisors.

If your advisors have scientific critique to explain why "they don't feel much confidence either," state their critique.

Steve

Reply via email to