Steven Krivit wrote:

The Cerron-Zeballos work was not only incompetent, but disingenuous: http://www.newenergytimes.com/v2/news/2008/NET29-8dd54geg.shtml

I find it incredulous that someone with your experience in science would even suggest that any negative result might "disprove" another's claim. You can explain and defend what you initially wrote on 7/17 any way you want. But to me, your 7/17 message ("disproved," "kind of care") is indistinguishable from spin.

The tone of this message is inappropriate. (Also, you find it "incredible," not "incredulous." You have no skeptical doubts that I wrote the message.)

Negative results often disprove other people's claims. As I mentioned, many claims have been disproved by showing that they are real but they have prosaic causes. In some cases the opposite occurs: a result that is considered prosaic is shown to be anomalous in a replication (or analysis). Lewis (CalTech) is a good example. The original data was correct but the interpretation of it was mistaken.


Not only am I surprised that you appear to be ignorant of my investigation, I am also surprised that you did not see Britz's review of the Focardi-Piantelli response. I am also surprised that you did not read (or appear to know about) the rebuttal paper in my library.

Why are you so surprised that I overlooked these things? Do you think I am omniscient? I suggest in future you should simply point this sort of thing out without the histrionics, and supply a hyperlink.


In the Piantelli-Focardi authors' introduction to their new paper, they state that they modified the cell they reported in 1994 [3] with "an improvement which allows the measurement and the monitoring of the external surface temperature."

This addresses the major doubt raised by Cerron-Zeballos. But I still don't feel much confidence in their calorimetry. Before I posted that message I discussed it with others, and they don't feel much confidence either. I also reviewed the Mizuno data, which shows large effects similar to what they report, all of them prosaic.


To top it all off Jed, you just completed a full index of all the papers on my site. Despite that, you are ignorant of the response paper by Focardi et al?

Yes, obviously I overlooked this. I have this paper at LENR-CANR as well, but I have not read it in many years.


How is it that you - somehow - learned about the Cerron-Zeballos paper but not the response by Focardi et al?

I learned about both back when they were written. I have copies of both. As I mentioned, my copy of Cerron-Zeballos was of poor quality so I never scanned it or uploaded it. The Focardi paper is a binary copy from the publisher.

- Jed

Reply via email to