Steven Krivit wrote:

Experimental disproof would require Cerron-Zeballos to have gone into the
> Piantelli-Focardi lab and determine exactly how Piantelli-Focardi goofed -
> or explicitly analyzed Piantelli-Focardi's data, assuming they made a
> mistake.
>

They did not need to do that any more than Miles needed to visit CalTech, or
than McKubre needed to visit the labs of the experiments that he
demonstrated were prosaic. All they have to do is get the same result and
show that it is not anomalous. That is what Cerron-Zeballos did with a gas
calorimeter, by putting a temperature probe on the outside as well as near
the Ni sample. The Ni got hot but the outside did not. That is proof that
with the initial configuration, the calorimetery did not work. Mizuno (with
proton conductors) and Biberian saw similar results with similar devices,
ranging from unconvincing to a definite null.

In the next round, Focardi used a more sophisticated calorimeter with more
thermocouples. That's good, but based on the performance of similar
calorimeters I would still prefer to see something like a Seebeck
calorimeter. Local hotspots and changes in conductivity still cannot be
ruled out. The temperature inversion shown in Fig. 4 is somewhat more
convincing. However, Mizuno's hydrogenation experiments also showed an
inversion yet at the same time *no excess heat* by the calibration and other
methods. I conclude that these devices are tricky and difficult to believe.
As I said at the outset, given all of the money that went into Focardi et
al. I cannot understand why they did not employ a more robust, believable
and accurate method of calorimetry.



> Therefore, *even if Piantelli-Focardi never responded*, Cerron-Zeballos
> never disproved Piantelli-Focardi.
>

Cerron-Zeballos got the same results with the same configuration and
demonstrated that the calorimetery was wrong! What more do you want? This is
like saying that Miles never disproved Lewis, or that Fleischmann never
proved that the liquid cells in other people's labs are well mixed by
dropping dye into his own cell. All cells of the same shape and description
with similar power levels operate in similar ways. If one is well mixed,
they all are. If you can show that Mizuno and Cerron-Zeballos got a null
result that would be mistaken for excess heat by Focardi, then you have
effectively disproved Focardi . . . unless it can be shown that the
improvements in the next round really address the problem. I am not sure
they do.



> The way I see it - (forgive me again for being so direct - no offense
> intended  but I don't beat want to beat around the bush) but here we have
> one of the strongest excess heat results on record - and you are using the
> same fallacious logic as that used by pathological skeptics.
>

This is not a strong result because it has not been independently replicated
yet, and because this kind of gas calorimetry is questionable.

You should never get excited about a result until it is independently
replicated, and in this case until it is tested with some sort of envelope
calorimeter (flow or Seebeck) that captures all heat from the cell, rather
than measuring temperatures at a few locations.

- Jed

Reply via email to